Finding easy regions for short-read variant calling from pangenome data
Heng Li \ORCID 0000-0003-4874-2874 · 2025
Read Finding easy regions for short-read variant calling from pangenome data by Heng Li \ORCID 0000-0003-4874-2874 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-03718.txt.
Introduction
Heng Li marks the easy stretches of the human genome for gene hunting, in a 2025 paper. Tests that call gene variants from short reads look near-perfect inside pre-set safe zones. Outside them, error rates can run ten times higher, which haunts clinics that lack a safe map for a new patient. Past zone sets leaned on old data or one lab's tools. Li instead built zones from hundreds of top-grade human genomes.
The zones cover most of the standard genome map, nearly all coding stretches, and nearly all known disease variants. Inside them, short-read calls reach high accuracy for any sample, since no single patient shaped the map. The recipe can be rerun for other genome builds or other species with many good assemblies. Li offers the set as a filter to cut false calls in clinic and lab alike.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Heng Li \ORCID 0000-0003-4874-2874 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 15 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-03718
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Finding easy regions for short-read variant calling from pangenome data Heng Li \ORCID 0000-0003-4874-2874 Abstract Background: While benchmarks on short-read variant calling suggest low error rate below 0.5%, they are only applicable to predefined confident regions. For a human sample without such regions, the error rate could be 10 times higher. Although multiple sets of easy regions have been identified to alleviate the issue, they fail to consider non-reference samples or are biased towards existing short-read data or aligners. Results: Here, using hundreds of high-quality human assemblies, we derived a set of sample-agnostic easy regions where short-read variant calling reaches high accuracy. These regions cover 87.9% of GRCh38, 92.7% of coding regions and 96.4% of ClinVar pathogenic variants. They achieve a good balance between coverage and easiness and can be generated for other human assemblies or species with multiple well assembled genomes. Conclusion: This resource provides a convient and powerful way to filter spurious variant calls for clinical or research human samples. Keywords: variant calling; pangenome; assembly \ast ]Corresponding author. [email protected] † † journal: TBD † † doi: TBD † † copyright-year: 2025 † † year: 2025 † † access: Advance Access Publication Date: Day Month Year † † appnotes: Preprint † † firstpage: 1 † † address: Department of Biomedical Informatics, Harvard Medical School, 10 Shattuck St, Boston, MA 02215, USA † † address: Department of Data Science, Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, 450 Brookline Ave, Boston, MA 02215, USA † † address: Broad Insitute of MIT and Harvard, 415 Main St, Cambridge, MA 02142, USA † † corresponding: [ 1 Introduction Variant calling from whole-genome sequencing data plays a crucial role in medical genetics, population genetics, and clinical genetic testing. Many algorithms have been developed for accurate variant calling from short-read data ( Depristo et al., 2011 ; Kim et al., 2018 ; Poplin et al., 2018 ; Cooke et al., 2021 ) and multiple benchmarks have been conducted to evaluate their accuracy ( Zook et al., 2014 ; Li et al., 2018 ) . A common practice in variant calling evaluation is to compare called variants to curated ground truth, notably generated by the Genome-In-A-Bottle (GIAB) group ( Zook et al., 2014 ) . Benchmarks using GIAB samples often report a low error rate of < 0.5% ( Olson et al., 2022 ) . On the other hand, when we compare variant calls from two callers, such as DeepVariant and GATK, their difference often exceeds 5%, 10 times higher than the error rate on GIAB samples. We see this apparent discrepancy because with GIAB, we only evaluate calls in sample-specific confident regions where the ground truth can be trusted. The error rate outside confident regions is much higher. The problem is that we do not know confident regions for a clinical sample. If we blindly take calls across the whole genome, the error rate will be closer to 5% than to 0.5%. Arguably, confident regions are more important than variant calling algorithms on GIAB-based benchmarks. Whereas confident regions are used for variant calling benchmarks on a specific sample, easy regions are derived for variant filtration agnostic to samples. They are genomic regions where general variant callers can reach high accuracy without sophisticated filtering. At same time, we also prefer to have large easy regions such that most clinically relevant variants can be retained. Constructing high-quality easy regions demands the balance between genome coverage and ease of calling. Broadly speaking, there are two classes of methods to identify easy regions. The first only considers unique regions in the reference genome. Methods in this class differ in how to define uniqueness. We derived a set of easy regions for ancient DNA variant filtering by selecting 35-mers that could not be mapped elsewhere within one mismatch or gap. ENCODE constructed similar k -mer-based sets with GEM mapper ( Marco-Sola et al., 2012 ) and switched to Umap ( Karimzadeh et al., 2018 ) later. GIAB combined short-range uniqueness of GenMap ( Pockrandt et al., 2020 ) and long-range segmental duplications ( Dwarshuis et al., 2024 ) . It optionally excluded short tandem repeats, regions of excessively low or high GC, and X-transposed and amplicon regions on X and Y chromosomes. Using the reference genome only, methods in this class are fast to run and easy to deploy. However, they would overlook regions unique in the reference genome but duplicated in non-reference samples. The second class of methods solve this problem by taking non-reference samples into account. We inspect the read alignment of multiple samples and exclude regions of excessively high or low coverage or enriched with alignments of low mapping quality. The 1000 Genomes Project (1KG) was the first to use such an approach ( 1000 Genomes Project Consortium, 2010 ) . Illumina posted an article in 2021 with a similar method, though not citing 1KG. Aganezov et al., 2022 reproduced these regions for T2T-CHM13 ( Nurk et al., 2022 ) . ENCODE blacklist ( Amemiya et al., 2019 ) considered empirical read alignment as well. Mandelker et al., 2016 defined problematic regions for GRCh37 exome which were often used in clinical testing. Methods in this class implicitly model biases in input reads and alignment algorithms. This helps variant calling given reads and alignment algorithms of similar property but is biased against new data types and alternative aligners. These methods also demand more computing and are harder to reproduce. In this article, we will describe a new method to produce easy regions from multiple high-quality human assemblies ( Liao et al., 2023 ) . It considers non-reference samples like the second class of methods but uses principles in the first class. It is also not biased towards sequencing data types or existing alignment algorithms. 2 Methods Suppose there are N genomes including the reference genome. A k -mer is sufficiently unique if 1) it has only one hit of edit distance up to d_{1} in the reference genome and 2) it has <1.01N hits of edit distance up to d_{2} across all genomes, d_{2}>d_{1} . With the first condition, the k -mer is unlikely to be mismapped if the second best hit d_{1} -edit away. The second condition kicks in when the k -mer is unique in the reference but has extra paralogous copies in non-reference samples. In this case, paralogous copies would be wrongly mapped to the unique reference position and differences between paralogous copies would be called as false variants. The second condition disregards the case where a k -mer is deleted in some genomes but duplicated in others. This is a weakness of our method. We could test the sufficient uniqueness of a reference k -mer by aligning it each genome separately. This would be computationally intensive. Instead, we construct a ropebwt3 index for all genomes including the reference ( Li, 2024 ) and align a k -mer with the revised BWA-SW algorithm in the end-to-end mode. This algorithm guarantees to find all exact matches and also reports suboptimal hits, though it may miss inexact hits due to heuristics. We sample one k -mer per w bases from the reference genome. If a k -mer at position i is not sufficiently unique, we mask interval [i,i+k) . After processing