The 3D Cosmic Shoreline for Nurturing Planetary Atmospheres Facilities: Exoplanet Archive, HST, JWST, Spitzer, Kepler, TESS astropy ( Astropy Collaboration et al. 2013 ; Astropy Collaboration et al. 2018 ; Astropy Collaboration et al. 2022 ) , numpy ( C. R. Harris et al. 2020 ) , matplotlib ( J. D.

Zach K. Berta-Thompson, Patcharapol Wachiraphan, Catriona Murray · 2025

Read The 3D Cosmic Shoreline for Nurturing Planetary Atmospheres Facilities: Exoplanet Archive, HST, JWST, Spitzer, Kepler, TESS astropy ( Astropy Collaboration et al. 2013 ; Astropy Collaboration et al. 2018 ; Astropy Collaboration et al. 2022 ) , numpy ( C. R. Harris et al. 2020 ) , matplotlib ( J. D. by Zach K. Berta-Thompson, Patcharapol Wachiraphan, Catriona Murray (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-02136.txt.

Introduction

Zach Berta-Thompson, Patcharapol Wachiraphan, and Catriona Murray draw a boundary in 2025 for which planets can hold atmospheres. Such boundaries are called cosmic shorelines, and they help show which forces strip air away and which planets deserve a closer look. Older versions rested on past radiation from each star, which cannot be measured directly.

Their boundary works in three dimensions: escape speed, light received, and star brightness. Using Solar System and exoplanet data, they fit one flat boundary and find it steeper than the classic version. The fit suggests Earth-sized planets near dim red stars past a set faintness are unlikely to keep air even in the mild zone.

Catalog record

CREATORZach K. Berta-Thompson, Patcharapol Wachiraphan, Catriona Murray
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE53 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-02136

