Deterministic Refund Mechanisms

Saeed Alaei, Shuchi Chawla, Zhiyi Huang, Ali Makhdoumi, Azarakhsh Malekian · 2025

Read Deterministic Refund Mechanisms by Saeed Alaei, Shuchi Chawla, Zhiyi Huang, Ali Makhdoumi, Azarakhsh Malekian (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-04148.txt.

Introduction

Saeed Alaei and four colleagues study refund mechanisms for a single buyer who is unsure what an item is worth, in a two thousand twenty-five paper. Buyer and seller share a model of the value, but the buyer learns the truth only after receiving the item. A seller can offer refunds, partial or random, when the buyer is unhappy.

Randomized refund schemes are common in practice, yet the authors focus on deterministic ones. They characterize optimal mechanisms as virtual value maximizers. The characterization covers both continuous and discrete type settings. Using it, plus bounds on menu size complexity, they build efficient algorithms. The algorithms find optimal and near-optimal deterministic mechanisms for sellers.

Catalog record

CREATORSaeed Alaei, Shuchi Chawla, Zhiyi Huang, Ali Makhdoumi, Azarakhsh Malekian
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE71 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-04148

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Deterministic Refund Mechanisms Saeed Alaei, Shuchi Chawla, Zhiyi Huang, Ali Makhdoumi, Azarakhsh Malekian Abstract We consider a mechanism design setting with a single item and a single buyer who is uncertain about the value of the item. Both the buyer and the seller have a common model for the buyer’s value, but the buyer discovers her true value only upon receiving the item. Mechanisms in this setting can be interpreted as randomized refund mechanisms, which allocate the item at some price and then offer a (partial and/or randomized) refund to the buyer in exchange for the item if the buyer is unsatisfied with her purchase. Motivated by their practical importance, we study the design of optimal deterministic mechanisms in this setting. We characterize optimal mechanisms as virtual value maximizers for both continuous and discrete type settings. We then use this characterization, along with bounds on the menu size complexity, to develop efficient algorithms for finding optimal and near-optimal deterministic mechanisms. 1 Introduction Buying personal items like clothing or shoes online can be fraught with risk – without the opportunity to see and try the item before purchasing, the buyer cannot be sure whether the item is worth the price they paid. Online retail platforms like Amazon ease the buyers’ dilemma and encourage spending by sharing their risk and offering flexible and generous return options. Returns and refunds are especially important when it is difficult for the platform to provide all of the information the buyer may need to assess whether the item satisfies their needs. For example, clothing is typically marked with one of a handful of size options, but this classification is coarse and may not fit all body types equally well. Likewise, while online retailers often provide pictures of the items they sell, these are not always true to color. Other traits like sturdiness cannot be judged through pictures at all. There is also variation across buyers in terms of how much risk or variation they are willing to undertake. Some buyers are very particular in their needs, whereas others would happily accept a range of qualities and parameters. Return policies can help bring more buyers and encourage more spending on a retail platform. But they can also potentially hurt the platform’s revenue by allowing buyers access to extra information that they would otherwise not have. Given this tradeoff, as well as uncertainty in buyer needs and item attributes, how should a platform design a practical and near optimal return/refund policy? This paper examines the design of return and refund schemes as a mechanism design problem where the goal is to maximize the seller’s expected revenue. We consider a stylized model for the sale of a single item to a single buyer drawn from a heterogeneous population. The item has attributes that are drawn from a known distribution. The value of the buyer for the item depends on both her type as well as the item’s attributes. However, neither the seller nor the buyer can directly observe the attributes before the sale happens. The selling mechanism, therefore, has two phases. The first phase happens after the buyer discovers her type but before she observes her true value for the item. At this phase, the seller allocates the item to the buyer with some probability at some price. The second phase happens after the buyer has seen the item and discovered her true value. At this point, the seller may offer the buyer the opportunity to return the item with some probability and with some additional transfer. We show that mechanisms in this model can be interpreted as menus where each option corresponds to an initial price paired with a random refund, which the buyer can obtain upon returning the item. Our work focuses on the computational complexity of optimizing revenue over deterministic refund schemes . Although optimal mechanisms in general may use randomness, such randomized refund schemes are rarely, if ever, seen in practice. In many mechanism design problems, optimizing over deterministic mechanisms is harder than optimizing over randomized mechanisms because the latter is general a convex set of possible solutions whereas the former is not. Nevertheless, for refund mechanisms we show that, under suitable assumptions, one can efficiently optimize over deterministic mechanisms. At a technical level our approach is based on two components. First, we show how to express the mechanism design problem in terms of suitably defined virtual values by deriving a payment identity. Then we provide menu size complexity results for the optimal mechanism in various settings of interest. These combined together yield efficient dynamic programming based algorithms for finding the optimal deterministic refund scheme. Ordered types. We now describe the key assumption that drives our results. Each buyer in the market has a type that specifies the distribution of her (a priori unknown) value for the item. We assume that these types are ordered in that a buyer of higher type has a value distribution that first-order stochastically dominates the value distribution at any lower type. One example of such an "ordered types" setting is when the item has a single ordered attribute (a.k.a. its quality) and the value of the buyer is a weakly increasing function of both her type and the item’s quality. So, a better quality item brings (weakly) higher value to the buyer; and a buyer of higher type values the item at any given quality at a (weakly) higher level than a lower type buyer. An interdimensional model. Our ordered types assumption places our model somewhere in between single dimensional and multi dimensional value models in mechanism design. There has been much work recently on so-called "interdimensional" settings in algorithmic mechanism design. Our model most closely resembles the ordered items setting in [ 16 ] and the second example above closely mimics the setting of the FedEx problem of [ 28 ] . However, there are important differences. In our setting, the item type is drawn exogenously and the seller has no control over it, whereas in these prior works the seller controls which item type (i.e., quality) the buyer receives. Thus, incentive constraints in our setting are quite different from those in previous work on interdimensional settings. Connections with information design. Our work is also related to information design settings where the seller has information about the item that informs the buyer’s value but is not available directly to the buyer such as [ 22 ] . In these settings, the seller can strategically decide how much information to share with the buyer prior to the sale of the item. Refunds can form an important component of mechanisms in this space, potentially simplifying and improving the design of information sharing schemes. In particular, the seller can couple sharing partial information about the item prior to the sale with the offer of a partial refund after the sale. This connection between information design and refunds has not been explored adequately, and we expect that our analysis can guide such connections. We discuss connections to prior work in more detail in Section 1.1 . Menu size. A key driver of our efficient algorithms is the observation that the menu size of the optimal deterministic refund scheme is small. Note that

Read the complete text