About the relatively uniform completion of a principal ideal

Elmiloud Chil · 2025

Read About the relatively uniform completion of a principal ideal by Elmiloud Chil (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-01507.txt.

Introduction

Elmiloud Chil wrote a short mathematics note in 2025 about the relatively uniform completion of a principal ideal, a key construction in the theory of rings. A later paper had claimed to provide a counterexample to one of Chil's earlier results. If correct, that example would have overturned the result. Chil examines the claimed example in detail and shows that its details are false. He also shows that the example is in fact compatible with his original result. The note therefore concludes that the claimed counterexample does not stand.

Catalog record

CREATORElmiloud Chil
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE5 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-01507

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

About the relatively uniform completion of a principal ideal
Elmiloud Chil

Abstract
In [2] the author claims to provide a counterexample to a result in a recent paper [1]. In this note, we prove that the details of his example is false and this example is compatible with our result in [1] and so is not a countreexample.



2010 Mathematics Subject Classification.
06F25, 46A40.

Keywords:
Riesz spaces, uniformly complete.

A Riesz space
E
is called
Archimedean
if for each non zero
a\in E

the set
\left\{na,n=\pm 1,\pm 2,...\right\}
has no upper bound in
E
. In
order to avoid unnecessary repetition we will assume throughout the paper that
all Riesz spaces under consideration are Archimedean.

A Riesz space is called
Dedekind complete
whenever every nonempty
subset that is bounded from above has a supremum. Let us say that a vector
subspace
G
of a Riesz space
E
is
majorizing

E
whenever for each

x\in E
there exists some
y\in G
with
x\leq y
.(or, equivalently whenever
for each
x\in E
there exists some
y\in G
with
y\leq x
)
.
A Dedekind
complete Riesz space
L
is said to be a
Dedekind completion
of the
Riesz space
E
whenever
E
is Riesz isomorphic to an order dense majorizing
Riesz subspace of
L
(which we identify with
E
). It is a classical result
that every Archimedean Riesz space
E
has a Dedekind completion, which we
shall denoted by
E^{\delta}
.

The relatively uniform topology on Riesz spaces plays a key role in the
context of this work. Let us recall the definition of the
relatively
uniform convergence
. Let
E
be an Archimedean Riesz space and an element

u\in E^{+}
. A sequence
(x_{n})_{n}
of elements of
E

converges
u-uniformly
to the element
x\in E
whenever, for every
\epsilon>0
, there
exists a natural number
N_{\epsilon}
such that
|x_{n}-x|\leq\epsilon u

holds for all all
n\geq N_{\epsilon}
. In such a case we shall write

x_{n}\rightarrow x(u)
. The element
u
is called the
regulator of
the convergence
. The sequence
(x_{n})_{n}

converges relatively
uniformly
to
x\in E
, whenever
x_{n}\rightarrow x(u)
for some
u\in E^{+}
. We shall write
x_{n}\rightarrow x
(r-u) if we do not want to specify the
regulator.
Relatively uniform limits
are unique if and only if
E
is
Archimedean. A nonempty subset
D
of
E
is said to be
relatively
uniformly closed
if every relatively uniformly convergent sequence in
D
has
its limit also in
D
. We emphasize that the regulator does need not to be an
element of
D
. The relatively uniformly closed subsets are the closed sets of
a topology in
E
, namely, the relatively uniform topology. The closure, with
respect to the relatively uniform topology of the Riesz space
E
in its
Dedekind completion is a uniformly complete vector lattice, denoted by

E^{ru}
and referred to as the uniform completion of
E
. Thus
E
is an
order dense majorizing Riesz subspace of
E^{ru}
.

1
Comments

Following a note published on arXiv [2] concerning the content of my research
findings [1], I consider it both important and necessary for the sake of
scientific integrity to respond to certain comments raised therein.

In [1] we prove the following result

Lemma 1

Let
E
be an Archimedean Riesz space,
0\neq x\in E
,
E_{x}
be the
principal ideal generated by
x
in
E
. Then

(E^{ru})_{x}=(E_{x})^{ru}.

Following we give the details that the author in [2] gave some false arguments.

Example 2

Consider the Archimedean Riesz space
E
consisting of all linear piecewise
continuous functions on
[0,1]
. Let
u\in E
be defined by
u(t)=t
for all

t\in[0,1]
. We have
E^{ru}=C[0,1]
and then
(E^{ru})_{u}
is the
principal ideal of
C[0,1]
generated by
u
. We claim that

(E_{u})^{ru}=(E^{ru})_{u}.

Proof.
First as it is noted in [1] we have
(E^{\delta})_{u}=(E_{u})^{\delta}.
From
this equality the
(r.u)
convergence in
E_{u}
coincide with the one on

(E^{\delta})_{u}
which is the uniformly convergence on
[0,1].
On the other
hand we remark that the inclusion
(E_{u})^{ru}\subset(E^{ru})_{u}
is
obvious. For the converse inclusion, let
f\in(E^{ru})_{u}=\left\{f\in C[0,1]:\exists M\geq 0,\left|f\right|\leq Mu\right\}
then

f(0)=0.
Now, by using a classical approximation Theorem there exists

(p_{n})_{n}\in E
which converges uniformly to
f
on
[0,1]
then

p_{n}(0)\rightarrow f(0)=0
so by replacing
p_{n}
by
p_{n}-p_{n}(0)
which
converges uniformly also to
f
we can assume without loss of generality that

p_{n}(0)=0
which implies that
\underset{t\rightarrow 0^{+}}{\lim}\frac{p_{n}(t)}{t}=p_{n}^{\prime}(0^{+})
the derived of
p_{n}
on the right of

0.
On the other hand
t\rightarrow\frac{p_{n}(t)}{t}
is continuous on

]0,1]
which implies that it is bounded on
[0,1]
and then
(p_{n})_{n}\in E_{u}
and converges uniformly to
f
. Consequently,
f

\in(E_{u})^{ru}.

This means that
(E^{ru})_{u}\subset(E_{u})^{ru}
. Therefore
(E_{u})^{ru}=(E^{ru})_{u}

Read the complete text