Understanding Everything as Code: A Taxonomy and Conceptual Model
1 st Haoran Wei, 2 nd Nazim Madhavji, 3 rd John Steinbacher · 2025
Read Understanding Everything as Code: A Taxonomy and Conceptual Model by 1 st Haoran Wei, 2 nd Nazim Madhavji, 3 rd John Steinbacher (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-05100.txt.
Introduction
Haoran Wei, Nazim Madhavji, and John Steinbacher present a 2025 study organizing Everything as Code, the push to define all parts of software delivery as code. The paradigm is popular, but standards and scholarly accounts of its scope are scarce. The authors ran a large review spanning academic and grey literature, then built a taxonomy and a conceptual model, checked with industry experts.
The taxonomy lists 25 distinct practices in six layers, ordered by industry awareness and role. The model shows where the practices focus, overlap, and interact across the delivery life cycle, with worked code examples. The authors claim the first full map of the field. They offer it as guidance for practitioners and as scaffolding for future research.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | 1 st Haoran Wei, 2 nd Nazim Madhavji, 3 rd John Steinbacher |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 45 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-05100
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Understanding Everything as Code: A Taxonomy and Conceptual Model 1 st Haoran Wei, 2 nd Nazim Madhavji, 3 rd John Steinbacher Abstract Background: Everything as Code (EaC) is an emerging paradigm aiming to codify all aspects of modern software systems. Despite its growing popularity, comprehensive industry standards and peer-reviewed research clarifying its scope and guiding its adoption remain scarce. Aims: This study systematically analyzes existing knowledge and perceptions of EaC, clarifies its scope and boundaries, and provides structured guidance for researchers and practitioners. Method: We conducted a large-scale multivocal literature review (MLR), synthesizing academic and grey literature sources. Findings were analyzed quantitatively and thematically. Based on this analysis, we developed a taxonomy and conceptual model of EaC, validated through collaboration with industry experts. Results: The resulting taxonomy comprises 25 distinct EaC practices organized into six layers based on industry awareness and functional roles. The conceptual model illustrates focus areas, overlaps, and interactions among these EaC practices within the software delivery lifecycle. Additionally, practical code examples demonstrating the implementation of these practices were developed in collaboration with industry experts. Conclusions: This work addresses the current scarcity of academic discourse on EaC by providing the first comprehensive taxonomy and conceptual model. These contributions enhance conceptual clarity, offer actionable guidance to practitioners, and lay the groundwork for future research in this emerging domain. I Introduction In recent years, Infrastructure as Code (IaC) has become indispensable for efficiently managing and provisioning computing environments through machine-readable definitions [ 1 ] . IaC primarily addresses infrastructure components such as servers, networks, and storage, yet other elements of the software delivery lifecycle (such as application configurations and operational pipelines) remain beyond its traditional scope [ 2 ] . Building upon the proven effectiveness of IaC, the Everything as Code (EaC) paradigm expands this foundational principle by advocating for all operational aspects—including infrastructure, configurations, security policies, and Continuous Integration/Continuous Delivery (CI/CD) pipelines—to be represented and managed uniformly as code [ 3 ] . This unified, code-centric approach aims to enhance automation, consistency, and traceability throughout the software delivery process [ 4 ] . Given these promising benefits, EaC is gaining substantial traction and is increasingly recognized as the future direction of IT operations [ 5 , 6 , 7 ] . However, the adoption of EaC presents notable challenges, primarily due to the requisite shift in organizational mindset. Unlike IaC, EaC necessitates the codification of a much broader range of processes and resources, often surpassing the capabilities of existing DevOps practices [ 8 ] . Consequently, clear industry standards and comprehensive scientific literature are needed to provide empirical evidence and structured guidance for EaC adoption. Currently, there is no dedicated standard—comparable to ISO/IEC/IEEE 32675 for DevOps—that provides explicit, comprehensive guidelines for EaC. Furthermore, our extensive literature search indicates a notable scarcity of peer-reviewed academic research on EaC (see Fig. 1 ). To the best of our knowledge, no comprehensive empirical studies on EaC currently exist (detailed further in