First Robust Detection of Linear Polarization from Metric Solar Emissions: Challenging Established Paradigms
Soham Dey, Devojyoti Kansabanik, Divya Oberoi, Surajit Mondal · 2025
Read First Robust Detection of Linear Polarization from Metric Solar Emissions: Challenging Established Paradigms by Soham Dey, Devojyoti Kansabanik, Divya Oberoi, Surajit Mondal (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-05196.txt.
Introduction
Soham Dey and co-authors report the first solid detection of linearly polarized radio waves from the Sun at meter wavelengths in a 2025 paper. Polarization carries clues about how the waves are made and what they pass through. For fifty years, studies at these low frequencies assumed linear polarization was absent, based on expected scrambling in the Sun's outer air.
Two telescopes with very different designs, thousands of kilometers apart, measured the same signal at the same time. That match makes an instrument glitch unlikely. The finding challenges the standard picture of how solar radio waves travel. Solar radio scientists must now rethink old data taken under the no-linear assumption.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Soham Dey, Devojyoti Kansabanik, Divya Oberoi, Surajit Mondal |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 40 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-05196
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
First Robust Detection of Linear Polarization from Metric Solar Emissions: Challenging Established Paradigms Soham Dey, Devojyoti Kansabanik, Divya Oberoi, Surajit Mondal Abstract Polarimetric radio observations of the Sun can provide rich information about emission mechanisms and the propagation medium. For the past five decades, solar polarimetric studies at low radio frequencies have almost always assumed the absence of linear polarization. This has been based on the expectations from coronal propagation effects. Here we present the first robust evidence of linear polarization from solar emissions at meter wavelengths using simultaneous measurements with two telescopes of very different designs separated by thousands of kilometers – the Murchison Widefield Array and the upgraded Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope. Both datasets show consistent linear polarization fractions, confirming this detection. Rapid changes in morphology, as well as the fractional linear polarization at small time and frequency spans, further rule out any possibilities of an instrumental origin. Assuming the absence of linear polarization in solar radio emissions can result in incorrect interpretation of solar observations as well as those of other flare stars, which are often guided by learnings from solar studies. This discovery highlights the need for relaxing this assumption and is essential for precise estimation of polarization signatures, ultimately leading to a better understanding of the plasma conditions in the Sun and other stars. I Introduction The solar corona, the outermost layer of the solar atmosphere, serves as a natural laboratory for investigating magnetized plasma under conditions difficult to achieve in terrestrial laboratories. Solar radio bursts — transient, intense emissions — are a direct manifestation of dynamic processes such as particle acceleration, plasma instabilities, and magnetic reconnection ( E. Y. Zlotnik 1994 ; D. Gary 2023 ) . Traditionally, these bursts have been broadly classified based on their appearance in the time-frequency plane ( J. Wild & L. McCready 1950 ; J. Wild 1950a ; J. Wild 1950b ) , referred to as dynamic spectrum (DS). The ones of particular interest here are referred to as type-I and type-III bursts in the literature. Type‐I noise storms appear as persistent, broadband enhancements in the background emission, interspersed with short, narrowband bursts, known as type-I bursts. They are thought to arise from energetic electrons confined within closed magnetic loops ( D. Melrose 1980 ) . In contrast, type‐III bursts manifest as brief, rapidly drifting streaks in DS that trace semi‐relativistic electron beams escaping along open magnetic field lines ( D. Melrose 1970 ; V. V. Zheleznyakov & V. V. Zaitsev 1970 ) . These bursts not only carry information about their underlying plasma emission mechanism ( G. A. Dulk 1985 ) but also bear the imprints of the electron density distribution and magnetic field configuration encountered during propagation. Polarimetric observations will enable us to study some properties of the emission mechanism and the medium better, such as polarities of magnetic fields, distribution