Constraining color-charge effects of partonic energy loss with jet axis-based inclusive jet substructure measurement

Raghunath Pradhan, and Olga Evdokimov · 2025

Read Constraining color-charge effects of partonic energy loss with jet axis-based inclusive jet substructure measurement by Raghunath Pradhan, and Olga Evdokimov (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-02725.txt.

Introduction

Raghunath Pradhan and Olga Evdokimov probe how quarks and gluons lose energy in a hot plasma. Their twenty twenty-five paper deals with the quark-gluon plasma, made when lead nuclei crash at high energy. Jets, sprays of particles from a hard hit, lose energy in the plasma, and the loss may depend on color charge.

The team reads recent CMS data on jet axes in lead-lead collisions. They match it with simulations that vary the mix of quark and gluon jets and fake charge-based loss. A template fit then bounds the gluon share and the mean momentum shift for each jet kind. The values line up with other model work.

Catalog record

CREATORRaghunath Pradhan, and Olga Evdokimov
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE32 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-02725

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Constraining color-charge effects of partonic energy loss with jet axis-based inclusive jet substructure measurement Raghunath Pradhan, and Olga Evdokimov Abstract This study investigates the color-charge dependence of parton energy loss in the quark-gluon plasma (QGP) medium and the associated relative modifications of quark and gluon jet fractions compared to vacuum, using jet axis decorrelation observables. Recent CMS jet axis decorrelation measurements in PbPb collisions at 5.02 TeV are interpreted using Pythia simulations with varied quark/gluon jet compositions and emulated color-charge dependent energy loss. A template-fit procedure is employed to estimate the limits on gluon jet fractions in the published CMS data and average shift in jet momentum due to quenching for quark- and gluon-initiated jets traversing the QGP. The extracted gluon jet fractions and the estimated quark and gluon energy losses based on this study of jet axis decorrelations are found to be consistent with other model calculations based on inclusive observables. This work illustrates the use of jet substructure measurements for providing constraints on the color-charge dependence of parton energy loss and offers valuable insights for jet quenching models. 1 Introduction Ultra-relativistic heavy-ion collision experiments aim to recreate a deconfined state of quarks and gluons, known as the quark-gluon plasma (QGP), under laboratory conditions to investigate the properties of this unique form of nuclear matter. Jets, collimated streams of particles produced in high-energy collisions, serve as versatile tools for probing the QGP Apolinario:2022vzg ; Cunqueiro:2021wls . These jets are initiated by energetic quarks and gluons (partons) produced in high-momentum-transfer processes during the initial stages of the collision. The partons subsequently fragment into lower-energy partons, which then hadronize into final-state particles. As the outgoing partons traverse the QGP, they lose energy through interactions with the medium. These interactions result in medium-induced modifications to various experimental observables, collectively referred to as “jet quenching”. Experimental evidence for jet quenching has been observed using multiple probes at both the BNL RHIC PHENIX:2001hpc ; STAR:2002ggv and the CERN LHC CMS:2021vui ; CMS:2021nhn ; ATLAS:2023hso ; ALICE:2023waz . Such probes include the suppression of high transverse momentum ( p_{\text{T}} ) particle yields, modifications to jet fragmentation functions, and changes in jet shapes. Some recent reviews on this subject can be found in Refs. CMS:2024krd ; ALICE:2022wpn ; Apolinario:2022vzg ; Cunqueiro:2021wls . In parallel with experimental studies of quenching phenomena, significant theoretical advances have been made over the past two decades in characterizing partonic energy loss in the QGP medium. The mechanisms understood as the primary contributors to the energy loss are medium-induced gluon radiation and collisional energy loss. Despite substantial progress on both theoretical and experimental fronts, the details of parton-medium interactions and the precise mechanisms governing parton energy loss remain unclear. Emerging techniques, such as jet substructure studies and the tagging (or selection) of quark and gluon jets, offer new insights into energy loss mechanisms Kogler:2018hem ; Vertesi:2024tdv . Due to differences in Casimir color factors ( \text{C}_{\text{F}}=4/3 for quarks and \text{C}_{\text{A}}=3 for gluons), gluon-initiated jets are expected to interact more strongly with the QGP and lose more energy compared to quark-initiated jets. This enhanced energy