The Cosmological analysis of X-ray cluster surveys
N. Cerardi, M. Pierre, F. Lanusse, X. Corap · 2025
Read The Cosmological analysis of X-ray cluster surveys by N. Cerardi, M. Pierre, F. Lanusse, X. Corap (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-01820.txt.
Introduction
Nicolas Cerardi, Marguerite Pierre, François Lanusse, and Xavier Corap wrote a 2025 paper on using galaxy clusters to measure the universe. The catalog title drops the paper's number and subtitle, which the head restores. Clusters are the largest held-together structures in space, and counting them across time reveals how structure grows. Standard counts rely on rough rules linking a cluster's glow to its mass.
The team skip those rules. They built a fast machine learning tool trained on simulations that models the hot gas in clusters directly, with real physical effects included. A pipeline then predicts cluster counts for a given universe. This proof of concept aims for cleaner measures with fewer built-in guesses.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | N. Cerardi, M. Pierre, F. Lanusse, X. Corap |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 69 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-01820
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Cosmological analysis of X-ray cluster surveys N. Cerardi, M. Pierre, F. Lanusse, X. Corap Abstract Context. Galaxy clusters, the pinnacle of structure formation in our universe, are a powerful cosmological probe. Several approaches have been proposed to express cluster number counts, but all these methods rely on empirical explicit scaling relations that link observed properties to the total cluster mass. These scaling relations are over-parametrised, inducing some degeneracy with cosmology. Moreover, they do not provide a direct handle on the numerous non-gravitational phenomena that affect the physics of the intra-cluster medium. Aims. We present a proof-of-concept to model cluster number counts, that bypasses the explicit use of scaling relations. We rather implement the effect of several astrophysical processes to describe the cluster properties. We then evaluate the performances of this modelling for the cosmological inference. Methods. We developed an accelerated machine learning baryonic field-emulator, based on an extension of the Lagrangian Deep Learning and trained on the CAMELS/IllustrisTNG simulations. We then created a pipeline that simulates cluster number counts in terms of XMM observable quantities. We finally compare the performances of our model, with that involving scaling relations, for the purpose of cosmological inference based on simulations. Results. Our model correctly reproduces the cluster population from the calibration simulations at the fiducial parameter values, and allows us to constrain feedback mechanisms. The cosmological-inference analyses indicate that our simulation-based model is less degenerate than the approach using scaling relations. Conclusions. This novel approach to model observed cluster number counts from simulations opens interesting perspectives for cluster cosmology. It has the potential to overcome the limitations of the standard approach, provided that the computing resolution and the volume of the simulations will allow a most realistic implementation of the complex phenomena driving cluster evolution. VII. Bypassing scaling relations with Lagrangian Deep Learning and Simulation-based inference. 1 Introduction One of the most intriguing open question of modern cosmology, the nature of dark matter (DM), was raised almost a century ago by the study of velocities in galaxy clusters ( Zwicky 1933 ) and, so far, remains unanswered. At the turn of the third millennium, extensive supernova studies showed that, in the local Universe, expansion is accelerating ( Riess et al. 1998 ; Perlmutter et al. 1999 ) . This indicates that the present-day Universe is under the influence of some “negative pressure”, the so-called dark energy (DE). The matter-energy budget of the local Universe, thus only allows for a few percent of luminous baryonic matter. To date, the simplest cosmological framework that accounts for the largest sample of observational facts is the \Lambda CDM model, within the framework of General Relativity, where the DE is the cosmological constant \Lambda . We have now entered the era of precision cosmology, where large and deep extragalactic surveys are multiplying: eROSITA ( Predehl