Steady-State Coherences under Partial Collective non-Markovian Decoherence

S. L. Wu 1,2, W. Ma 1, Zhao-Ming Wang 3, P. Brumer 4, Lian-Ao Wu 2,5,6 · 2025

Read Steady-State Coherences under Partial Collective non-Markovian Decoherence by S. L. Wu 1,2, W. Ma 1, Zhao-Ming Wang 3, P. Brumer 4, Lian-Ao Wu 2,5,6 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-02557.txt.

Introduction

Open quantum systems leak order to their surroundings, yet some shared order can survive at a steady level. Wu and co-authors study two linked oscillators that face both shared and private noise baths. Their 2025 work adds a dial that sets how much of the noise is shared and how much is private.

By solving the exact motion rules, the team finds that lasting order depends on the start state under shared noise, but not when the noise is only partly shared. Noise with a memory, which breaks the usual simple rules, adds rich and tangled patterns of its own. The results give fresh insight into how memory in noise shapes quantum systems. They also serve as a yardstick for the shortcut methods used to model such systems.

Catalog record

CREATORS. L. Wu 1,2, W. Ma 1, Zhao-Ming Wang 3, P. Brumer 4, Lian-Ao Wu 2,5,6
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE60 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-02557

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Steady-State Coherences under Partial Collective non-Markovian Decoherence S. L. Wu 1,2, W. Ma 1, Zhao-Ming Wang 3, P. Brumer 4, Lian-Ao Wu 2,5,6 Abstract Steady-state coherence in open quantum systems is crucial for quantum technologies, yet its behavior is not fully understood due to the interplay between collective and individual decoherence. While collective decoherence is thought to induce steady-state coherence, experiments often fail to observe this because of individual decoherence. We study a system of two harmonic oscillators coupled to both individual and collective environments, introducing a tunable parameter to adjust the decoherence proportions. By analytically solving the exact dynamical equations, we find that steady-state coherence depends on the initial state under collective decoherence, but not under partial decoherence. Interestingly, non-Markovianity induces rich and complex steady-state coherence behaviors. Our results offer new insights into the role of non-Markovian decoherence in quantum systems and serve as a benchmark for evaluating approximate methods in modelling quantum processes. pacs 03.67.-a, 03.65.Yz, 05.70.Ln, 05.40.Ca I Introduction The study of steady-state coherence in open quantum systems is of fundamental importance in quantum physics and has practical implications for quantum technologies such as quantum computation Verstraete2009 ; Yosifov2024 , quantum metrology Wang2018 ; Naghiloo2019 , and quantum thermodynamics Goold2016 ; Lu2024 . Coherence, as a signature of quantum superposition, is essential for these applications, but its feature in the presence of environmental couplings is a major challenge Ask2022 ; Ablimit2024 ; Singh2021 . Understanding how coherence behaves in the long-time limit, especially in systems coupled with multiple or various environments simultaneously Becker2022 ; Tucker2020 , is critical for the development of robust and efficient quantum systems. This makes the investigation of steady-state coherence not only theoretically significant but also practically necessary. Theoretically, under complete collective decoherence Liu2024 ; Venkatesh2018 , the common environment can induce steady-state coherence in an open quantum system Guarnieri2021 ; Gribben2020 ; Zhou2022 . This intriguing prediction suggests that even in the presence of dissipation, coherence can be preserved or even generated in certain conditions Zanardi2014 ; Dodin2021 ; Dodin2024 . This forms the basis for the concept of the decoherence-free subspace Venkatesh2018 ; Wu2002 . However, experimental observations often fail to confirm such predictions Pushin2011 , with feeble steady-state coherence being detected. The primary reason for this discrepancy lies in the unavoidable presence of individual decoherence Mewes2005 ; Ruimy2021 , which competes with and suppresses the effects of collective decoherence. Given the diversity of physical systems and