The importance of the dynamical corotation torque for the migration of low-mass planets
Jesse Weder, Clément Baruteau, Christoph Mordasini · 2025
Read The importance of the dynamical corotation torque for the migration of low-mass planets by Jesse Weder, Clément Baruteau, Christoph Mordasini (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-02050.txt.
Introduction
Jesse Weder, Clément Baruteau, and Christoph Mordasini give planet builders a shortcut for a subtle drag. Their 2025 paper studies the dynamical corotation torque, a force from gas swirling near a young planet that can brake its inward drift through the birth disk.
In quiet, low-turbulence disks this torque matters most, but full simulations are too costly for global models. The authors write simple one-dimensional recipes for the swirling flows on both sides of the planet, including a memory timescale for the trapped flow, and tune them against two-dimensional simulations. The fast recipes matched the heavy simulations across a wide range of cases. Their maps show the torque halving the classic drift for a ten-Earth-mass planet in a young disk.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jesse Weder, Clément Baruteau, Christoph Mordasini |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 75 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-02050
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The importance of the dynamical corotation torque for the migration of low-mass planets Jesse Weder, Clément Baruteau, Christoph Mordasini Abstract Context. Recent developments in the evolution of protoplanetary discs have suggested that planet formation occurs in regions of the discs with low levels of turbulent viscosity. In such environments, the dynamical corotation torque is thought to play an important role by slowing down the migration of low-mass planets (type I migration). Aims. We aim to provide a simple analytical prescription for the dynamical corotation torque for use in 1D global models of planet formation and evolution, and assess the importance of the dynamical corotation torque for the migration of low-mass planets in low-viscosity discs. Methods. We propose simple prescriptions for calculating in 1D the time evolution of the vortensities of the librating and orbit-crossing flows around a low-mass planet, which both enter the analytical expression for the dynamical corotation torque. One of our prescriptions involves a memory timescale for the librating flow, and 2D hydrodynamical simulations of disc-planet interactions are used to assess the memory timescale and validate our model. Results. The orbital evolution of a low-mass planet is calculated by 1D simulations where the dynamical corotation torque features our prescriptions for the vortensities of the librating and orbit-crossing flows, and by 2D hydrodynamical simulations of disc-planet interactions, assuming locally isothermal discs. We find very good agreement between the 1D and 2D simulations for a wide parameter space, whether the dynamical corotation torque slows down or accelerates inward migration. We provide maps showing how much the dynamical corotation torque reduces the classical type I migration torque as a function of planet mass and orbital distance. The reduction is about 50% for a 10 Earth-mass planet at 10 au in a young disc with surface density profile in r − 1 / 2 r^{-1/2} and alpha viscosity of 10 − 4 10^{-4} . Conclusions. In discs with low turbulent viscosity, the dynamical corotation torque should be taken into account in global models of planet formation and evolution as it can strongly slow down type I migration. 1D analytical prescriptions verified by 2D hydrodynamical simulations 1 Introduction Understanding planet formation and evolution has remained a difficult endeavour as many physical processes act simultaneously on different length and time scales. The use of global models in planetary population syntheses helps assess the interaction between these processes (see, e.g., the review by Burn & Mordasini 2024 ), but such global models rely on a good understanding of the underlying individual processes and on having simple prescriptions that still capture their physical nature. One fundamental ingredient of global models of planet formation and evolution is the evolution of the protoplanetary disc, as it impacts how planets grow and migrate. Past models usually assumed discs with alpha turbulent viscosities \alpha_{\mathrm{vis}}\gtrsim\mathrm{a\;few}\times 