et al. 2021 ) , DESI ( DESI Collaboration et al. 2022 ) , Euclid ( Collaboration et al. 2024 ) , LSST ( Ivezić et al. 2019 ) , CMB-S4 ( Abazajian et al. 2019 ) , SKA ( Maartens et al. 2015 ) and ATHENA ( Nandra et al. 2013 ) . These facilities should allow testing theoretical models beyond \Lambda CDM, by combining various cosmological probes. Galaxy clusters hold a privileged position in this quest. As the ultimate product of hierarchical structure formation, clusters, the nodes of the cosmic web, are sensitive to both the growth of structures and to the geometry of the Universe. In particular, they occupy the high end of the halo mass function (HMF), which is very sensitive to several cosmological parameters, especially \Omega_{m} and \sigma_{8} . This has motivated numerous cluster number count studies for more than three decades ( Henry et al. 1992 ; Vikhlinin et al. 2009 ; Mantz et al. 2010 ; Bocquet et al. 2019 ; Garrel et al. 2022 ) . The detection of the intra-cluster gas (ICM) in X-ray is much less subject to projection effects than galaxy densities in the optical; moreover, ab initio modelling of the ICM is straightforward. For these reasons, X-ray cluster cosmology has been very productive. Future prospects for this waveband are exciting: from the eROSITA all-sky survey ( Ghirardini et al. 2024 , z\leq 1 ; following the first survey analysis from) , to ATHENA in the next decade ( Cerardi et al. 2024 , 1<z<2 ;) . Similarly, surveys in the millimeter wavelength, also targeting the ICM through the Sunyaev-Zel’dovich effect, offer a promising avenue, from SPT currently ( Bocquet et al. 2025 ) to SPT-3G ( Sobrin et al. 2022 ) and later CMB-S4. The HMF predicts the number of clusters formed per unit mass and volume as a function of cosmic time. Because cluster masses are not directly measurable, scaling relations are used to relate X-ray luminosities or temperatures to mass, assuming hydrostatic equilibrium or using measurements from gravitational lensing to calibrate the mass scale. The slope and evolution of the scaling relations can be predicted from a purely self-similar gravitational collapse of matter overdensities ( Kaiser 1986 ) . However, observed and simulated cluster populations present significant deviations from the expected scaling relations ( Maughan et al. 2012 ; Adami et al. 2018 ; Bulbul et al. 2019 ; Bahar et al. 2022 , e.g. ) . The reason is twofold. First, each cluster is affected by its connections to the cosmic web, leading to non-spherical collapse and merger events, hence to departure from equilibrium ( Arnaud et al. 2010 ; Mantz et al. 2016 ) . Second, strong radiative cooling occurs at the cluster centres and non-gravitational processes inject energy into the ICM (from active galactic nuclei, or AGN, and supernova feedback, turbulence and magnetic fields). Fitting power-laws with intrinsic dispersion (possibly as a function of redshift) is an easy way to encapsulate all non-gravitational effects, in order to render the global properties of a cluster sample. However, these empirical scaling-relation coefficients are numerous (see table 5 ) and degenerate with cosmology; e.g. are clusters in a given mass range not detected because they have not formed yet, or because they are under-luminous, or too extended? Moreover, scatter (and its evolution) is a key parameter in the relations but is difficult to measure because of selection effects. All in all, while useful for implementing the necessary mass-observable connections in the cosmological analysis, scaling relations are over-parametrised and do not allow direct insights into the individual non-gravitational processes that galaxy clusters experience. To date, all cluster count analyses used empirical scaling relations in their approach to cosmology. (e.g Vikhlinin et al. 2009 ; Mantz et al. 2010 , with mass and luminosity, respectively) . Clerc et al. 2012b ; Clerc et al. 2012a proposed to forward model the theoretical number counts from the HMF down to the clusters properties, as registered by the detector (ASpiX method). In this new approach, the cluster population is summarised into a 3D X-ray Observable Diagram (XOD) combining count-rate, hardness ratio and redshift ( CR , HR , z ), analogous to a flux, colour, redshift diagram in X-rays. Although the subsequent cosmological analysis bypasses the calculation of the individual clusters masses and provides better control on the measurement errors, it still relies