Spin Dependence of Meson Thresholds in the Diabatic Dynamical Diquark Model
Richard F. Lebed · 2025
Read Spin Dependence of Meson Thresholds in the Diabatic Dynamical Diquark Model by Richard F. Lebed (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-05368.txt.
Introduction
Richard Lebed works in 2025 on a theory model for exotic particles made of four quarks. The model tries to unite two older pictures: one where quarks bind in tight pairs, and one where whole mesons loosely pair up. Adding the pull of meson pair thresholds turns the basic four-quark states into the physical particles seen in labs.
Lebed extends the model by adding the effects of heavy-quark spin symmetry for each meson pair. That step brings in the spin factors and mass gaps between related mesons, such as the D and its starred partner. He works out clear interaction formulas for all states with spin zero, one, and two. Along the way he derives unusual forms of a known reordering identity. The paper closes by pointing the formulas at named particles that labs have already observed.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Richard F. Lebed |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 107 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-05368
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Spin Dependence of Meson Thresholds in the Diabatic Dynamical Diquark Model Richard F. Lebed Abstract The diabatic dynamical diquark model is designed to unify diquark and molecular approaches for exotic hadrons, by including the effects of di-meson thresholds on fundamental diquark-antidiquark states in order to form physical tetraquarks. We generalize this model by implementing the consequences of heavy-quark spin symmetry for each di-meson pair. We include the specific spin factors and mass differences associated with mesons related by this symmetry (such as D , D ∗ D,D^{*} ), both features being necessary for the systematic incorporation of effects beyond the static, heavy-source limit inherent to the (adiabatic) Born-Oppenheimer treatment. We obtain explicit interaction potentials for all J = 0 , 1 , 2 J=0,1,2 states, along the way deriving unusual variants of Fierz reordering identities, and discuss the application of the potentials to specific physical states such as χ c 1 ( 3872 ) \chi_{c1}(3872) and T c c ¯ 1 ( 3900 ) T_{c\bar{c}1}(3900) . I Introduction The pace of discovery in the field of heavy-quark exotic hadrons [ i.e. , any hadron containing a significant component that is neither a valence quark-antiquark pair q\bar{q} nor a quark (or antiquark) trio qqq ] over the past two decades has been nothing less than breathtaking. As late as the early 2000s, one could still argue that some unknown dynamical mechanism of QCD restricts all clearly observable physical hadronic states to appear solely in conventional q\bar{q} and qqq configurations. Just over two decades later, at least 70 heavy-quark ( c,b ) states that are not easily explained as conventional hadrons have been observed Navas et al. 2024 , spread over several flavor sectors: hidden-charm (both nonstrange and strange, both tetraquarks and pentaquarks), hidden-bottom, and double open-charm. A particularly interesting property of the exotic candidates is that many of them lie close, sometimes extraordinarily so, to di-hadron thresholds, suggesting a substantial role for the di-hadron state as a constituent in the structure of the full exotic hadron. The most spectacular example of this phenomenon is perhaps the first heavy-quark exotic candidate discovered, \chi_{c1}(3872) . Using the latest mass measurements Navas et al. 2024 , m_{\chi_{c1}(3872)}-m_{D^{0}}-m_{D^{*0}}=-0.05\pm 0.09\ {\rm MeV}\,, (1) implying that the di-meson state D^{0}\bar{D}^{*0} (understood to include its charge conjugate) is undoubtedly a prominent component of \chi_{c1}(3872) . And yet, multiple heavy-quark exotic candidates lie many MeV from plausible constituent di-hadron thresholds, such as the charmoniumlike J^{PC}\!=\!1^{--} states in excess of conventional c\bar{c} states \psi [ e.g. , \psi(4230) , previously Y(4230) ], and the \pi^{+}\!