Work and entropy of mixing in isolated quantum systems

Budhaditya Bhattacharjee, Rohit Kishan Ray, Dominik Šafránek · 2025

Read Work and entropy of mixing in isolated quantum systems by Budhaditya Bhattacharjee, Rohit Kishan Ray, Dominik Šafránek (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-05054.txt.

Introduction

Budhaditya Bhattacharjee, Rohit Kishan Ray, and Dominik Šafránek rethink, in a 2025 paper, the classic puzzle of mixing two gases inside a sealed quantum system. Textbooks treat mixing with the system open to a heat bath. Here nothing is exchanged, the start may be far from equilibrium, and only coarse measures are known.

They show the entropy of mixing is a special case of a broader idea, observational entropy, where both entropy and usable work depend on how finely the observer measures. This dissolves the Gibbs paradox: learning that two particle types exist raises entropy on paper, but it grants no extra work if the types cannot be told apart in practice. They also derive a Landauer-like bound on how much two observers' energy gains can differ.

Catalog record

CREATORBudhaditya Bhattacharjee, Rohit Kishan Ray, Dominik Šafránek
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE153 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-05054

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Work and entropy of mixing in isolated quantum systems Budhaditya Bhattacharjee, Rohit Kishan Ray, Dominik Šafránek Abstract The mixing of two different gases is one of the most common natural phenomena, with applications ranging from CO 2 \text{CO}_{2} capture to water purification. Traditionally, mixing is analyzed in the context of local thermal equilibrium, where systems exchange energy with a heat bath. Here, we study mixing in an isolated system with potentially non-equilibrium initial states, characterized solely by macroscopic observables. We identify the entropy of mixing as a special case of observational entropy within an observer-dependent framework, where both entropy and extractable work depend on the resolution of measurement. This approach naturally resolves the Gibbs mixing paradox in quantum systems: while an observer experiences a discontinuous increase in entropy upon learning of the existence of two particle types, this knowledge does not provide an advantage in work extraction if the types of particles remain operationally indistinguishable in their measurements. Finally, we derive a Landauer-like bound on the difference in energy extracted by two observers, where an ‘observational temperature’ emerges, determined by the accessible information. These results provide a foundation for rigorously determining the energy required to unmix in non-equilibrium settings and extend beyond quantum systems, offering insights into the thermodynamics of isolated classical gases. I Introduction Mixing two types of particles is one of the most common occurrences in nature. Whether it is the down-to-earth act of putting milk into our coffee or the release of \text{CO}_{2} into the atmosphere, the underlying physical laws remain the same. Such processes also have practical implications—most notably in determining how much energy is needed to separate two compounds once mixed. For gases, this minimal energy has a fundamental bound, revealing that capturing \text{CO}_{2} before it is released is far more efficient than attempting to remove it afterward Abd et al. 2020 . A similar principle applies to other modern environmental challenges, such as desalination Karagiannis and Soldatos 2008 or filtering microplastics Chandra and Walsh 2024 and hormones Gonsioroski et al. 2020 from our water supply, where proactive measures can significantly reduce both costs and ecological impacts. In classical physics, where gases are assumed to be in thermal equilibrium at a well-defined temperature, the energy cost of mixing is well understood. However, in systems that do not equilibrate or are not connected to a thermal bath the usual assumptions break down. Consequently, it becomes unclear how much energy is required to separate the gases. This challenge is especially pronounced in isolated quantum systems, which are now routinely realized and studied in experimental settings Gong et al. 2021 ; Bernon et al. 2013 ; Léonard et al. 2023 . These questions are also fundamentally observer-dependent: to study how much energy it costs to separate the two gases, one must first define what it means “to separate.” Typically, this notion carries a connotation of spatial separation, such as one type of gas being confined within a box while the other remains outside. Even in this case, however, the energy cost depends on the size of the box, which is determined by the observer or the agent attempting to separate the gases Blundell and Blundell 2010 . This definition is inherently tied to what the agent can achieve, shaped by their specific capabilities and limitations in carrying out the separation Jaynes 1992 . This interplay between the observer’s experimental capabilities and knowledge lies at the heart of the Gibbs mixing paradox (GMP). Consider two observers, one who can distinguish the two gases and the other who cannot. Recognizing the difference, the first observer assigns a higher entropy to the observed state, based on the larger number of microstates in compliance with any macroscopic observation. The second observer perceives no distinction and assigns a lower entropy, asserting that all particles are of the same type. Crucially, the first observer’s knowledge provides an advantage—if the gases are spatially separated, they can extract energy by allowing the gases to mix (classically, through semi-permeable membranes). The second observer, unaware of the distinction, cannot exploit this opportunity. As E.T. Jaynes noted Jaynes 1992 : “We would observe, however, that the number of fish that you can catch is an ‘objective experimental fact’; yet it depends on how much ‘subjective’ information you have about the behavior of fish.” While the role of different observers is widely acknowledged in these discussions, their treatment remains somewhat ambiguous in the absence of a formal framework defining what constitutes an “observer.” Instead, the situation is typically described qualitatively, with explanations stating that one observer can distinguish the two gases while the other cannot. From this premise, the appropriate definition of equilibrium entropy is either postulated or argued for, but it is not systematically deduced from the original statement. This lack of rigorous derivation leaves the connection between the observer’s capabilities and the entropy definition somewhat imprecise. Does “being able to distinguish” imply the ability to probe each particle individually and determine its type, or does it refer to probing a specific region of space to ascertain the proportion of particles of each type within it? These two interpretations are fundamentally different and lead to distinct outcomes, both in terms of the observer’s knowledge and the resulting thermodynamic description of the system. This also highlights another aspect of the paradox: the abrupt, discontinuous change in entropy that occurs when particles are distinguishable, even if differences between them are minimal. The mere potential for distinction leads to a significantly larger associated entropy. This apparent paradox arises from treating entropy as a fundamental property of the physical system. However, if entropy is instead understood as an informational measure—reflecting the observer’s perceived ignorance about the system and defining the limits of their ability to extract energy—the paradox dissolves. In this interpretation, entropy is relational, shaped by the observer’s knowledge and capabilities rather than an intrinsic characteristic of the system. In this paper, we formalize the concept of an observer and their capabilities in precise mathematical terms. This systematic approach removes the need for overly intuitive reasoning. Instead, it allows us to directly approach the question with higher clarity and precision. Thereby it allows us to quantify the additional energy that an observer with a higher resolution can extract from a system compared to an observer with a lower resolution. As an application, we analyze the difference in extracted energy between two observers in the Gibbs mixing scenario, in the generic 1D lattice model with fermions of two colors. Additionally, we focus on isolated quantum systems and compute the difference in energy that an observer can extract before and after the two gases mix, thereby establishing a lower bound on the energy required to separate them again. Interestingly, this result bears a strong mathematical resemblance to Landauer’s bound, with a key difference: instead of the bath temperature, an “observational temperature” emerges, defined by the observer’s experimental capabilities and limitations. Furthermore, since equivalent reasoning applies to classical systems, the insights gained extend beyond the quantum case. The framework allows us to discuss the energy required to separate isolated classical gases out of equilibrium, broadening the applicability of the results. First, we review the background including mixing and observational entropy (Sec. II ). Then, we

Read the complete text