of non-thermal electrons, and length scales of inhomogeneities, as compared to using total intensity (Stokes I) alone. Propagation effects due to density irregularities and variable magnetic field orientations and strengths can alter the polarization state and even depolarize the signal. For example, noise storms and type-I bursts tend to be less circularly polarized near the solar limb than at the central meridian ( K. Kai 1962 ) , while type-III bursts, though theoretically expected to be highly circularly polarized, are often observed with weak ( <30\% ) or even negligible polarization ( G. A. Dulk & S. Suzuki 1980 ) . This reduced polarization is often attributed to mode coupling between magnetoionic modes in the corona, a process that may be further enhanced by large-amplitude Alfvén waves twisting the magnetic field lines ( D. Melrose 1974 ) . In such scenarios, radiation that is initially 100% polarized in one magneto-ionic mode (ordinary or O-mode for plasma emission) can acquire a partial linear component upon traversing a quasi-transverse region, where the wave vector is nearly perpendicular to the magnetic field ( D. Melrose 1970 ; V. V. Zheleznyakov & V. V. Zaitsev 1970 ) . A detailed understanding of these propagation effects could transform polarimetric studies of solar radio emission into a powerful diagnostic tool for probing coronal inhomogeneities and magnetic fields. Full-polarization, spectroscopic snapshot interferometric imaging studies at meter wavelengths hold great promise for this purpose. Although linear polarization from active solar regions at microwave frequencies ( \sim 5 GHz) has been reported ( C. E. Alissandrakis & F. Chiuderi-Drago 1994 ) , no robust detection has been made at meter wavelengths until now. In this work, we report the first robust detection of linearly polarized radio emission from metric solar radio emissions, which challenges a decades-old paradigm. The Letter is organized as follows. Section II provides a brief overview of this decades-old paradigm in solar physics and related observational challenges. Details of observations and data analysis are presented in Sections III and IV , respectively. Section V presents the key results from this study, followed by a discussion about the possible physical origins of the linearly polarized emission in Section VI . We conclude and discuss future directions in Section VII . II Observational Challenges and The Decades-old Paradigm Full polarization studies, including robust and unbiased detection of both linear and circular polarization from metric solar radio emissions, remain rare due to the limited availability of suitable instruments and significant calibration challenges. The scarcity of polarized calibrators at low radio frequencies makes it hard to follow the traditional approach for polarimetric calibration employed at higher frequencies. In addition, the wide field-of-view (FoV) design of most low-frequency arrays further complicates calibration ( D. Kansabanik 2022 ) . Moreover, the high flux density of the Sun can contaminate calibrator observations, and the calibrator’s true polarization properties are also altered by Faraday rotation in the Earth’s magnetized ionosphere ( D. Kansabanik et al. 2025 ) . Consequently, many studies have relied on the decades-old, longstanding assumption, driven by the expectation of high Faraday rotation in the corona, that any observed linear polarization at low radio frequencies is entirely instrumental ( R. Grognard & D. McLean 1973 ; K. Sasikumar Raja & R. Ramesh 2013 ; A. Kumari et al. 2017 ; P. I. McCauley et al. 2019 ; D. E. Morosan et al. 2022 ; R. Ramesh et al. 2023 ) . Faraday rotation is the rotation of the plane of linear polarization when an electromagnetic wave traverses through a birefringent medium. It depends on the electron density and the magnetic field strength along the line of sight and is proportional to the square of the observing wavelength ( \lambda^{2} ). The latter makes the effect of Faraday rotation more pronounced at meter wavelengths. The Faraday rotation is most naturally described by the rotation measure (RM), which is defined as Faraday rotation per \lambda^{2} . Using a well-accepted coronal density profile ( G. J. Newkirk 1961 ) and magnetic field model ( G. A. Dulk & D. J. McLean 1978 ) , a radial ray originating at 1 solar radius above the photosphere yields RM of the order of 10^{5}~rad~m^{-2} . Such high RM implies that linear polarization signatures in solar radio emissions at meter wavelengths are expected to be essentially erased. Three primary mechanisms contribute to