Quantum Anharmonic Effects in Hydrogen-Bond Symmetrization of High-Pressure Ice

Qi Zhang, Lei Wang · 2025

Read Quantum Anharmonic Effects in Hydrogen-Bond Symmetrization of High-Pressure Ice by Qi Zhang, Lei Wang (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-01452.txt.

Introduction

Qi Zhang and Lei Wang compute what quantum effects do to ice squeezed to extreme pressures. Deep inside planets, ice passes from a form where hydrogen sits off-center between oxygens to one where it sits at the midpoint, turning ice VIII into ice X. Classical estimates put that switch above 100 gigapascals, while quantum tunneling brings it near 60. Their 2025 study checks the math behind those numbers.

A common density functional understates the energy wall hydrogen must cross, they find, which drops the predicted pressure by more than ten gigapascals against a stricter method checked on Monte Carlo results. A neural method that treats quantum wiggle beyond the harmonic picture found the switch pressure steady across temperatures. It also shaved two gigapascals off simpler estimates. Oddly, the hydrogen bond's stretch softens under pressure in their results, against the usual hardening.

Catalog record

CREATORQi Zhang, Lei Wang
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE26 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-01452

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Quantum Anharmonic Effects in Hydrogen-Bond Symmetrization of High-Pressure Ice Qi Zhang, Lei Wang Abstract The nuclear quantum effects of hydrogen play a significant role in determining the phase stability of water ice. Hydrogen-bond symmetrization occurs as hydrogen atoms tunnel in a double-well potential, ultimately occupying the midpoint between oxygen atoms and transforming ice VIII into ice X under high pressure. Quantum fluctuations lower this transition from classical predictions of over 100 ​ GPa 100~\text{GPa} to 60 ​ GPa 60~\text{GPa} . We reveal that the Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof functional underestimates the hydrogen double-well barrier, thus resulting in a transition pressure over 10 ​ GPa 10~\text{GPa} lower than the strongly constrained and appropriately normed functional, which is validated against quantum Monte Carlo calculations. Nuclear quantum anharmonicity, treated via neural canonical transformation (NCT), reveals that this transition pressure is temperature-independent and observes a 2 ​ GPa 2~\text{GPa} reduction when comparing the non-Gaussian flow models based wavefunction compared to the self-consistent harmonic approximation. Despite increasing pressure typically shortens chemical bonds and hardens phonon modes, NCT calculations reveal that hydrogen bond softens hydrogen-oxygen stretching in ice VIII upon pressure. Introduction .– Water is one of the most abundant hydrogen-containing compounds in nature. In water ice, each molecule can form up to four hydrogen bonds with neighboring molecules, creating a unique hydrogen-bonded network that gives rise to a remarkable diversity of crystal structures Loerting et al. 2020 . At ambient conditions, each hydrogen atom forms a covalent bond ( \text{O}-\text{H} ) with one oxygen atom and a hydrogen bond ( \text{O}\cdots\text{H} ) with another. However, increasing pressure reduces molecular spacing and distorts bond angles, leading to a series of phase transitions. