Partial Compositeness: from Anarchy to Symmetry
Kaustubh Agashe, Lorenzo Ricci, Raman Sundrum · 2025
Read Partial Compositeness: from Anarchy to Symmetry by Kaustubh Agashe, Lorenzo Ricci, Raman Sundrum (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-05332.txt.
Introduction
Kaustubh Agashe and co-authors blend two flavor stories for a composite Higgs in a 2025 paper. Partial compositeness can grow the wide spread of quark and lepton masses, but flavor tests push its scale far past collider reach. Flavor symmetric dynamics dodge those tests yet must fake the spread by hand.
Their blend lets flavor symmetry emerge only near the compositeness scale, not in the far past. Flow over long spans then builds the mass spread first, and a late stage settles into near flavor and CP symmetry. Small neutrino masses with large mixings fit that flow as well. Collider and low energy signs shift under the blend.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Kaustubh Agashe, Lorenzo Ricci, Raman Sundrum |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 74 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-05332
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Partial Compositeness: from Anarchy to Symmetry Kaustubh Agashe, Lorenzo Ricci, Raman Sundrum Abstract Within the Composite Higgs paradigm, Partial Compositeness has emerged as an elegant mechanism for generating large flavor hierarchies such as are observed in the quark and lepton masses and mixings. This mechanism exploits the strong renormalization group effects of the compositeness dynamics when these are not flavor-symmetric. Despite its remarkable properties, at this point it is stringently constrained by the body of flavor- and CP-violation tests, so that the compositeness scale must be at least O ( 100 ) O(100) TeV, beyond the direct reach of proposed colliders. On the other hand, Composite Higgs theories with flavor-symmetric strong dynamics, but with realistic flavor-violating hierarchies introduced in an ad hoc manner, can extend the GIM mechanism of the standard model and thereby be far less constrained, at the edge of LHC reach and well within reach of future colliders. We show how the best features of both these types of dynamics can be combined if flavor-symmetries of the strong composite dynamics are emergent in the IR near the compositeness scale but absent in the far UV. In this case, flavor hierarchies can be generated by the renormalization group flow in the UV, followed by an IR stage in which the dynamics flows towards accidental flavor and CP symmetries. We point out how the collider and low-energy phenomenology is significantly impacted by the IR stage. Our analysis includes a discussion of the distinctive features of the small neutrino masses and their large mixings. I Introduction The Standard Model’s (SM) Higgs mechanism and Higgs boson remain among its most enigmatic features and are the focus of intense experimental efforts to probe. Its couplings are central to the hierarchical structure of particle physics that we see, both in the sense of the Hierarchy Problem related to the scale of EW symmetry breaking, v\ll m_{\text{Planck}} , as well as the pattern of hierarchical quark and lepton masses and mixings. The Composite Higgs beyond-SM (BSM) paradigm offers one of the boldest proposals for addressing these mysteries (see, e.g., Panico and Wulzer 2016 for a review). The defining hypothesis is that the Higgs doublet is a composite of some as-yet unknown strongly-coupled constituents assembled at a scale \sim m_{*} . The Higgs is significantly lighter than m_{*} because it is a pseudo-Nambu-Goldstone Boson (pNGB) of the strong dynamics. If m_{*} is not too far above v , then this compositeness solves the bulk of the Hierarchy Problem. The new strong dynamics creating the Higgs then also offers the possibility of understanding how its hierarchical Yukawa couplings emerge. Experimentally, the generic manifestation of the new physics would be the appearance of other composite excitations, also carrying SM gauge charges, with masses \sim O(m_{*}) , which may well be within collider reach. Even for collider energies E<m_{*} , off-shell composites will mediate new non-renormalizably weak interactions which can be probed at colliders or, if combined with distinctive breaking of approximate SM symmetries, within low-energy precision tests. Partial Compositeness Kaplan 1991 is a generic and important possibility: the observed particle mass-eigenstates can be superpositions of elementary particles and composite particles, where the superposition is quantitatively determined by the strong dynamics renormalization group (RG) flow from the far UV. Phenomenologically, these superpositions determine the degree to which different mass eigenstates participate in the new interactions. Beyond these general considerations, such strongly-coupled BSM theories are hard to study or even formulate microscopically. However, we can take advantage of two powerful expansion parameters to develop provisional theories. One is the 1/N\ll 1 expansion familiar from QCD Coleman 1985 , where N is the number of colors, which can readily generalize to, and simplify, BSM strong dynamics by making the composites couple with typical strength g_{*}\sim 4\pi/\sqrt{N} , intermediate between SM couplings and maximal strong coupling 4\pi . Furthermore, the simplest robust form of strong dynamics is one which is approximately conformally (scale) invariant above m_{*} , governed in large part by the non-trivial scaling dimensions \Delta_{\mathcal{O}} of its primary composite operators \mathcal{O} . If only a finite subset of operators \mathcal{O} have \Delta_{\mathcal{O}}\leq\Delta_{gap} for some \Delta_{gap}\gg 1 , then we can also expand in 1/\Delta_{gap}\ll 1 . Remarkably, via AdS/CFT Duality, this expansion is given precisely by AdS 5 effective field theory (EFT) keeping only the finite set of 5D fields dual to this subset of operators (see, e.g., the discussion in Sundrum 2012 ). When the strong dynamics is coupled to external elementary particles/fields, the dual description is given by warped 5D EFTs of Randall-Sundrum I (RS1) type Randall and Sundrum 1999 (see, e.g., Sundrum 2005 ; Gherghetta 2011 for reviews). The fifth dimension is now an interval which roughly geometrizes and reflects the physics of the strong RG flow between a far UV scale \Lambda_{\text{UV}} and m_{*} Arkani-Hamed et al. 2001 ; Rattazzi and Zaffaroni 2001 . Partial compositeness is reflected in the extra-dimensional profiles of the lightest 4D modes of the 5D fields Contino et al. 2003 ; Contino and Pomarol 2004 ; Agashe et al. 2005a , and new strong interactions are modulated by the extra-dimensional overlap of the participating 4D particles Grossman and Neubert 2000 ; Gherghetta and Pomarol 2000 . Currently, the most explicit realistic modeling is formulated at the level of such non-renormalizable 5D RS1 EFTs. Anarchic Partial Compositeness (APC) is the simplest theoretically compelling realization of this dynamics, where “anarchy” refers to the minimal use of (approximate) symmetries. Here, SM fermion and gauge fields, each couple to different {\cal O} of the strong sector, whose scaling dimensions then determine the partial compositeness of the observed lightest states through the RG flow. For a “generic” spectrum of scaling dimensions the EFT <m_{*} has hierarchical structure qualitatively similar to that of the SM EFT we observe, and quantitatively can be fit to it. In this framework, the lightest mass eigenstates are correlated with having the smallest superposition with strong composites, so that they have the weakest new interactions in general. This greatly reduces sensitivity to the new physics within our most powerful experimental precision low-energy tests precisely because these apply to the lightest particles Gherghetta and Pomarol 2000 ; Huber and Shafi 2001 ; Huber 2003 ; Agashe et al. 2005b . 1 1 1 The standard Strong CP Problem associated with neutron EDM constraints is not mitigated in this way and requires a separate solution, such as the QCD axion mechanism with which partial compositeness is fully compatible. Consequently, most of the precision constraints are compatible with m_{*}\sim 10-50 TeV, at the boundary of plausible collider reach (see, e.g., Glioti et al. 2025 for updated bounds). But dramatic improvements of electron EDM measurements in the last decades provide one of the most powerful constraints on BSM CP-violation in general, and APC in particular, for which m_{*}> PeV, far above any contemplated collider reach! However, just mild use of leptonic symmetries of the strong dynamics relaxes the leptonic constraints back to m_{*}\sim 10-50 TeV Frigerio et al. 2018 . Fig. 1 sketches the form of the dual 5D warped EFT structure, in particular the distinctive profiles of the different species of light 4D modes. These are determined by the 5D masses, related to