Stacking the Deck: Gambling on a Light QCD Axion

Abhishek Banerjee ID, Manuel A. Buen-Abad ID, Anson Hook ID · 2025

Read Stacking the Deck: Gambling on a Light QCD Axion by Abhishek Banerjee ID, Manuel A. Buen-Abad ID, Anson Hook ID (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-02049.txt.

Introduction

Abhishek Banerjee, Manuel Buen-Abad, and Anson Hook study axions that are lighter than their couplings would suggest. Their 2025 paper starts from a multi-copy symmetry model of the axion. A small added link between the Higgs field and a reheating field breaks that symmetry just a touch.

That small break opens a large part of the light axion plane to study. It also removes a fine-tuning flaw of the base model and explains why only our sector was reheated after inflation. Heat effects then force one of two fates on the axion's starting angle. It is pinned near a set value, or it is shuffled at random. The authors frame the odds in gambling terms.

Catalog record

CREATORAbhishek Banerjee ID, Manuel A. Buen-Abad ID, Anson Hook ID
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE65 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-02049

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Stacking the Deck: Gambling on a Light QCD Axion Abhishek Banerjee ID, Manuel A. Buen-Abad ID, Anson Hook ID Abstract We consider axions lighter than what their QCD couplings might otherwise suggest. Starting with a ℤ N \mathbb{Z}_{N} -axion, we introduce a small explicit ℤ N \mathbb{Z}_{N} symmetry-breaking coupling between the Standard Model Higgs boson and a reheaton. This small explicit breaking allows us to populate a large portion of the light axion m a m_{a} – f a f_{a} plane, removes the 1 / N 1/N tuning in the ℤ N \mathbb{Z}_{N} -axion, and explains why only our sector was reheated. Due to finite temperature effects, axions of this sort undergo either “rigged” misalignment, where the axion misalignment angle is effectively π \pi regardless of its initial value; or “shuffled” misalignment, where the initial angle is effectively randomized. I Introduction One of the intriguing properties of the Standard Model (SM) is the smallness of the neutron electric dipole moment (EDM). This puzzling fact, sometimes called the strong CP problem, begs for an explanation. A very popular solution to this problem is the QCD axion Peccei and Quinn 1977a ; Peccei and Quinn 1977b ; Weinberg 1978 ; Wilczek 1978 ; Zhitnitsky 1980 ; Dine et al. 1981 ; Kim 1979 ; Shifman et al. 1980 . The QCD axion dynamically relaxes the neutron EDM to zero, thereby addressing the strong CP problem; at the same time the axion can be cold dark matter (DM), economically solving two problems at the same time Preskill et al. 1983 ; Dine and Fischler 1983 ; Abbott and Sikivie 1983 . The QCD axion is highly predictive. The axion mass is uniquely determined by its coupling to QCD, f_{a} , which yield the well-known QCD axion line. As a popular DM candidate, there are a large number of experiments looking for the QCD axion (see e.g. Ringwald 2024 ; O’Hare 2020 ; Navas et al. 2024 and references therein for a comprehensive list). For a fixed mass, m_{a} , any given experiment will first exclude couplings stronger than the QCD axion before, hopefully, working its way to the QCD axion line itself. Because the QCD axion has a fixed QCD coupling for a given mass, it is interesting to ask if the experiments are excluding any theory on their way to the QCD axion line. For couplings to fermions and photons, the answer to this question is that the experiments are probing a wide variety of axion-like particle (ALP) models. The situation is different for the defining coupling of the QCD axion, because the coupling to gluons is also the coupling responsible for producing the mass of the axion. Experimentally, this feature leads to a variety of interesting signatures, as finite density effects can be very important Hook and Huang 2018 ; Balkin et al. 2020 ; Prabhu 2021 ; Budnik et al. 2021 ; Balkin et al. 2022 ; Balkin et al. 2023 ; Noordhuis et al. 2023 ; Balkin et al. 2023 ; Gómez-Bañón et al. 2024 ; Kumamoto et al. 2024 ; Balkin et al. 2024 ; Banerjee et al. 2025 . Theoretically, to