Radical scaling: beyond our feet and fingers
M.A. Fardin, M. Hautefeuille, V. Sharma · 2025
Read Radical scaling: beyond our feet and fingers by M.A. Fardin, M. Hautefeuille, V. Sharma (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-02631.txt.
Introduction
Marc-Antoine Fardin, Mathieu Hautefeuille, and Vivek Sharma propose a new way to set the axes of scaling laws in a 2025 paper. Scaling laws state simple power links between two quantities, drawn as straight lines on log plots. In truth each law holds only over a range, with crossovers to other laws at its edges, and the units used are often human choices like feet and seconds.
Using blast data from laser, chemical, and nuclear explosions, the authors set axis scales from the crossover points themselves. Two regimes then collapse onto one curve, but a third regime stays off it under base ten. Replacing base ten with a special unit-free base built from the crossovers brings all three regimes onto one master curve. They show the same trick for drops and bubbles.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | M.A. Fardin, M. Hautefeuille, V. Sharma |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 121 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-02631
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Radical scaling: beyond our feet and fingers M.A. Fardin, M. Hautefeuille, V. Sharma Abstract Scaling laws arise and are eulogized across disciplines from natural to social sciences for providing pithy, quantitative, ‘scale-free’, and ‘universal’ power law relationships between two variables. On a log-log plot, the power laws display as straight lines, with a slope set by the exponent of the scaling law. In practice, a scaling relationship works only for a limited range, bookended by crossovers to other scaling laws. Leading with Taylor’s oft-cited scaling law for the blast radius of an explosion against time, and by collating an unprecedented amount of datasets for laser-induced, chemical and nuclear explosions, we show distinct kinematics arise at the early and late stages. We illustrate that picking objective scales for the two axes using the transitions between regimes leads to the collapse of the data for the two regimes and their crossover, but the third regime is typically not mapped to the master curve. The objective scales permit us to abandon the arbitrarily chosen anthropocentric units of measurement, like feet for length and heart-beat for time, but the decimal system with ten digits (fingers) is still part of the picture. We show a remarkable collapse of all three regimes onto a common master curve occurs if we replace the base 10 by a dimensionless radix that combines the scales from the two crossovers. We also illustrate this approach of radical scaling for capillarity-driven pinching, coalescence and spreading of drops and bubbles, expecting such generalizations will be made for datasets across many disciplines. Significance Statement: Scaling laws expressed in arbitrary units often fail when observations span a broader range. Transitions between regimes reveal objective units, allowing to capture these regimes and their crossovers. Beyond units, we must reconsider the numerical base (radix) we use. Decimal, derived from our ten fingers, dominates, but natural phenomena operate independently of human conventions. By analyzing transitions between successive scaling regimes, we propose using a number derived from the system itself as the base instead of 10. This approach captures universal behavior across regimes, creating new opportunities to revisit examples from diverse disciplines. Such a framework challenges anthropocentric standards, offering deeper insight into how numbers and units emerge directly from physical phenomena. What we see, perceive, and measure in the natural world is the combination of what is , and the angle, perspective, or reference frame we have chosen. Finding out what this elusive thing is then requires an array of viewpoints to overlap. For the practitioners of scaling analysis this overlap is understood quite literally. One may initially start with a messy set of intersecting data sets, and then strive to find the “right scale” with which the data almost magically overlap. Usually this quest stops when one finds judicious units for both axes of the plot. In this contribution, we show that a more complete scaling analysis should seek not solely to find units, but also to renormalize the very base we use for counting. Conventionally the base is 10, like the number of our fingers. However, fingers are no more legitimate than feet to count and measure. The starting point of a scaling analysis is usually a scaling law or power law, i.e. a relation of proportionality between one variable and some power of another, y=Kx^{\alpha} Barenblatt 2003 ; Santiago 2019 . Relationships of this kind are found everywhere. The periods of rotation of a planet is proportional to its distance to the Sun raised to a power \alpha=\frac{3}{2} (Kepler law). The mean square displacement of a diffusive particle is proportional to the square root of the time, so with \alpha=\frac{1}{2} (Einstein-Smoluchowski law). The metabolic rate of many animals is proportional to their mass to the power \alpha=\frac{3}{4} (Kleiber law). The forces of gravity or of electrostatics are inversely proportional to the square of the distance, \alpha=-2 (Newton and Coulomb laws). The power radiated by a black body scales with the fourth power of the temperature, \alpha=4 (Stefan-Boltzmann law). The frequency of occurrence of a word is inversely proportional to its rank, \alpha=-1 (Zipf-Mandelbrot law). The list goes on and on. Scaling laws are ubiquitous but they are usually studied in isolation. Their apparent simplicity is often a consequence of the narrowness of the observational range. When data are gathered more broadly any scaling law is bound to meet its demise. This statement has been verified time and time again by experiments. What we will show is that the eventual breakdown of a power law is actually a necessity if the associated phenomenon is to be independent of our human imprint. We will show that two intersecting power laws are needed to find objective units, and three to find an objective base. This article is accompanied by video lectures on Youtube , and a website making the data freely available. Details on how to use this material are provided in Supporting Information (SI). Scaling laws Figure 1: Trinity: a paragon of scaling law. (a) Pictures of the nuclear test, taken by the optical team led by J.E. Mack Mack 1946 ; Mack 1947 , and used by Taylor to analyze the kinematics of the explosion blast. Details and additional images are provided in SI and on a webpage we created for the greater dispersion of these data (Images courtesy of the Los Alamos National Laboratory). (b) Radius of the nuclear blast over time based on the images available to Taylor in 1950 Taylor 1950b . The grey line is d=Kt^{\frac{2}{5}} , with K=1913 ft.s {}^{-\frac{2}{5}} . (c) Replotting the data as an explosivity \tilde{X}\equiv d^{5}/t^{2} versus time t , distance d , speed d/t , or acceleration d/t^{2} –examples of the fact that the horizontal variable is indeterminate. The horizontal grey line is X\equiv K^{5} . Scaling laws have been studied in a wide variety of contexts and the arguments we shall develop in this article can be generally applied. We will however restrict our examples to particularly visual scaling laws tracking the evolution of a size or distance d over time t : d\simeq Kt^{\alpha} (1) Note that we use an approximate rather than strict equality, because actual data sets rarely perfectly match a power law. In Eq. 1 if \alpha=1 then motion is uniform and K is a speed. If \alpha=2 , motion is uniformly accelerated and K is an acceleration. If \alpha=\frac{1}{2} , K may be called a ‘sorptivity’ Philip 1957 , but one usually writes d=(Dt)^{\frac{1}{2}} , defining a ‘coefficient of diffusion’ or ‘diffusivity’ D\equiv K^{2} . This definition allows to deal with a kinematic quantity with integer exponents, since [D]=\mathcal{L}^{2}.\mathcal{T}^{-1} , but [K]=\mathcal{L}.\mathcal{T}^{-\frac{1}{2}} (brackets are used to give the dimensions of the enclosed quantity). Generally K is a kinematic quantity, i.e. depending solely on space and time, with [K]=\mathcal{L}.\mathcal{T}^{-\alpha} . One example of the kind of power law defined in Eq. 1 is found in many textbooks on scaling and dimensional analysis: d=Kt^{\frac{2}{5}} , which describes the extension of a blast wave of radius d , a time t after detonation Barenblatt 2003 ; Santiago 2019 . In that case, K has no standard name, but for future reference we may call X\equiv K^{5} an ‘explosivity’ Fardin et al. 2024 ,