10^{-3} ( Bitsch et al. 2015 ; Liu et al. 2019 ; Emsenhuber et al. 2021 ; Drążkowska et al. 2023 ) . However, observational constraints on turbulent line broadening from the gas emission of protoplanetary discs, or on vertical/radial diffusion of dust from the modelling of discs continuum emission, indicate that \alpha_{\mathrm{vis}}\lesssim 10^{-3} in the outer part of discs (at a few tens of au, see review by Pinte et al. 2023 ). These values of \alpha_{\mathrm{vis}} are not consistent with what is needed to explain observed stellar accretion rates by angular momentum transport through turbulence ( Hartmann et al. 1998 ; Emsenhuber et al. 2023 ) . This and the lack of physical processes to sustain such high levels of turbulence throughout the disc are part of the reason why MHD winds have gained popularity as a way to transport angular momentum and drive disc evolution ( Bai & Stone 2013 ; Bai 2013 ) . Although a protoplanetary disc that is threaded by a magnetic field is susceptible to the magneto-rotational instability (MRI), detailed modelling including non-ideal MHD effects showed that MRI is suppressed in large parts of the disc from one to several tens of astronomical units (au). Turbulence in this region is thus mostly set by hydrodynamical instabilities and is expected to imply \alpha_{\mathrm{vis}}\lesssim 10^{-4} ( Lesur et al. 2023 , see review by) . This coincides with the region where planet formation is thought to take place. With this in mind it has become very relevant to investigate planet formation and evolution in MHD wind-driven discs at low effective turbulence \alpha_{\mathrm{vis}} ( Ogihara et al. 2015 ; Ogihara et al. 2018 ; Kimmig et al. 2020 ; Kimura & Ikoma 2022 ; Wafflard-Fernandez & Lesur 2023 ; Lau et al. 2024 , e.g.,) . However, moving towards low turbulent viscosities comes with many challenges for planet formation and evolution models as the absence of viscous heating leads to the loss of convergence zones for migration ( Emsenhuber et al. 2021 ) and the absence of diffusion leads to a saturation of the corotation torque, ultimately leading to faster, inward-only type I migration. The presence of an MHD wind promotes flatter or even inverted surface density profiles in the inner disc which slows down or even reverses inward migration ( Ogihara et al. 2015 ) . Further moving towards low turbulent viscosities also promotes the dynamical corotation torque which can reduce ( Paardekooper 2014 ; Ogihara et al. 2017 ; Ndugu et al. 2021 ) or, conversely, also speed up type I migration ( Paardekooper 2014 ; Pierens 2015 ) . In this work we study the importance of the dynamical corotation torque on type I migration in low-viscosity discs. In Section 2 we propose a simple description of the dynamical corotation torque for use in 1D discs models. In Section 3 we run 2D hydrodynamic simulations of disc-planet interactions to investigate the effect of vortensity mixing in the planet’s horseshoe region due to viscosity, which provides parameterisations needed for our 1D model. In Section 4 we verify our model by direct comparison between 2D hydrodynamical simulations and 1D simulations. This enables us to assess the importance of the dynamical corotation torque on planet formation in Section 5 . A discussion follows in Section 6 , which includes notably an alternative parametrisation of the dynamical corotation torque for 1D models, before we conclude. 2 Dynamical corotation torque: preliminaries and memory timescale Classically, planet migration is assessed by calculating the disc torque onto a planet held on a fixed orbit. In 2D non-magnetised disc models, the torque comprises 1 1 1 Thermal torques that arise from accretion onto the planet ( Masset 2017 ) and dust-related torques ( Benítez-Llambay & Pessah 2018 ; Guilera et al. 2023 ; Chrenko et al. 2024 ) are discarded here for simplicity. the Lindblad torque ( \Gamma_{\mathrm{lin}} , angular momentum exchange between the planet and its wakes in the disc) and the static corotation torque ( \Gamma_{\mathrm{c,static}} , angular momentum exchange between the planet and the disc in its horseshoe region; hereafter HS region). Several studies, including Paardekooper et al. 2011 , have studied the static corotation torque for planets on fixed orbits. In particular, when the disc’s turbulent viscosity is high enough, the static corotation torque remains unsaturated whereas it saturates at low viscosity, leaving only the Lindblad torque. When the planet and the disc