get an axion with the same mass but larger coupling or, equivalently, the same coupling but a smaller mass, it becomes necessary to cancel the calculable QCD contribution to the mass of the axion. There is only one theory that achieves this without fine tuning: the \mathbb{Z}_{N} -axion Hook 2018 . The \mathbb{Z}_{N} -axion invokes several decoupled copies of the Standard Model (SM). By having the axion non-linearly realize a \mathbb{Z}_{N} exchange symmetry, there is an exponential cancellation between the various contributions to the axion mass, making it much lighter than in the canonical QCD case. There are, however, several features and/or issues with the \mathbb{Z}_{N} -axion. Because N is an integer, the theory cannot accommodate every single combination of small m_{a} and f_{a} , but only a discrete set of them. This is good news for falsifiability, as an axion discovery with m_{a} – f_{a} values outside of this discrete set of combinations would instantly disprove the \mathbb{Z}_{N} model, but is also a problem as this implies that there is no theory that naturally populates the entire parameter space. The next issue is that observations require that only one of the identical N SM copies have a significant cosmic abundance; all other sectors must have a negligible energy density. Observational constraints on \Delta N_{\rm eff}\equiv\rho_{\text{dark rad.}}/\rho_{1\nu}\lesssim 0.3 Aghanim et al. 2020 imply that the temperature of any of the \mathbb{Z}_{N} copies of the SM must be much smaller than that of our own, spontaneously breaking the \mathbb{Z}_{N} symmetry. In other words, \mathbb{Z}_{N} -breaking dynamics must be part of our cosmic history. Finally the last issue to address is that, as a consequence of the non-linear realization of the \mathbb{Z}_{N} symmetry, the \mathbb{Z}_{N} -axion has N minima, only one of which solves the strong CP problem for our sector (“our” sector being defined as the sector that was reheated). Thus, solving our strong CP problem requires the axion to land in the correct minimum, which constitutes a 1/N accident. In this paper, we seek to address all of the previous issues with the \mathbb{Z}_{N} -axion. Our approach is to introduce an explicit, but very small, soft \mathbb{Z}_{N} symmetry-breaking coupling between the SM Higgs and the reheaton, the particle 1 1 1 This could be the inflaton itself, or another particle. whose decay reheats our sector. This explicit breaking allows our copy of the SM to be reheated while all the other copies remain cold. Because of this soft symmetry-breaking coupling, our Higgs boson has a minutely different mass from that of the other Higgses copies, resulting in an additional contribution to the axion mass that is aligned with \overline{\theta}=0 for our sector. With the appropriate sign, this additional contribution removes the N vacua degeneracy in favor of a single vacua with \overline{\theta}=0 , solving the 1/N tuning problem. Finally, because there is an additional, extremely small parameter in the reheaton-Higgs potential, the axion mass m_{a} and f_{a} are decoupled from each other. As a result, most of the light axion region in the m_{a} – f_{a} plane can be populated. Finally, the global shape of the axion potential is just the canonical QCD axion potential re-scaled to smaller masses. This distinction is important when it comes to neutron star constraints, as it is not clear if the bounds of Refs. Gómez-Bañón et al. 2024 ; Kumamoto et al. 2024 apply to the \mathbb{Z}_{N} axion, but do apply to the model we present in this paper. The cosmology of our light axions is slightly different from that of the \mathbb{Z}_{N} axion Di Luzio et al. 2021a ; Co et al. 2024 . As we discuss below, there are two main regions of the axion parameter space, which correspond to two different misalignment regimes. In the first regime, which we dub rigged misalignment , there is an early period of oscillations around \theta=\pi , effectively “rigging” the axion initial conditions to this specific value, regardless of what they might have been before. As a result of this “rigging” of the axion’s initial conditions, for this parameter space region,

Read the complete text