A Model for the Capability Approach
2025
Read A Model for the Capability Approach (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-02028.txt.
Introduction
Rohit Parikh examines in this 2025 paper two pressure points in the capability approach, the framework founded by Amartya Sen and Martha Nussbaum. The approach judges well-being by what people can actually do, not only by what they own: equal incomes mean little when one person needs a wheelchair. Parikh, writing for a game theory conference, asks what formal modeling must face.
His first point is spillover: raising one person's capability can endanger another, as teaching lock-picking empowers a thief, or open-carry laws arm some while exposing others. The paper builds toward a model that can hold such clashes, where freedom for one side is risk for the other.
Catalog record
| YEAR | 2025 |
|---|---|
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 23 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-02028
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Model for the Capability Approach Abstract “The capability approach is a theoretical framework that entails two normative claims: first, the claim that the freedom to achieve well-being is of primary moral importance and, second, that well-being should be understood in terms of people’s capabilities and functionings.” Ingrid Robeyns and Morten Fibieger Byskov, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy “whether you should sleep on your back or on your belly is a matter in which the society should permit you absolute freedom, even if a majority of the community is nosey enough to feel that you must sleep on your back.” Sen 1970 International Conference on Game Theory Stony Brook, July 2025 Rohit Parikh City University of New York 1 Introduction The capability approach was jointly founded by the Nobelist Amartya Sen, and Martha Nussbaum. The motivation behind the capability approach is a dissatisfaction with the idea that a person’s well being depends solely on what they have . Rather, what Sen and Nussbaum are suggesting is that what people can do with what they have is primary and what they have is only a tool to get what they want. An example that Sen gives is of two people who have the same income but one of them is handicapped. The one who is handicapped needs a wheelchair and the other one doesn’t, Then having the same amount of money is not an adequate comparison because a person who needs a wheelchair needs help and more resources in order to acquire the same well being as the other one. What we propose to do in this paper is to point to two issues related to the capability approach. A) One is that when one person’s capability is increased then that fact may have negative consequences for someone else. For example if I teach someone to pick a lock then he will acquire capabilities which he did not have earlier. But on the other hand householders will then come under danger of theft or violence. So one person’s increase in capability may have negative consequences for another person. And this of course is the reason why many people object to the open carry law for weapons, which increases the capabilities of some people but puts some others in danger. In 1893 in Southern Africa, British colonial police slaughtered 1,500 Ndebele warriors, losing only four of their own men in the process. This astronomical, almost unfathomable victory was earned not through superior strength, courage, or strategic skill, but because the British were armed with five machine guns and the Ndebele were not. The invention and development of the machine gun by engineers such as Richard Gatling, William Gardner, and Hiram Maxim proved vital in colonization. The extra capabilities of the British had a disastrous consequence for the Ndebele warriors, and eventually for Africans generally. For a more contemporary example, Thomas Matthew Crooks who shot Trump used a drone to survey the area of the Republican convention. The drone increased his capability but brought a danger to Trump and to Corey Comperatore who died shielding his family from the gunman. Of course, Sen and Nussbaum are primarily interested in helping those who are poor and need resources. And machine guns were no doubt far from their minds. But once we intrroduce the notion of capability, we do need to ask, what kind of capability? And capability for what? . When I teach a man to fish, I do increase his capability in some way. He will be able to feed himself and his family. But surely the fish are going to have a different view of that increase in capability. The literature on the capability approach does not seem to explicitly acknowledge the game theoretic issues but these can clearly arise when one person’s action increasing his utility may have the side effect of another person’s utility becoming decreased. And can the other person retaliate in some way? We will return to this issue later on. B) However a second issue that we want to address here is the following: namely what is the quantitative measure that goes with the capability approach? For example let’s suppose that a town has enough resources to build a swimming pool or alternately to have a bus line to a nearby city. Now the swimming pool will obviously increase the capability of some people who want to be able to swim but cannot afford a pool at home. The bus line will increase the capability of some other people who will then be able to travel to the nearby city to work there. Which should the town do? Obviously the town needs some measure that says that the swimming pool will cause so much increase in capability and the bus line will result in some other increase in capability. Which is greater? And which sub-population will benefit? The increases may not be for the same sub-population and we need some measure to decide whether to do the one or the other. 2 The Model In this model, there is a finite set \cal A of agents, a set \cal W of worlds. Moreover each agent i has a set of functions (capabilities) from \cal W to \cal W . The set of functions of agent i will be denoted C_{i,k} where k ranges over the capabilities of agent i . If an agent i has capability f then she can use f to move (the world) from w to f(w) . Moreover for each world w\in{\cal W} and each individual i there is a value v(i,w) which is the value of agent i in world w . If the agent i is in the world w and uses capability f her value will change from v(i,w) to v(i,f(w)) . If v(i,f(w)) is larger than v(i,w) then she will carry out the action f . If Aditi is in a world w where there is no ice cream, f is the procedure of walking to an ice cream shop, then her value, by applying f , will increase from v(a,w) to v(a,f(w)) . She will be happier and enjoy the ice cream. And note that she needed not only the money to buy the ice cream but also the existence of the ice cream shop. But the value of another agent m who is Aditi’s mother may also change as a result of Aditi applying f . The mother will worry, “where is my daughter?” So m ’s value may decrease. We note that when Aditi changes the world she changes it both for herself and for her mother and even for the ice cream shop which acquires a tiny bit of revenue. To avoid this problem we may require an independence condition that when an agent i applies a capability f , only i ’s value can change and no one else’s value will change. Aditi can walk to the ice cream shop without her mother worrying. Thus if f is a capacity of i and j is another agent, distinct from i and w is a world, then v(j,w)=v(j,f(w) . We discuss a possible formalization of the independence condition in a later section. Of course the real