Constraining compact dark matter with time-varying quasar equivalent widths

Georgios Vernardos, James Hung Hsu Chan, Frederic Courbin · 2025

Read Constraining compact dark matter with time-varying quasar equivalent widths by Georgios Vernardos, James Hung Hsu Chan, Frederic Courbin (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-02046.txt.

Introduction

Georgios Vernardos and co-authors hunt dark matter in the flicker of distant quasars, looking for compact objects crossing the line of sight. Some dark matter may be solid bodies — black holes or even planets — rather than particles. When one passes before a quasar, its gravity lenses the light, and the spectrum's line strengths wobble in a telltale way. Their 2025 study mines archival spectra of seven hundred seventy-seven quasars.

Nineteen quasars show decisive signs of such lensing. The inferred masses run far below what gravitational wave detectors could ever catch, down toward planetary scales. That range is exactly where primordial black hole theories live. The method revives an old probe with time-domain data. Cosmologists get fresh limits on how much dark matter can hide as compact bodies.

Catalog record

CREATORGeorgios Vernardos, James Hung Hsu Chan, Frederic Courbin
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE58 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-02046

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Constraining compact dark matter with time-varying quasar equivalent widths Preprint: APS/123-QED Georgios Vernardos, James Hung Hsu Chan, Frederic Courbin Abstract One of the possible explanations for dark matter is that of compact dark objects of baryonic origin, such as black holes or even planets. Accumulating evidence, including the discovery of merging stellar mass black holes through gravitational waves, point to a population of such objects making up at least some fraction of dark matter. We revisit a historically heavily used probe, quasar spectra, from the new perspective of time variability and gravitational lensing. From a sample of 777 quasars selected from archival data we identify 19 that show decisive evidence of lensing by compact objects with masses measured in the range 5 × 10 − 5 < M / M ⊙ < 2 × 10 − 2 5\times 10^{-5}<M/\mathrm{M}_{\odot}<2\times 10^{-2} with 99% confidence. This is much lower than what is hoped to be detected by even the most futuristic gravitational wave detectors and analysis strategies, but is crucial for theories of compact dark matter, such as primordial black holes predicted from quantum phase transitions in the early Universe. I Introduction The current cosmological paradigm implies that 85% of the matter content of the Universe remains invisible to the eye Planck2020 . There is a plethora of possible models and interpretations for this so-called “dark matter” (DM), albeit still poorly constrained by observations Bertone2018 . If it exists at all, it is not clear if it is cold Blumenthal1984 , or warmer, depending on the properties of a yet-to-be-discovered elementary particle. Another possible explanation is that it consists of an undetected population of compact, too dim or dark, baryonic objects such as stars, planets, or stellar remnants like black-holes. More exotic objects could be added to this population, such as ultra-compact DM halos Ricotti2009 ; Blinov2021 , boson stars Visinelli2021 , composite DM structures KribsNeil2016 , and primordial black holes Carr2024 . By first detecting such compact objects and subsequently measuring their abundance and mass we can constrain several alternative theories for compact DM, for example, any detection below 3 M ⊙ would be a confirmation of the existence of non-stellar, primordial black holes VillanuevaDomingo2021 . Figure 1: Schematic view of microlensing by an isolated compact object passing in front of a (non-strongly-lensed) quasar. Left: at some reference time, t_{0} , a quasar accretion disk (black) is located within a region of the sky (shown in grey) where the lensing magnification due to a foreground compact object is above a given threshold, \mu_{\rm thres} . Some time, t , later (many years), the quasar has moved away from this region and is not lensed anymore. Right: As the Narrow Line Region (NLR) of the quasar is much larger than the accretion disk and than the lensing cross-section, shown in black and grey on the left panel respectively, it is unaffected by microlensing. As a result, the equivalent width, W_{0} , measured at t_{0} when the continuum was magnified with respect to the lines, becomes larger at time t when there is no microlensing anymore. The present work investigates how to optimise the detection of a change in equivalent width and assesses the probability that it is due to microlensing and not intrinsic quasar variability. The time scales we consider are of the order of a decade between t_{0} and t . The first place to look for compact DM has historically been the halo of our own Galaxy and one of the main probes for doing so is gravitational lensing. Microlensing experiments in the Galactic halo (MACHO and EROS; Alcock1993 ; Aubourg1993 ) and bulge (OGLE; Udalski1993 ; Paczynski1986 ) concluded that less than 25% of the dark matter content in the Milky Way is in the form of compact objects of <1 M ⊙ , while more recent observations of the Large Magellanic Cloud have shown that no more than 10% of DM can be attributed to objects with masses <10^{3} M ⊙ Mroz2024 . The discovery of gravitational waves from compact binary systems Abbott2016 with mass above 10 M ⊙ Hutsi2020 reinvigorated these efforts, with Sahu2022 even reporting the discovery of an intermediate mass black hole ( \sim 7 M ⊙ ) from a long-duration (t \sim 276 days) astrometric microlensing event in the Galactic bulge. Looking for compact dark object in our Galaxy is an ongoing effort, with a new technique proposed very recently that searches for dimmed instead of amplified lensing events Bramante2025 . Given the accepted paradigm of structure formation via hierarchical gravitational collapse, massive halos populated by galaxies are the places to look for compact DM outside our Galaxy. Such dense places in the Universe are galaxy clusters where super-magnified stars lensed by compact objects have been detected Oguri2018 ; Muller2024 . The existence of free-floating compact objects in the inter-galactic space along random lines of sight has not been excluded either. Population studies of lensing effects on type I-a Supernova light curves Zumalacarregui2018 ; Dhawan2023 and other transient events, such as time-delayed signals present in Gamma Ray Bursts Paynter2021 or interference patterns in Fast Radio Bursts Leung2022 , have also provided measurements of mass and abundance of compact objects. But perhaps the most mainstream probe for detecting compact DM throughout the decades have been quasars. A higher optical depth to lensing by compact objects is to be expected in strongly lensed quasars, which can display “anomalous flux ratios” between their lensed images Wen2022 ; Dike2023 , however, similar lensing signatures can occur in field quasars if we assume the presence of a large population of almost free-floating compact objects. The principle of the method was first proposed by PressGunn1973 and has been continuously revisited since then Canizares1982 ; Hawkins1993 ; Hawkins2011 . Schneider1993 used quasar variability to place an upper limit of \Omega\leq 0.1 to the cosmological density of compact objects with masses <0.1 M ⊙ , depending on the physical size of the quasar emitting region ZackrissonBergvall2003 . Zackrisson2003 concluded that microlensing alone was not sufficient to explain photometric variations in quasars and Hawkins2022 postulated that a combined lensing and intrinsic variability is necessary. Luo2020 identified 16 quasars from SDSS Stripe 82 with bell shaped light curves interpreted as candidate microlensing events. Quasar emission regions of different physical size respond differently to lensing magnification VernardosISSI2024 , especially the continuum and emission line regions: when a compact mass intersects the line of sight to a distant quasar but is light enough not to create resolvable multiple images ( <10^{7} M ⊙ ), the small continuum region is magnified (sits entirely within the caustics), while the much larger Broad and Narrow Line Regions are barely affected. As a result, the line equivalent width in a quasar spectrum, W , is smaller in presence of microlensing than in its absence - Fig. 1 gives a schematic view of the effect. This method, first proposed by Canizares1982 , was employed to study the fraction and mass of such putative compact objects Dalcanton1994 ; Wiegert2003 ; Francis1996 . In this work we revisit the role of spectral deformation of non-strongly-lensed quasars as a probe of compact object DM, expanding on previous works by including a time-dependence: the relative

Read the complete text