environments, it is essential to study models that incorporate both collective and individual decoherence to better understand their combined effects and the conditions under which steady-state coherence might survive Eastham2016 . In this work, we explore a model of two non-interacting harmonic oscillators coupled to both individual and collective environments. By introducing a tunable parameter to adjust the proportions of collective and individual decoherence Wang2023 , we systematically investigate the impact of the decoherence proportions on the steady-state coherence of the system. In the Heisenberg picture, we derive exact dynamical equations for the annihilation operators of the oscillators, expressing their time evolution as a linear combination of their initial values. This approach allows us to obtain exact analytical solutions for the dynamics and separate transient effects from the steady-state properties. Our findings highlight the conditions under which steady-state coherence can be preserved or enhanced, offering valuable insights into the interplay between individual and collective decoherence Braun2011 . Our results reveal that the balance between collective and individual decoherence critically determines the steady-state coherence of the system. Using the main values of suitable observables to quantify the coherence of the harmonic oscillators Chou2008 , we find that the properties of steady-state coherence under perfect collective decoherence differ fundamentally from those under partial collective decoherence. Remarkably, under collective decoherence, the steady-state coherence depends on the system’s initial state, while partial collective decoherence suppresses this dependence. Additionally, contrary to previous results, Even for the partial collective decoherence model, by appropriately selecting system parameters, we can always ensure the observation of steady-state quantum coherence, especially in the non-Markovian regime Ask2022 ; Ablimit2024 . These findings provide a deeper understanding of how environmental interactions influence quantum coherence and highlight the necessity of considering both types of decoherence in realistic models. This paper is organized as follows: In Sec. II , we present the exact dynamical equations of the harmonic oscillator system and the analytical solutions in the Heisenberg picture. In Section III , we present numerical results illustrating the steady-state coherence under varying conditions. Conclusions are presented in Sec. IV II Exact Dynamics II.1 Exact Dynamical Equation We consider that the two oscillators couple to their own bosonic reservoirs at finite reservoir temperatures T_{i} (i=1,2) individually and a common bosonic heat reservoir at a finite reservoir temperature T_{0} . The total Hamiltonian is \hat{H}_{\text{tot}}=\hat{H}_{\text{S}}+\hat{H}_{\text{B}}+\hat{H}_{\text{SB}}, where \hat{H}_{\text{B}}=\sum_{i=0,1,2}\sum_{\alpha}\omega_{i,\alpha}\hat{b}_{i,\alpha}^{\dagger}\hat{b}_{i,\alpha} is the reservoir Hamiltonian. \hat{b}_{i,\alpha} is the annihilation operator for the i -th thermal reservoir, and \omega_{i,\alpha} is the corresponding characteristic frequency. The system Hamiltonian reads \hat{H}_{\text{S}}=\sum_{i=1,2}\omega_{i}\hat{c}_{i}^{\dagger}\hat{c}_{i}, where \omega_{i} is the frequency of the i -th resonator with corresponding annihilation operator \hat{c}_{i} .The interaction Hamiltonian is considered as \hat{H}_{\text{SB}}=\sum_{i=0,1,2}\sum_{\alpha}g_{i,\alpha}\hat{L}_{i}\otimes\hat{b}_{i,\alpha}^{\dagger}+\text{h.c.}, where \hat{L}_{i} are the system coupling operators. For i=0 , it indicates that the two resonators interact with a common thermal reservoir with \hat{L}_{0}=\left(\hat{c}_{1}+\hat{c}_{2}\right) , while for i=1,2 , it represents the interaction of the resonators with their respective thermal reservoirs with \hat{L}_{1}=\hat{c}_{1} and \hat{L}_{2}=\hat{c}_{2} , in which g_{i,\alpha} is the coupling strength. According to the Heisenberg equation, we can obtain the evolution equation of \hat{c}_{i}(t) in the Heisenberg picture \displaystyle\dot{\hat{c}}_{1} \displaystyle= \displaystyle-i\,\omega_{1}\hat{c}_{1}-i\,\sum_{\alpha}g_{0,\alpha}^{*}\hat{b}_{0,\alpha}-i\,\sum_{\beta}g_{1,\beta}^{*}\hat{b}_{1,\beta}, (1) \displaystyle\dot{\hat{c}}_{2} \displaystyle= \displaystyle-i\,\omega_{2}\hat{c}_{2}-i\,\sum_{\alpha}g_{0,\alpha}^{*}\hat{b}_{0,\alpha}-i\,\sum_{\beta}g_{2,\beta}^{*}\hat{b}_{2,\beta}. (2) The