Causal Impacts of Protected Bike Lanes on Cycling Behavior with Demographic Disparities
Marcel Moran, Malik Salman, Takahiro Yabe · 2025
Read Causal Impacts of Protected Bike Lanes on Cycling Behavior with Demographic Disparities by Marcel Moran, Malik Salman, Takahiro Yabe (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-04936.txt.
Introduction
Marcel Moran, Malik Salman, and Takahiro Yabe published a paper in 2025 measuring which bike lanes actually cause more cycling in New York City. Cities plead tight budgets and car-first streets, so the type of lane matters. Drawing on seventy-two million Citi Bike trips, the team compared protected lanes, painted lanes, and shared-lane markings.
Stations near any new lane gained trips in the following year, roughly eighteen percent for protected lanes and fourteen for the lesser types. But a difference-in-differences design, which strips out citywide trends, found a causal lift only for protected lanes, about 379 extra rides per station each month. The lift was strongest in older neighborhoods and absent in areas with medium-to-high shares of Black residents, an equity gap the authors flag plainly.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Marcel Moran, Malik Salman, Takahiro Yabe |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 43 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-04936
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Causal Impacts of Protected Bike Lanes on Cycling Behavior with Demographic Disparities Marcel Moran, Malik Salman, Takahiro Yabe Abstract Cities around the world face significant barriers to grow urban cycling, including competing budgetary priorities and car-centric streets. Thus, when making decisions regarding the installation of bicycle infrastructure, it is crucial to understand if and to what extent different bicycle-lane types increase bicycle ridership. However, associations between bicycle infrastructure and bicycle ridership have primarily been studied in the context of individual lanes and corridors, or when analyzed at the scale of entire cities, generalized across different bike-lane types. Drawing upon 72 million bikeshare trips from Citi Bike in New York, we demonstrate that there is an approximately 18% increase in bikeshare trips at adjacent stations in the 12 months following the installation of protected bike lanes (those with a physical barrier between cyclists and automobile traffic) and a 14% increase associated with painted bike lanes (where a line of pavement marking is present) and ‘sharrows’ (where a normal traffic lane is marked with a bike stencil). However, using a difference-in-differences analysis, we detect a causal effect on bikeshare ridership only following the installation of protected bike lanes, with an average monthly increase of 379 rides per station ( p < 0.001 p<0.001 ). Despite this causal effect being pronounced among census block groups with higher percentages of older adults (688 rides per month per station, p < 0.001 p<0.001 ), the causal effect of protected bike lanes on bikeshare ridership is absent in census block groups where the percentage of Black residents is medium to high. Taken together, these findings indicate that planners must emphasize protected bike lanes to spur ridership, and simultaneously target policies and programming to communities of color, to ensure that such infrastructure makes urban cycling a viable option for all residents. keywords Cycling, Causal Inference, Planning Introduction Increasing urban cycling can benefit cities by reducing air and noise pollution, carbon emissions, and roadway fatalities, relative to automobiles. [ 1 ] This is of particular importance given the transportation sector now represents the largest share of carbon emissions in the U.S., [ 2 ] and has been stubborn in terms of decarbonization. [ 3 ] In addition, cycling and pedestrian fatalities have remained high in the U.S. relative to peer nations, [ 4 , 5 ] as have deficits in daily physical activity. [ 6 ] Despite this constellation of motivations for increasing urban cycling, it has remained low in American cities, relative to European counterparts. [ 7 ] This is particularly the case in terms of race and ethnicity; people of color are under-represented among cyclists nationally. [ 7 , 8 ] Part of this disparity is potentially tied to infrastructure; the primary means of both safeguarding existing cyclists and encouraging new cyclists is by providing bike lanes, which designate semi- or fully-exclusive space for bicycle riding within the public right of way. [ 9 ] Though some U.S. cities have built large bike-lane networks (including Boston, Washington, D.C., Portland, OR, and San Francisco), many cities still provide little in the way of physical infrastructure for cycling. Further, a study of the provision of bike lanes in 22 large American cities determined that census block groups with higher percentages of non-white residents had lower access to bike lanes. [ 10 ] There is also growing evidence that protected bike lanes specifically can lead to increased ridership diversity. A mailed and intercept survey in Boston found a strong preference for protected bike lanes among non-white respondents, [ 11 ] and video recording and intercept survey of riders on bike lanes in Brooklyn indicated high non-white and local ridership. [ 12 ] Cycling in the U.S. also remains overrepresented by young people. [ 13 ] Though there has been fewer quantitative studies on bicycle infrastructure and older adults, cities that have implemented a broad range of programs to encourage bicycling, including protected bike lanes, have seen the share of trips by older adults increase. [ 14 ] Indeed, this area of bicycle research requires further scrutiny, particularly as America’s population ages in the coming decades. [ 15 ] Active-transportation research provides consistent evidence of a positive association between bike lanes and bike ridership. At the scale of a single bike lane, a difference-in-differences analysis found that a new bike lane in Boston causally increased bikeshare ridership by 80 percent. [ 16 ] In New York City, for each additional mile of bike lanes installed in Manhattan, 285 more bikeshare trips were generated. [ 17 ] Further, analyzing bicycle traffic at newly-installed protected lanes across five U.S. cities detected increases in cycling ranging from +21 percent to +171 percent. [ 18 ] In addition, in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, data from bicycle counters across 106 European cities indicated that the roll-out of provisional or ‘pop-up’ bike lanes [ 19 , 20 ] was associated with increases in cycling between 11-48%. [ 21 ] There are three important features of this existing literature that inform the design of this study. First, not all analyses differentiate between bike-lane type, at times treating painted and protected bike lanes as equivalent. Second, the variation in spatial scale (e.g. block, corridor, etc.) can make it difficult to compare findings across case studies, or draw larger insights about how bike-lane type influences behavior at the scale of an entire city. Third, attempts at linking bikeshare trips to bike lanes, including difference-in-differences analyses, [ 22 ] have yet to incorporate broader sociodemographics of the areas where trips occur. For these reasons, we sought to probe the relationship between bike lanes and bikeshare ridership at the city scale, while maintaining block-level specificity as to bike-lane type, and incorporating a range of likely-relevant sociodemographics. Based on works cited above, we hypothesize that not only will the expansion of bike lanes in New York City be associated with increases in bikeshare trips generally, but that there will be detectable spatial differences in such increases based on what type of bike lane each bikeshare station lies adjacent to. Indeed, we hypothesize that bikeshare trips which begin adjacent to protected bike lanes will increase to a greater extent than those which begin adjacent to either painted bike lanes or sharrows. Further, given existing racial disparities in biking, we hypothesize that in areas in which non-white persons make up a larger percentage of residents, the effect of protected bike lanes on bikeshare ridership will be less pronounced. With this context, we pursue a simultaneously comprehensive and fine-grain analysis of the relationship between bike-lane types and bikeshare trips, in the case of New York City, which maintains both a massive and expanding bike-lane network (see Figure 1A ), as well as North America’s largest bikeshare system (Citi Bike). Specifically, we analyze roughly 72 million publicly-available Citi Bike trips, in conjunction with publicly-available bike-network data, in order to detect how trips change over time based on what type of bike lanes they begin adjacent to. Given cycling’s ability to increase urban transportation’s safety, sustainability, and physical health, if and to what extent different types of bike lanes are associated with increases in cycling is paramount to assessing their value, and thus their prioritization