Envisioning the Distance Ladder in the Era of the Habitable Worlds Observatory

Gagandeep Anand, 1 Meredith Durbin, 2 Rachael Beaton 1, Contributing Authors: Joseph Jensen (Utah Valley University), Adam Riess (Johns Hopkins University), Endorsed by: Howard Bond (Penn State University), Michael Davis (Southwest Research Institute), Chris Impey (University of Arizona), Pierre Ker · 2025

Read Envisioning the Distance Ladder in the Era of the Habitable Worlds Observatory by Gagandeep Anand, 1 Meredith Durbin, 2 Rachael Beaton 1, Contributing Authors: Joseph Jensen (Utah Valley University), Adam Riess (Johns Hopkins University), Endorsed by: Howard Bond (Penn State University), Michael Davis (Southwest Research Institute), Chris Impey (University of Arizona), Pierre Ker (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-02056.txt.

Introduction

Gagandeep Anand and co-authors plan how a future space observatory could sharpen the cosmic distance ladder in a 2025 paper. Measuring the universe's expansion rate to one percent now takes three steps: direct distances, standard candles nearby, and supernovae far away. Each step adds error, so dropping a step is attractive.

The planned Habitable Worlds Observatory should be sharp and sensitive enough to reach the smooth expansion flow with stellar markers alone. That would cut the ladder to two steps. The paper lays out what such a program needs from the telescope and its instruments. It also notes the observatory could measure distances to small galaxies through their pulsing stars.

Catalog record

CREATORGagandeep Anand, 1 Meredith Durbin, 2 Rachael Beaton 1, Contributing Authors: Joseph Jensen (Utah Valley University), Adam Riess (Johns Hopkins University), Endorsed by: Howard Bond (Penn State University), Michael Davis (Southwest Research Institute), Chris Impey (University of Arizona), Pierre Ker
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE33 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-02056

