Do Pulsar Timing Datasets Favor Massive Gravity?

Chris Choi, Tina Kahniashvili · 2025

Read Do Pulsar Timing Datasets Favor Massive Gravity? by Chris Choi, Tina Kahniashvili (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-02059.txt.

Introduction

Chris Choi and Tina Kahniashvili ask in 2025 whether pulsar timing data already hint that gravity's carrier has a tiny mass. A whisper of background gravitational waves was lately caught by watching pulsars blink in chorus. If the waves' carrier were massive, their spread and extra vibration modes would bend the pattern of those blinks.

Fitting two data sets, one American and one Chinese, the pair find massive waves match the observed pattern better. The claim holds whatever source made the background hum. Sharper future data could catch the extra modes directly and weigh the graviton for real.

Catalog record

CREATORChris Choi, Tina Kahniashvili
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE27 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-02059

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Do Pulsar Timing Datasets Favor Massive Gravity? Chris Choi, Tina Kahniashvili Abstract Several observational phenomena suggest that the standard model of cosmology and particle physics requires revision. To address this, we consider the extension of general relativity known as massive gravity (MG). In this Letter, we explore the imprints of MG on the propagation of gravitational waves (GWs): their modified dispersion relation and their additional (two vector and one scalar) polarization modes on the stochastic GW background (SGWB) detected by pulsar timing arrays (PTAs). We analyze the effects of massive GWs on the Hellings-Downs curve induced by modification of the overlap reduction function. Our study consists of analyzing observational data from the NANOGrav 15-year dataset and the Chinese PTA Data Release I, and is independent of the origin of the SGWB (astrophysical or cosmological). By considering the bound on the graviton mass imposed through the dispersion relation, we scrutinize the possibility of detecting traces of MG in the PTA observational data. We find that massive GWs predict better fits for the observed pulsar correlations. Future PTA missions with more precise data will hopefully be able to detect the GW additional polarization modes and might be effectively used to constrain the graviton mass. Introduction —The standard cosmological concordance model assumes that general relativity (GR) is the correct theory of gravity on cosmological length and time scales, and that the acceleration of the universe’s expansion is due to a cosmological constant ( \Lambda ) that has a time-independent energy density and becomes dominant at late times Dodelson and Schmidt 2020 . Despite the success of the concordance model, there are several unanswered questions, including the gauge hierarchy problem, the smallness of gravity compared to the other standard model forces, and the failure to formulate a unified theory of quantum gravity, among many others Dvali 2013 ; Moffat 1998 . These puzzles suggest that GR is not suitable for describing physical processes at cosmological scales, and thus, one possibility is to assume that the true theory of gravity differs from GR de Rham and Tolley 2023 . One of the most active areas of research in gravity theory is in massive gravity (MG), which stems from the assumption that the graviton has a non-zero mass m_{g} . It may seem at first like a strange assumption, but there is no reason why the mass of the force carrier of gravity must be zero. The idea of a nonzero graviton mass has a long history, starting from the formulation of MG at the linear level by Fierz and Pauli Fierz and Pauli 1939 in the 1930s. In contrast to GR, where gravitational waves (GWs) possess just two degrees of freedom with helicity (spin) \pm 2 , tensor modes, generic MG theories have an additional three degrees of freedom, namely the helicity \pm 1 vector and 0 scalar modes. As