\psi(2S) resonance T_{c\bar{c}1}(4430)^{+} [previously Z_{c}(4430) ]. In such cases, a diquark-antidiquark ( \delta^{\vphantom{1}}{\bar{\delta}} ) structure can provide an alternative paradigm for explaining the existence of a spectrum of isolated tetraquark states. Typical diquark models suffer a significant drawback by not explaining why a \delta^{\vphantom{1}}{\bar{\delta}} structure should be favored over the (presumably more stable) bound di-hadron configuration. However, di-meson thresholds occupy only a fraction of the space of total energy values available to the 4-quark states, thus allowing substantial regions of energy in which \delta^{\vphantom{1}}{\bar{\delta}} structures are preferred. Moreover, even for energy values not far from such thresholds, the 4-quark state may form in a configuration in which the two quarks qq or the two antiquarks \bar{q}\bar{q} lie closer to each other than either of the q lies to either of the \bar{q} ; and since the short-distance attraction of a qq pair in its color- \bar{\bf 3} configuration is fully half as large as the corresponding q\bar{q} color- \bf 1 attraction, the qq and \bar{q}\bar{q} attractions can produce a \delta_{\bf\bar{3}}{\bar{\delta}}^{\vphantom{+}}_{\bf 3} configuration that persists even in energy regions not far from di-meson thresholds. These observations form the essence of the dynamical diquark picture Brodsky et al. 2014 . It can also be extended to pentaquarks Lebed 2015 by noting that the aggregation of quarks through successive combination of color- 3 quarks allows one to model the pentaquark as a (qq)_{\bar{\bf 3}}[q_{\bf 3}(\bar{q}\bar{q})_{\bf 3}]_{\bf\bar{3}} (a diquark- triquark ) compound. This picture is elevated to the predictive dynamical diquark model Lebed 2017 in cases in which each diquark (or triquark) quasiparticle contains a heavy quark, hence allowing for the configuration to develop into that of two heavy, slow sources connected by a color flux tube, ideally suited for use in the Born-Oppenheimer (BO) approximation. The interaction provided by the flux tube is the \bf 3 - \bar{\bf 3} static potential calculated in multiple lattice-QCD simulations ( e.g. , Refs. Mor ; Capitani et al. 2019 ), typically to study the spectra of conventional and hybrid heavy-quark mesons. The dynamical diquark model has been thoroughly explored in a series of papers that present the results of numerical analysis in multiple flavor sectors and state configurations Giron et al. 2019 ; Giron et al. 2020 ; Giron and Lebed 2020a ; Giron and Lebed 2020b ; Giron and Lebed 2020c ; Giron et al. 2021 ; Giron and Lebed 2021 ; Jafarzade and Lebed 2025 , but relying (in these works) exclusively upon the adiabatic heavy-source limit inherent to the BO approximation. However, the composition of the physical mass eigenstate necessarily changes rapidly in the energy region near di-hadron thresholds; for example, the \delta^{\vphantom{1}}{\bar{\delta}} system with a mass near the D^{0}\bar{D}^{*0} threshold may form the kernel of the state that ultimately becomes \chi_{c1}(3872) , but the D^{0}\bar{D}^{*0} state dominates the composition of the physical \chi_{c1}(3872) state. This diabatic extension of the dynamical diquark model Lebed and Martinez 2022 ; Lebed and Martinez 2023 ; Lebed and Martinez 2024a ; Lebed and Martinez 2025 , which descibes the mechanism of this configuration mixing, is the formalism in which the calculations of this paper are performed; it is outlined in the next section. Detailed calculations performed thus far in the diabatic dynamical diquark model assume a universal interaction between the fundamental \delta^{\vphantom{1}}{\bar{\delta}} state and threshold di-meson pair. Of course, such interactions should also depend upon the spin and flavor quantum numbers of both the fundamental and the hadronic state. In the case of hadrons containing a heavy quark Q , couplings for states that differ only through the orientation of the spin of Q (such as D and D^{*} ) are related by heavy-quark spin symmetry (HQSS) Manohar and Wise 2000 . The diabatic mixing of conventional heavy quarkonium ( Q\bar{Q} ) states with (universal) di-meson thresholds was first described in Ref. Bruschini and González 2020 , and the effects obtained from imposing HQSS were derived in Ref. Bruschini 2023 . Our purpose is to extend this HQSS formalism to the mixing of di-meson thresholds with \delta^{\vphantom{1}}{\bar{\delta}} states. This derivation requires innovations such as the incorporation of states with larger spin eigenvalues and the generalization of the best-known Fierz reordering theorem for 4-fermion operators. As an illustration of the results, we present explicit expressions for diabatic couplings of the lowest well-known hidden-charm exotics: \chi_{c1}(3872) , T_{c\bar{c}1}(3900) [formerly Z_{c}(3900) ], and T_{c\bar{c}1}(4020) [formerly Z_{c}(4020) ]. Note that the latter two states have I\!=\!1 and thus cannot mix with conventional c\bar{c} states. This paper is structured as follows. In Sec. II we review the dynamical diquark model briefly in its original (adiabatic) form, and more thoroughly in its diabatic