Vanadium-doped HfO 2 , multiferroic uncompromised

Vincenzo Fiorentini, Paola Alippi, Gianaurelio Cuniberti · 2025

Read Vanadium-doped HfO 2 , multiferroic uncompromised by Vincenzo Fiorentini, Paola Alippi, Gianaurelio Cuniberti (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-03653.txt.

Introduction

Fiorentini, Alippi, and Cuniberti report calculations on hafnia with vanadium added, in a 2025 paper. Hafnia is an oxide that holds an electric order. The question is whether adding vanadium can make it magnetic as well, without losing that order.

Their calculations show the mixed material stays an insulator with both traits intact. Magnetism and a local warp break a tie in the vanadium states. That leaves one filled state per atom and a clear energy gap. The electric order is kept at about two-thirds of the pure hafnia value. Magnetism grows in a straight line with vanadium content. The authors present the material as a multiferroic with no trait traded away.

Catalog record

CREATORVincenzo Fiorentini, Paola Alippi, Gianaurelio Cuniberti
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE28 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-03653

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Vanadium-doped HfO 2 , multiferroic uncompromised Vincenzo Fiorentini, Paola Alippi, Gianaurelio Cuniberti Abstract Ab initio density-functional calculations show that orthorhombic P ​ c ​ a ​ 2 1 Pca2_{1} hafnia HfO 2 mixed with vanadium at low concentration is a ferroelectric and ferromagnetic insulator. The multiorbital degeneracy of singly-occupied V states in the nominally 4+ ionic state is broken by magnetism, reduced symmetry, and local distortion, causing a single one-electron majority state per V atom to be occupied. A gap of order 1 eV thus survives at all V concentrations, and intrinsic polarization is preserved, at the level of 60-70% of the hafnia value. Ferromagnetic magnetization is found to increase linearly with V content, with values of 30-40 emu/cm 3 at concentrations near the end of the stability range ( ∼ \sim 16% V). I Introduction Multiferroics –materials in which multiple states of order coexist, such as ferroelectricity and some sort of magnetic order– are rare. Ferroelectrics that possess ferromagnetic order are even more rare, and usually only weakly ferromagnetic due to e.g. Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya-type interactions. In search for a more robust sort of multiferroicity, here we explore the doping of ferroelectric hafnia with a transition metal, signally V. As the stoichiometry is fixed by construction, one may also view this as the mixing of two materials each endowed with one of the requisite orders: the ferromagnet is VO 2 in its C2/m monoclinic structure vo2 ; eyert (more about this in Sec. II.1 ); the ferroelectric is HfO 2 in the metastable (but amenable to stabilization) orthorhombic Pca2_{1} structure FEhafnia . The two are mixed into Hf 1-x V x O 2 (or (Hf,V)O 2 for short) with x up to around 0.37. For this proof of concept, we assume the starting structure of hafnia, and analyze the energetics and a few relevant physical quantities (signally, magnetization and polarization), using a simple model to discuss stability against separation in bulk components. For the time being, we do not address the other end of the x range, where a non-polar or, potentially, metallic VO 2 state would probably dictate the structure. The results, in a nutshell, are that polarization is conserved (though reduced) and magnetization increases linearly over the whole range considered; according to a model mixing free energy, the solid solution should be stable up to about x =0.15 at growth or annealing temperature 1000 K. The electronic structure evolves from the large gap of hafnia towards that of VO 2 , with the appearance and progressive increase in weight of a V-related occupied density-of-states feature above the upper edge of the valence band. The geometry of V configurations seems to indicate a tendency to first form rows, then combinations of rows producing incomplete planes, then planes decorated by excess V, then V-rich regions separated by Hf-rich regions, causing the mixture to resemble a rough superlattice of hafnia and vanadia (typically stacked along the crystal directions b and, to a lesser extent, a ). Our