Section II). Due to this gap, developers are often compelled to rely on non-peer-reviewed resources such as blogs and online forums. However, these informal resources typically provide generic advice or subjective opinions, rather than rigorously validated guidelines [ 9 ] . Our preliminary analysis highlights a significant lack of consensus among these sources regarding the standardized scope, boundaries, and interactions of EaC practices, complicating informed decision-making for practitioners (detailed in Section II). To address these gaps, we conducted a large-scale multivocal literature review [ 21 ] on EaC, synthesizing findings through both quantitative and thematic analysis [ 22 ] . Based on this comprehensive review, we propose a detailed taxonomy to clarify the scope of EaC. Our taxonomy identifies 25 distinct EaC practices (e.g., Infrastructure as Code, Configuration as Code, and Policy as Code) and classifies them according to their industry awareness and functional roles. Complementing this taxonomy, we developed a conceptual model that illustrates the focus areas, overlaps, and interrelationships among the various EaC practices across the software delivery lifecycle. Furthermore, we collaborated closely with industry experts to validate and refine both our taxonomy and conceptual model, ensuring their accuracy, relevance, and applicability (validation details are provided in Section VI). The taxonomy (Section IV) and conceptual model (Section V) constitute the primary contributions of this paper. Additionally, in collaboration with industry practitioners, we have developed practical code examples to demonstrate the implementation of our conceptual model using industry-standard tools. These examples serve as supplementary contributions. Collectively, these contributions aim to provide improved conceptual clarity, actionable guidance for practitioners adopting EaC practices, and a foundation for future academic research in this domain. II Related Work and Motivation Despite the growing significance of Everything as Code (EaC) in modern software delivery [ 5 ] , peer-reviewed literature explicitly addressing it remains scarce, as shown in Fig. 1 . Existing studies are limited in scope or depth. Stirbu et al. [ 3 ] identified Infrastructure as Code (IaC) and Configuration as Code (CaC) [ 16 ] as EaC subsets but focused on non-software contexts (e.g., healthcare compliance), limiting applicability to software engineering. Yanagawa et al. [ 10 ] proposed a framework combining Policy as Code (PaC) [ 17 ] and Compliance as Code (CoaC) [ 18 ] , narrowly defined EaC through this integration. Haverinen et al. [ 11 ] explored automation for compliance and security, addressing a subset of EaC. Zhao et al. [ 12 ] summarized DevSecOps tools, briefly mentioning Security as Code (SaC) [ 20 ] , PaC, and CoaC. Several book chapters [ 13 , 14 , 15 ] also touched upon EaC’s implications within software delivery, albeit superficially. A comprehensive empirical study that synthesizes EaC’s scope, key as-code practices, and their interrelationships is absent. Current work either focuses on specific practices or lacks rigorous data-driven analysis. Fig. 1: Numbers of publications on “Everything as Code” in major academic databases, searched in March 2025. Given this limitation, we expanded our investigation to include grey literature (e.g., white papers, industry reports, and blogs). Fig. 2 illustrates divergent perspectives regarding key EaC components identified in the grey literature sources. The varied interpretations captured in Fig. 2 highlight the absence of consensus among practitioners regarding the standardized scope of EaC. Fig. 2: Infrastructure as Code (IaC) and Configuration as Code (CaC) consistently emerged as foundational practices within EaC. Other as-code practices, including Policy as Code (PaC), Compliance as Code (CoaC), Pipeline as Code (PiaC), and Security as Code (SaC), are frequently, but inconsistently, identified as elements of EaC. Additionally, certain as-code practices—particularly PaC and CoaC—display overlapping functionalities and tightly coupled interdependencies, lacking clear boundaries or a well-articulated separation of concerns. For instance, Yanagawa et al. [ 10 ] characterized CoaC primarily as expressing regulatory controls as code, positioning PaC as a downstream mechanism for their validation and enforcement. Whereas, some industry practitioners conceptualize CoaC as a subset of PaC dedicated exclusively to enforcing regulatory compliance [ 37 , 38 ] . Conversely, others adopt a broader definition, applying CoaC to describe comprehensive, programmatic methods for automating the entire compliance lifecycle—encompassing implementation, validation, remediation, monitoring, and reporting—thus surpassing PaC’s scope [ 33 , 34 , 35 , 36 ] . Furthermore, existing practitioner discourse largely addresses EaC at a conceptual or motivational