loss reduces the fraction of gluon jets within the surviving jet population in heavy-ion collisions at a given jet p_{\text{T}} compared to the vacuum case without a medium. Recent measurements suggest that the relative fractions of quark and gluon jets are modified in heavy-ion collisions compared to elementary proton-proton collisions, reflecting the differential energy loss due to the distinct color charges of quarks and gluons mediumqg ; eg:partonloss ; ALICE:2019ykw . The CMS experiment attempted to study gluon-like jet fractions by applying the template-fit method to the jet-charge observable for an inclusive jet sample from lead-lead ( PbPb ) collisions at a center-of-mass energy per nucleon pair ( \sqrt{s_{{}_{\text{NN}}}} ) of 5.02 TeV CMS:2020plq . This measurement found no significant evidence of a decrease in gluon jets or a corresponding increase in quark jets. The jet-charge observable currently lacks theoretical predictions for the expected in-medium modifications. The ATLAS experiment measured the jet nuclear modification factor ( R_{\text{AA}} ) and estimated the fractional energy loss ( S_{\text{loss}} ) for photon-tagged jets, and compared these observables with those for inclusive jets ATLAS:2023iad . Photon-tagged jets are more likely to be quark-initiated, whereas inclusive jets at low transverse momentum ( p_{\text{T}}<200 GeV ) are predominantly gluon-initiated at the LHC ATLAS:2023iad . It was reported that the R_{\text{AA}} of photon-tagged jets is significantly higher, and their estimated S_{\text{loss}} significantly lower, than those of inclusive jets, providing evidence that quark jets lose less energy than gluon jets in the medium. However, a detailed description of color-charge dependent energy loss in the QGP medium, along with the relative modifications of quark and gluon jet fractions, remains elusive and warrants further experimental and theoretical investigation through additional observables. Recently, the CMS experiment measured a new jet substructure observable, the jet axis decorrelation ( \Delta\text{j} ), for a similar data sample (inclusive jets from 5.02 TeV PbPb collisions) CMS:2024koh . This observable is predicted to be sensitive to the parton-medium interactions and provide constraints for energy loss models angelJetaxis . The study found that \Delta\text{j} is narrower than predictions from various unquenched models, such as pythia pythia82 and herwig Sirunyan:2020pqv . This narrowing could be attributed to modifications in the internal structure of jets caused by interactions with the QGP medium, selection biases favoring less-quenched jets, and/or results from the color-charge dependence of partonic energy loss. In the latter scenario, the larger average energy loss shifts gluon jets further down in energy compared to quark jets, resulting in a different partonic composition of quenched and unquenched jet samples. In this paper, we attempt to interpret the recent CMS jet axis decorrelation measurements by comparing them to pythia 8 pythia82 simulations with varying relative quark/gluon fractions and emulated color-charge dependent jet energy loss. A template-fit approach is employed to estimate the lower limit on gluon jet fractions within the inclusive jet sample. The quark- and gluon-initiated jet templates are derived from inclusive jet samples in 5.02 TeV pp collisions simulated with the pythia 8 event generator. Simultaneously, the average jet energy loss for inclusive, quark, and gluon jets is estimated by minimizing the chi-square (\chi^{2}) between the \Delta\text{j} distributions measured by CMS and those generated by pythia 8 with an applied p_{\text{T}} shift imitating energy loss (in this simplistic approximation, we assume all jets in a given sample lose the same fractional amount of energy, e.g., each jet p_{\text{T}} is shifted down by the same percentage). The paper is organized as follows. Section 2 outlines the analysis framework used to measure jet axis decorrelation. Section 2.1 discusses the template fits, while Section 2.2 focuses on estimating the p_{\text{T}} shifts for inclusive, quark, and gluon jets to interpret the CMS \Delta\text{j} distributions. Section 3 presents the results, followed by a detailed discussion. Finally, Section 4 summarizes the main conclusions of this work. 2 Analysis method and framework The jet axis decorrelation, \Delta\text{j} , is the angular difference between the axes determined by the anti- k_{\text{T}} energy-weighted (E-scheme) recombination and the winner-take-all (WTA) recombination schemes angelJetaxis ; CMS:2024koh . It is defined as \displaystyle\Delta\text{j}=\sqrt{(\eta^{\text{E-scheme}}-\eta^{\text{WTA}})^{2}+(\phi^{\text{E-scheme}}-\phi^{\text{WTA}})^{2}}, (1) Where \eta^{\text{E-scheme}} ( \eta^{\text{WTA}} ) and \phi^{\text{E-scheme}} ( \phi^{\text{WTA}} ) denote the pseudorapidity and

Read the complete text