findings seem to compare well with a very recent set of experiments on a device stack involving the solid solution vhfo2 . II Methods We calculate observables from first principles within density functional theory at multiple concentrations and for multiple configurations of V substituting for Hf in ferroelectric HfO 2 . We use the VASP code (v.6.5) vasp and the PAW formalism PAW with the datasets V , Hf and O s , at a cutoff of 350 eV (1.3 times the maximum recommended cutoff). The polarization is obtained by the Berry-phase method berry . The density-functional calculations use spin-polarized GGA+U, i.e. the generalized gradient approximation (with the PBE PBE functional) with U corrections in the Dudarev version LDAU . We set U–J=3 eV on V d states only, and no correction on all other channels. This choice is based on preliminary comparisons with hybrid functional calculations HSE for a few selected configurations at low V concentration, and is confirmed by previous reports V-U . This setting limits computational costs and makes it possible to study a large number of configurations. Several counterchecks with hybrid functionals confirm the findings of GGA+U. The main difference is the HfO 2 gap, smaller (4.9 eV in GGA+U and 5.9 in HSE, close to experiment) but still quite sufficient to capture the evolution of the electronic structure as function of V concentration. The calculations are done in a supercell containing 32 cations and 64 anions (a 2 \times 2 \times 2 replica of the Pca2_{1} unit cell). In each configuration, V atoms substitute a random sample of n unique Hf atoms in the cell; n is between 1 and 12, corresponding to concentrations x between 0.031 and 0.375 in steps of 0.031. A total of 1481 configurations involving 9500 vanadium atoms are considered in the averages; the pairs (n:N_{\rm conf}) are (2:130, 3:153, 4:165, 5:153, 6:131, 7:149, 8:145, 9:166, 10:75, 11:80, 12:80). For n =1, we use 7 configurations, finding them identical to numerical accuracy as expected since all sites are equivalent. The volume and internal geometry are optimized for each configuration using a 2 \times 2 \times 2 k-space grid. Observables (energy, polarization, magnetization, dielectric function, Born charges) and density of states are then computed on a 4 \times 4 \times 4 grid. (Finer grids are impractical given the relatively large cell and number of configurations). A Gaussian smearing of 0.02 eV is used. The various quantities presented below are obtained as configurational averages with the Boltzmann weights \exp ( E_{i} / k_{B}T_{g} ) of the computed energies E_{i} and the assumed growth temperature T_{g} =1000 K (well within the range generally used for hafnia growth ; see also Sec. III.5 ). The error bars in the Figures are obtained from the square root of the covariance matrix of the weighted quantities. II.1 Magnetic insulator, general considerations For polarization to be directly computable via the standard Berry-phase approach the system must remain insulating. If the local geometry were strictly octahedral, the excess valence electron of V would occupy a 6-fold degenerate t_{2g} state. A combination of ”crystal-field” and magnetic level splitting is required to remove all degeneracies and open a gap in the spectrum. For example, in monoclinic C2/m VO 2 the t_{2g} majority triplet splits ega1 into an e_{g}^{\pi} doubly-degenerate state and an a_{1g} singly-degenerate state, which dominates the top valence bands. In Pca2_{1} HfO 2 , whose point symmetry is mm2 , the (majority) t_{2g} states are expected to split in three non-degenerate states a_{1} , b_{1} , and b_{2} , and the e_{g} into a_{1} and b_{1} . Disorder by random V substitutions, and the attendant local distortions, about which more below, indeed formally remove all symmetries. As in VO 2 , the a_{1} even state is expected to be lowest. Of course degeneracy removal requires a concurrent magnetic exchange splitting between the minority and majority channels, which is found to be approximately 2 to 4 eV in the present case. The end result is thus that a majority-channel gap (of order 1 eV) appears in the whole concentration range considered, separating occupied and empty V-derived states in the HfO 2 gap. A small percentage of the configurations are found to be ferrimagnetic, with part

Read the complete text