reservoir modes \hat{b}_{i,\alpha}(t) satisfy \displaystyle\dot{\hat{b}}_{i,\alpha} \displaystyle= \displaystyle-i\,\omega_{i,\alpha}\hat{b}_{i,\alpha}-i\,g_{i,\alpha}\hat{L}_{i}. (3) By formally integrating Eq. ( 3 ), it yields \displaystyle\hat{b}_{i,\alpha}(t) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\hat{b}_{i,\alpha}(0)\exp\left(-i\>\omega_{i,\alpha}t\right) \displaystyle-i\,g_{i,\alpha}\int_{0}^{t}\text{d}s\,\hat{L}_{i}(s)\exp\left(-i\>\omega_{i,\alpha}\left(t-s\right)\right). Substituting the formal solution into Eq. ( 2 ), we have \displaystyle\dot{\hat{c}}_{j}(t) \displaystyle= \displaystyle-i\,\omega_{j}\hat{c}_{j}-i\,\sum_{\alpha}g_{0,\alpha}^{*}\hat{b}_{0,\alpha}(0)\exp\left(-i\>\omega_{0,\alpha}t\right) \displaystyle- \displaystyle\sum_{\alpha}|g_{0,\alpha}|^{2}\int_{0}^{t}\text{d}s\,\hat{L}_{0}(s)\exp\left(-i\>\omega_{0,\alpha}\left(t-s\right)\right) \displaystyle- \displaystyle\sum_{\beta}|g_{j,\beta}|^{2}\int_{0}^{t}\text{d}s\,\hat{c}_{j}(s)\exp\left(-i\>\omega_{j,\beta}\left(t-s\right)\right) \displaystyle- \displaystyle i\,\sum_{\beta}g_{j,\beta}^{*}\hat{b}_{j,\beta}(0)\exp\left(-i\>\omega_{j,\beta}t\right). We represent the annihilation operator of the harmonic oscillator as a linear combination of the initial annihilation operators for both the system and the reservoir, \displaystyle\hat{c}_{j}(t) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\sum_{i}C_{i}^{j}(t)\hat{c}_{i}^{0}+\sum_{k,\alpha}B_{k,\alpha}^{j}(t)\hat{b}_{k,\alpha}^{0}, (4) where we have used the definitons \hat{c}_{i}^{0}\equiv\hat{c}_{i}(0) and \hat{b}_{k,\alpha}^{0}\equiv\hat{b}_{k,\alpha}(0). The exact dynamical equations of the expansion coefficients in \hat{c}_{j}(t) are \displaystyle\dot{C}_{i}^{j}(t) \displaystyle= \displaystyle-i\,\omega_{j}C_{i}^{j}(t)-\int_{0}^{t}\text{d}\tau\,f_{j}(t-\tau)C_{i}^{j}(\tau) (5) \displaystyle-\int_{0}^{t}\text{d}\tau\,f_{0}(t-\tau)\sum_{p}C_{i}^{p}(\tau), \displaystyle\dot{B}_{k,\alpha}^{j}(t) \displaystyle= \displaystyle-i\,\omega_{j}B_{k,\alpha}^{j}(t)-\int_{0}^{t}\text{d}\tau\,f_{j}(t-\tau)B_{k,\alpha}^{j}(\tau) (6) \displaystyle-\int_{0}^{t}\text{d}\tau\,f_{0}(t-\tau)\sum_{p=1,2}B_{k,\alpha}^{p}(\tau) \displaystyle-i\,g_{k,\alpha}^{*}e^{-i\>\omega_{k,\alpha}t}\delta_{jk}-i\,g_{0,\alpha}^{*}e^{-i\>\omega_{0,\alpha}t}\delta_{k0}. with f_{k}\left(t-s\right)=\sum_{\alpha}|g_{k,\alpha}|^{2}\exp\left(-i\omega_{k,\alpha}\left(t-s\right)\right) for j=1,2 . Once these expansion coefficients are obtained and the initial states of the system and the reservoir are determined, the expectation value of any observable at any given time can be calculated. II.2 Analytical Solutions Under certain conditions, the dynamical equation of the open oscillators system can be solved analytically. Here, we assume \omega_{1}=\omega_{2} , \omega_{1,\alpha}=\omega_{2,\alpha} , g_{1,\alpha}=g_{2,\alpha} , g_{0,\alpha}=g_{\alpha}\cos^{2}\theta , and g_{1,\alpha}=g_{\alpha}\sin^{2}\theta with an effective coupling strength g_{\alpha} . \theta determines the proportions of the individual decoherence and collective decoherence. For \theta=\pi/2 , H_{\text{SB}} represents the coupling of the system with their own reservoir (the individual decoherence), while for \theta=0 , H_{\text{SB}} describes the interaction of the two resonators with a common environment (the collective decoherence) Wang2023 . To obtain the exact solution, we first group C_{j}^{i} and B_{j}^{i} , and then apply appropriate transformations to derive a set of decoupled second-order differential equations. As an example, we consider a group variants C_{j}^{i} , which satisfy \displaystyle\dot{C}_{j}^{1}(t) \displaystyle= \displaystyle-i\,\omega_{1}C_{j}^{1}(t)-\sin^{4}\theta\int_{0}^{t}\text{d}\tau\,f(t-\tau)C_{j}^{1}(\tau) \displaystyle-\cos^{4}\theta\int_{0}^{t}\text{d}\tau\,f(t-\tau)\sum_{p=1,2}C_{j}^{p}(\tau), \displaystyle\dot{C}_{j}^{2}(t) \displaystyle= \displaystyle-i\,\omega_{1}C_{j}^{2}(t)-\sin^{4}\theta\int_{0}^{t}\text{d}\tau\,f(t-\tau)C_{j}^{2}(\tau) \displaystyle-\cos^{4}\theta\int_{0}^{t}\text{d}\tau\,f(t-\tau)\sum_{p=1,2}C_{j}^{p}(\tau), It is convenient to

Read the complete text