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The 3D Cosmic Shoreline for Nurturing Planetary Atmospheres Facilities: Exoplanet Archive, HST, JWST, Spitzer, Kepler, TESS astropy ( Astropy Collaboration et al. 2013 ; Astropy Collaboration et al. 2018 ; Astropy Collaboration et al. 2022 ) , numpy ( C. R. Harris et al. 2020 ) , matplotlib ( J. D. Hunter 2007 ) , jax ( J. Bradbury et al. 2018 ) , numpyro ( D. Phan et al. 2019 ) , arviz ( R. Kumar et al. 2019 ) , exoatlas ( github.com/zkbt/exoatlas ) Zach K. Berta-Thompson, Patcharapol Wachiraphan, Catriona Murray Abstract Various “cosmic shorelines” have been proposed to delineate which planets have atmospheres. The fates of individual planet atmospheres may be set by a complex sea of growth and loss processes, driven by unmeasurable environmental factors or unknown historical events. Yet, defining population-level boundaries helps illuminate which processes matter and identify high-priority targets for future atmospheric searches. Here, we provide a statistical framework for inferring the position, shape, and fuzziness of an instellation-based cosmic shoreline, defined in the three-dimensional space of planet escape velocity, planet bolometric flux received, and host star luminosity; explicitly including luminosity partially circumvents the need to estimate host stars’ historical X-ray and extreme ultraviolet fluences. Using Solar System and exoplanet atmospheric constraints, under the restrictive assumption that one planar boundary applies across a wide parameter space, we find the critical flux threshold for atmospheres scales with escape velocity with a power-law index of p = 6.08 − 0.48 + 0.69 p=6.08_{-0.48}^{+0.69} , steeper than the canonical literature slope of p = 4 p=4 , and scales with stellar luminosity with a power-law index of q = 1.25 − 0.22 + 0.31 q=1.25_{-0.22}^{+0.31} , steep enough to disfavor atmospheres on Earth-sized planets out to the habitable zone for stars less luminous than log 10 ⁡ ( L ⋆ / L ☉ ) = − 2.22 ± 0.21 \log_{10}(L_{\star}/L_{\sun})=-2.22\pm 0.21 (roughly spectral type M4.5V). If we relax the assumption that one power law must stretch from the hottest exoplanets to the coolest Solar System worlds, the narrower question of “Which warm planets have thick CO 2 secondary atmospheres?” is still poorly constrained by data but should improve significantly with planned JWST observations. I Introduction Where can atmospheres thrive? This question has grown more urgent as astronomers branch out from the Solar System to exoplanets, where atmospheres require great observational expense to measure or sometimes can only be imagined. A complete, precise, and predictive answer to this question might not exist, as each individual atmosphere is the integrated balance of difficult-to-model sources and sinks. Atmospheres grow through early accretion from primordial nebulae, through later impact delivery, through continual magmatic outgassing from the interior, and through evaporation or sublimation of surface volatiles. Atmospheres wither through myriad upper-atmosphere escape processes driven by stellar radiation, stellar winds, and/or impacts; through sequestering into the interior; and through condensation or deposition to the surface. These processes continuously interact with each other, they operate on timescales spanning minutes to gigayears, and they depend on historical environmental inputs that can be wildly uncertain, chaotic, or stochastic. On Earth and other inhabited planets, atmospheric evolution is further complicated by biogeochemical cycles that may include the influence of technological civilizations. For more on atmospheric evolution, see reviews by R. E. Johnson et al. 2008 ; H. Lammer et al. 2008 ; F. Tian 2015 ; J. E. Owen 2019 ; G. Gronoff et al. 2020 ; R. Wordsworth & L. Kreidberg 2022 and textbooks by J. W. Chamberlain & D. M. Hunten 1987 ; R. T. Pierrehumbert 2010 ; S. Seager 2010 ; A. P. Ingersoll 2013 ; J. J. Lissauer & I. De Pater 2019 . Despite the incredible specifics needed to model an atmosphere’s detailed history, we can still seek systematic trends among basic planet properties that may allow for the cultivation of an atmosphere. K. J. Zahnle & D. C. Catling 2017 distilled this idea into the search for a “cosmic shoreline”, with dry volatile-poor atmosphere-less worlds (the sand) on one side of the shoreline and worlds rich in volatiles or atmospheres on the other (the lake/sea/ocean). ZC17 explored log-linear boundaries in 2D spaces defined by planetary escape velocity v_{\sf esc} – a tracer of how strongly planets hold onto volatiles (or various combinations of v_{\sf esc} with planet mass M , radius R , density \rho ) -- and by various sources of incoming energy available to drive escape: the current bolometric flux 1 1 1 In this work we primarily use “flux” ( f ) to refer to the power per unit area (W/m 2 ) a planet receives from its star. It is equivalent to “insolation” ( in coming sol ar radi ation ) as used by ZC17, “instellation” ( in coming stell ar radi ation ) introduced for exoplanets by A. L. Shields et al. 2013 , or “irradiance.” planets receive f , the cumulative X-ray and extreme ultraviolet (XUV) fluence planets have received over their history F_{\sf XUV}=\int_{0}^{\sf now}f_{\sf XUV}(t)dt , and/or the estimated velocity of giant impacts v_{\sf imp} . Although it is typically less than 0.01% of a star’s bolometric luminosity ( K. France et al. 2016 ) , the difficult-to-measure XUV flux is distinctly important because it drives the upper-atmosphere heating and ionization that mediate many escape processes ( J. L. Linsky & S. Redfield 2024 ) . ZC17 identified f\propto v_{\sf esc}^{4} and F_{\sf XUV}\propto v_{\sf esc}^{4} as effective definitions of instellation-based cosmic shorelines, as well as v_{\sf imp}/v_{\sf esc}=5 as a potential impact-driven shoreline ( K. Zahnle 1998 , see also) . The ZC17 instellation-based shorelines have been adopted among the exoplanet community trying to identify rocky exoplanets most likely to have atmospheres and to contextualize non-detections of such atmospheres from JWST ( B. Park Coy et al. 2024 , and references therein) . The Rocky Worlds STScI Director’s Discretionary Time program is using 500 hours of JWST time to survey terrestrial transiting exoplanets for atmospheres ( S. Redfield et al. 2024 ) and includes estimated location relative to the F_{\sf XUV} shoreline as a metric for target prioritization 2 2 2 rockyworlds.stsci.edu . Since the shoreline is being used, we want to help make it as useful as possible. In this work, we revisit the ZC17’s instellation-based shorelines through the lens of Bayesian probabilistic modeling, incorporating new rocky exoplanet atmospheres contraints from JWST. We define a generative model for the probability of a planet having an atmosphere and use it to infer the location, slope, and width of a cosmic shoreline, along with uncertainties on these quantities. We expand the shoreline into 3D, using planetary escape velocity v_{\sf esc} , planetary bolometric flux f , and stellar luminosity L_{\star} as three predictors for whether planets have atmospheres. The inclusion of stellar luminosity is designed to remove the need for star-by-star estimates of hard-to-measure environmental drivers for atmospheric escape (like high-energy fluence F_{\sf XUV} ), moving them to where they can be modeled and marginalized more easily on an ensemble level. Thus, the predictors for atmospheres can stay rooted in easy-to-observe measurements, while still capturing trends in changing stellar environment toward lower mass stars. Acknowledging that a true underlying cosmic shoreline is

Read the complete text