a result, MG is subject to van Dam-Veltman-Zakharov (vDVZ) discontinuity van Dam and Veltman 1970 ; Zakharov 1970 , where the five modes fail to reduce to the two tensor modes that we expect in GR in the massless limit. Taking into account the nonlinear effects of the strong gravitational potential, the Vainshtein mechanism Vainshtein 1972 is able to do away with the additional vector and scalar modes, freeing MG from the vDVZ discontinuity 1 1 1 GR is recovered in a strong gravitational field Tasinato et al. 2013a , allowing us to verify GR in terrestrial and solar system level tests. . The effects of MG appear only on cosmological scales, possibly leading to an accelerated expansion D’Amico et al. 2011 . However, extensions in the nonlinear regime are unsatisfactory due to the presence of an unhealthy sixth ‘‘ghost’’ mode 2 2 2 Until 2010, it was thought that all Lorentz-invariant MG theories were characterized by the unhealthy presence of the ghost-mode, and thus were not valid de Rham et al. 2011 . Boulware and Deser 1972 . More recently, groundbreaking progress has been made through the formulation of ghost-free MG in the de Rham-Gabadadze-Tolley (dRGT) theory de Rham and Gabadadze 2010 ; de Rham et al. 2011 , and its generalization to bigravity Hassan and Rosen 2012 (see Ref. de Rham et al. 2023 for a review). Since then, many different modifications of dRGT and bigravity have been proposed Hinterbichler 2012 ; de Rham 2014 ; Koyama 2016 ; de Rham et al. 2017 ; Hinterbichler 2016 ; Cusin et al. 2017 ; Kenna-Allison et al. 2020 ; Kazempour et al. 2022 ; Högås and Mörtsell 2021a ; Högås and Mörtsell 2021b ; Högås and Mörtsell 2021c ; Högås et al. 2020 ; Gialamas and Tamvakis 2025 ; Gialamas and Tamvakis 2024 ; Gialamas and Tamvakis 2023a ; Gialamas and Tamvakis 2023b ; Dwivedi and Högås 2024 , resulting in the analysis of the consequences of MG and massive cosmologies (pioneered by Ref. D’Amico et al. 2011 and further explored by Refs. Gratia et al. 2012 ; Gumrukcuoglu et al. 2012a ; Maeda and Volkov 2013 ; Akrami et al. 2015 ; Zhang et al. 2013 ; Lambiase 2012 ; Koyama et al. 2011 ; Tasinato et al. 2013b ; Solomon et al. 2015 ; Akrami et al. 2013 ; Koennig et al. 2014 ; Gumrukcuoglu et al. 2016 ; Heisenberg et al. 2024 ; Smirnov 2025 ; Comelli et al. 2014 ), such as in the context of the creation of GWs and their propagation De Felice et al. 2013 ; Gümrükçüoğlu et al. 2013 ; De Felice et al. 2013 ; De Felice and Mukohyama 2016 ; Babichev and Brito 2015 ; Sakstein et al. 2017 . The direct detection of GWs at high frequencies by interferometers Abbott et al. 2016a ; Abbott et al. 2016b ; Akutsu et al. 2021 ; Acernese et al. 2015 and the more recent detection of the stochastic GW background (SGWB) through various PTA collaborations Agazie et al. 2023 ; Xu et al. 2023 ; Antoniadis et al. 2023 ; Antoniadis et al. 2023a ; Antoniadis et al. 2023b ; Zic et al. 2023 ; Reardon et al. 2023 have ignited further interest in GW astronomy, giving us the unique possibility of constraining fundamental physics and understanding the nature of gravity. In our study, we used data collected by two GW detection missions, namely NANOGrav Agazie et al. 2023 and Chinese PTA (CPTA) Xu et al. 2023 , chosen for their unique approach to their data, to help us better understand gravity and connect MG to observables. In this Letter, we derive the overlap reduction function (ORF) and the dispersion relation in the case of ghost-free MG, taking into account the effect of these extra polarization modes. Unlike Refs. Liang and Trodden 2021 ; Anholm et al. 2009 ; Arjona et al. 2024 ; Lee 2013 ; Bernardo and Ng 2023 ; Bernardo and Ng 2024a ; Bernardo and Ng 2024b ; Bernardo and Ng 2025 , we place an emphasis on the non-suppression of the exponential factors in the ORF, made possible by analyzing them within the context of an optimistic PTA observation prospect. In what follows, we use natural units, setting c= \ \hbar= \ k_{B}= \ 1 . Massive gravity —The following

Read the complete text