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Envisioning the Distance Ladder in the Era of the Habitable Worlds Observatory Gagandeep Anand, 1 Meredith Durbin, 2 Rachael Beaton 1, Contributing Authors: Joseph Jensen (Utah Valley University), Adam Riess (Johns Hopkins University), Endorsed by: Howard Bond (Penn State University), Michael Davis (Southwest Research Institute), Chris Impey (University of Arizona), Pierre Kervella (Paris Observatory & CNRS IRL FCLA), Eunjeong Lee (EisKosmos (CROASAEN), Inc.), Karen Masters (Haverford College), Kristen McQuinn (Space Telescope Science Institute & Rutgers University), Ilaria Musella (National Institute for Astrophysics (INAF) - Astronomical Observatory of Capodimonte (Naples)), Donatas Narbutis (Institute of Theoretical Physics and Astronomy, Faculty of Physics, Vilnius University, Vilnius, Lithuania), Chow-Choong Ngeow (Graduate Institute of Astronomy, National Central University), Javier Pascual-Granado (Institute of Astrophysics of Andalusia (CSIC)), Nicolás Rodríguez-Segovia (UNSW Canberra), Frank Soboczenski (University of York & King’s College London) Abstract The current state-of-the-art cosmic distance ladder requires three rungs—geometric distances, primary indicators, and Type Ia Supernovae—to achieve a 1% measurement of the Hubble constant H 0 H_{0} . The Habitable Worlds Observatory will have the sensitivity and resolution to reduce this to a two-step measurement, eliminating the third rung entirely and reaching into the Hubble flow with stellar distance indicators such as Cepheid variables and the tip of the red giant branch alone. We discuss the requirements for a program to measure H 0 H_{0} to 1% with HWO here, including telescope and instrument design considerations. We also comment on the potential of HWO to measure distances to low-mass dwarf galaxies via their RR Lyrae stars. 1 Introduction Galaxy distances are a fundamental astrophysical quantity. Distances to astronomical objects translate between observed quantities (relative system or angular values) and astrophysical quantities (absolute system and physical dimensions) necessary to compare objects across space and time. As such, knowledge of precise and accurate distances are required to set the foundation for most extragalactic science. Despite great advances in the extragalactic distance scale in modern times, distances within \sim 100 Mpc ( \sim 300 million light-years) remain one of the most difficult quantities to measure directly. In addition to providing the basis for measuring nearly all physical parameters of nearby galaxies, distances allow us to probe the evolution of structure over a broad range of environments (from sparse voids to rich galaxy clusters), and perform highly precise and accurate measurements of the expansion rate of the Universe, allowing us to provide strict constraints on cosmological models. The latter point is especially relevant given the current state of the “Hubble tension”, a significant disagreement between the model-predicted expansion rate of the Universe at the present day, versus what is actually measured in the local Universe with premier facilities such as Hubble and JWST ( Di Valentino & Brout 2024 ) . While the most recent results from these observatories show little sign of easing this tension, several concerns remain. HWO will allow us to make major breakthroughs in our understanding of the physics driving cosmic expansion and the formation and evolution of the Universe as a whole. This contribution summarizes a Science Case Development Document (SCDD). This SCDD relates to the following topics in the Astro2020 Decadal Survey ( National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine 2021 ) , while also covering topics under the purview of the NASA Astrophysics Program Offices for Cosmic Origins and the Physics of the Cosmos: • What physics drives the cosmic expansion and the large-scale evolution of the universe? • How do the histories of galaxies and their dark matter halos shape their observable properties? • What are the most extreme stars and stellar populations? 2 Science Objective 2.1 Measuring distances out to 100 Mpc using primary indicators The modern distance ladder is precise and accurate (with individual distances routinely achievable at the \sim 5\% level), but still requires great effort and detailed observations. Beyond 100 Mpc, we can use an galaxy’s observed velocity and the Hubble constant as a proxy for distance when needing to determine physical parameters, with minimal uncertainty ( \lesssim 5%) resulting from peculiar velocities due to galaxy-galaxy interactions (although galaxy distances beyond 100 Mpc are still needed for generating maps of peculiar velocity fields themselves). However, within 100 Mpc, uncertainties from peculiar velocities are significant enough that many science cases will require carefully measured distances via resolved stellar distance indicators. With respect to the primary goal of measuring the current expansion rate of the Universe, the Hubble Constant is measured in three steps at present. The first is the geometric foundation, where a physical distance is directly measured from an angular size. The best-known of these is trigonometric parallax ( Lindegren et al. 2016 , e.g., Gaia;) , but orbital modeling of eclipsing binary stars and water megamasers around active galactic nuclei are critical for extragalactic distances as well ( Pietrzyński et al. 2019 ; Pesce et al. 2020 ) . Next are primary indicators, which relate an observed luminosity to a known intrinsic one by the inverse square law of light, and which can be calibrated directly to geometric anchors. These include pulsating variable stars such as classical Cepheids and RR Lyrae, whose pulsation periods correlate with their luminosities, and color-magnitude diagram (CMD) features such as the tip of the red giant branch (TRGB) and J-region asymptotic giant branch (J-AGB), which occur at more-or-less fixed absolute magnitudes at certain wavelengths. The third and last is Type Ia Supernovae (SNe Ia), extremely energetic transient events with roughly constant peak luminosities that can be detected out to great distances in the Hubble flow. HWO, on the other hand, will have the sensitivity and resolution to measure Cepheid distances out to 100 Mpc. This is far enough into the Hubble flow that peculiar velocities no longer dominate redshift uncertainties. This in turn will enable us to put together a two-step distance ladder (anchors and Cepheids), bypassing SNe Ia completely and thereby greatly reducing the total uncertainty budget by dropping the third-rung (SNe Ia) of the present-day distance ladder. SNe Ia still have a number of unsolved problems lingering over their use ( Brout et al. 2022 ; Popovic et al. 2023 , e.g., incomplete understanding of their progenitors, uneven distribution on the sky due to history of ground-based measurements, ground-based photometry with differing instrumental systematics, etc.;) . Figure 1: Main panel: false-color HST imaging of IC 4040, a spiral galaxy in the Coma Cluster at 100 Mpc. The upper inset panel zooms in on a small region of the HST image, showing that individual stars cannot be resolved. The lower two panels show a simulation of the same scene imaged with a 6m version of HWO, which resolves the galaxy into stars. The center panel shows a luminous Cepheid at maximum light ( M_{V}=-6.5 ), and the lower the same Cepheid at minimum light ( M_{V}=-5.1 ). 2.2 Galaxy parameters & population-dependent distance techniques Classical Cepheids will see the most transformative gains for establishing H_{0} with HWO. While JWST is transforming the quality of infrared measurements of Cepheids, its blue cutoff is too red to identify previously unobserved Cepheids, effectively limiting SNe Ia host sample sizes to what is reachable by HST and locking in Cepheid samples in HST-surveyed galaxies at their current number. Figure 1 shows existing HST and

Read the complete text