Explaining ultra-massive quiescent galaxies at 3 < z < 5 3<z<5 in the context of their environments
Christian Kragh Jespersen, Adam C. Carnall, Christopher C. Lovell · 2025
Read Explaining ultra-massive quiescent galaxies at 3 < z < 5 3<z<5 in the context of their environments by Christian Kragh Jespersen, Adam C. Carnall, Christopher C. Lovell (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-05340.txt.
Introduction
Christian Jespersen, Adam Carnall, and Christopher Lovell ask if the zone near a star group can clear up a puzzle. The puzzle is huge star groups that quit star birth at a young age. Such groups at red shifts three to five look too huge and too still for stock birth models. The team notes that all of them sit in thick clumps of more groups.
They change a code for top end stats to count clump of groups. The read of each group is set on the zone it sits in. With that change, the huge still group set no more strains plain birth models in a grave way. The team puts out the changed code. Their point frames a seeming crunch as in part a pick effect of thick zones.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Christian Kragh Jespersen, Adam C. Carnall, Christopher C. Lovell |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 33 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-05340
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Explaining ultra-massive quiescent galaxies at 3 < z < 5 3<z<5 in the context of their environments Christian Kragh Jespersen, Adam C. Carnall, Christopher C. Lovell Abstract The swift assembly of the earliest galaxies poses a significant challenge to our understanding of galaxy formation. Ultra-massive quiescent galaxies at intermediate redshifts ( 3 < z < 5 3<z<5 ) currently present one of the most pressing problems for theoretical modeling, since very few mechanisms can be invoked to explain how such galaxies formed so early in the history of the Universe. Here, we exploit the fact that these galaxies all reside within significant overdensities to explain their masses. To this end, we construct and release a modified version of the Extreme Value Statistics (EVS) code which takes into account galaxy environment by incorporating clustering in the calculation. With this new version of EVS, we find that ultra-massive quiescent galaxies at 3 < z < 5 3<z<5 do not present as serious a tension with simple models of galaxy formation when the analysis of a given galaxy is conditioned on its environment. I Introduction The James Webb Space Telescope is currently pushing the limits of galaxy formation theory. The discoveries of not only ultra-high redshift galaxies, but also extremely massive quiescent galaxies at 3<z<5 , imply that a surprisingly large amount of star formation took place at very early times ( Carnall et al. 2023a ; Carnall et al. 2023b ; Valentino et al. 2023 ; Carniani et al. 2024 ; Glazebrook et al. 2024 ; de Graaff et al. 2025a , e.g.,) . Many possible explanations have been invoked post-hoc , including highly bursty star formation, changes to \Lambda CDM, and artificially elevated star-formation efficiencies ( Dekel et al. 2023 ; Lovell et al. 2023 ; Endsley et al. 2024 ) . While bursty star formation seems like a promising explanation for observations of ultra-high redshift galaxies ( Mason et al. 2023 ) , it is irrelevant for inferring the masses of quiescent galaxies. Quiescent galaxies therefore present a unique opportunity for isolating other effects. This has resulted in suggestions that star formation efficiencies (SFE) must either be close to 100%, or that modifications to the well-understood physics of halo formation would be necessary ( Carnall et al. 2024 ; Glazebrook et al. 2024 ) . However, previous analyses of early ultra-massive quiescent galaxies have so far ignored the well-known fact that low redshift and simulated massive quiescent galaxies reside in overdense environments ( Frenk et al. 1988 ; Norberg et al. 2002 ) , a relation which seems to continue even at high redshift, as massive quiescent galaxies observed with JWST appear to preferentially populate overdensities ( Valentino et al. 2023 ; Jin et al. 2024 ; Ito et al. 2024 ; Morishita et al. 2025 ) . For example, the broadly used Extreme Value Statistics (EVS) approach of Lovell et al. 2023 assumes that all galaxies exist in a perfectly average field with no clustering. Another approach, presented by Jespersen et al. 2025b , marginalizes over the environment, since the environments of ultra-high redshift galaxies are rarely known. However, at intermediate redshifts, we may obtain strong constraints on the type of overdensity in which ultra-massive quiescent galaxies reside ( Overzier 2016 ) . These overdense environments require corrections to EVS ( Davis et al. 2011 ) . Here, we therefore explicitly include the dependence on overdensity in the EVS calculation of the probability distribution for the mass of the most massive galaxy observed in a given survey volume. We apply our model to three ultra-massive quiescent galaxies discovered with JWST in the CANDELS UDS field. II Data Figure 1: Top: The 3D distribution of galaxies at 3<z<5 with spectroscopic redshifts within the PRIMER UDS area. Strong clustering is visible, with two prominent overdensities (marked in grey). The overdensities host ultra-massive galaxies (blue stars), which have been proposed to challenge galaxy formation models. Bottom: Further identification of possible concentrated and extended overdensities. Left: Two possible z\approx 4.62 volumes that could define the overdensity that PRIMER-EXCELS-109760/117560 exist in. The volumes are roughly 1.5 orders of magnitude apart. Right: Two possible z\approx 3.21 volumes that could define the overdensity that ZF-UDS-7329 exists in. The volumes are roughly an order of magnitude apart. In this work, we consider the objects discussed in Carnall et al. 2024 in the UDS field. They discuss three especially problematic galaxies: ZF-UDS-7329 at z =3.195 with log {}_{10}(M_{*}/\mathrm{M_{\odot}})\simeq 11.1 ( Schreiber et al. 2018 ; Nanayakkara et al. 2024 ; Glazebrook et al. 2024 ), PRIMER-EXCELS-109760 ( z=4.622 ), and PRIMER-EXCELS-117560 ( z=4.621 ), both with log {}_{10}(M_{*}/\mathrm{M_{\odot}})\simeq 11 and newly reported by Carnall et al. 2024 . The relatively involved EXCELS selections are detailed in §3 of Carnall et al. 2024 , with §3.2.1 being of particular importance to the selection of the main galaxies of interest here. To investigate the environments of these objects, we compile a list of available spectroscopic redshifts in the UDS field within the PRIMER survey area from 3<z<5 as follows. We begin with the EXCELS spectroscopic redshift catalogue presented in Carnall et al. 2024 . We then supplement this with the DJA NIRSpec graded v3 compilation ( Heintz et al. 2024 ; de Graaff et al. 2025b ) , using only redshifts with a grade of 3. We supplement these with the compilation of pre- JWST spectroscopic redshifts from Begley et al. 2025 . The resulting distribution of objects with reliable spectroscopic redshifts in the PRIMER UDS field from 3<z<5 is shown in Figure 1 , with the three objects discussed in Carnall et al. 2024 highlighted in blue. III Methods To calculate the mass of the most massive galaxy conditioned on density, a few steps must be taken. We quickly summarize these steps, and expand on them in the following subsections. 1. The volumes of the overdensities must be identified (see § III.1 ). 2. A mapping from the total possible number of such volumes in a given survey ( \mathrm{N_{\delta}} ) to a distribution of overdensities must be established. This is most easily done by estimating the density percentile ( \mathrm{u_{\delta}} ) of a given overdensity (see § III.2 ). 3. Stellar mass functions dependent on density percentile, SMF( \mathrm{u_{\delta}} ), must be constructed (see § III.3 and Figure 2 ). For each SMF( \mathrm{u_{\delta}} ), EVS can be used to estimate \mathrm{P(M_{max}|u_{\delta}}) . \mathrm{P(M_{max}|u_{\delta}}) can then be multiplied with P(\mathrm{u_{\delta}}|N_{\delta}) to give us the final estimate of \mathrm{P(M_{max}|N_{\delta}}) . III.1 Overdensity identification Visual inspection of Figure 1 indicates that the three galaxies of interest reside in overdensities. PRIMER-EXCELS-109760/117560 are close in mass and reside in the same overdensity. ZF-UDS-7329 is significantly more massive than other galaxies belonging to its overdensity. We fit the size of each overdensity by fitting a spheroidal volume. The spheroidal shape is motivated by theoretical work on clusters and protoclusters in large N-body simulations ( Lovell et al. 2018 ) . We determine the three major axes of each overdensity by considering the minimum volume enclosing ellipsoid (MVEE) for each overdensity. The volume is grown until there is a clear break in the number of galaxies included, which then defines our fiducial overdensity regions.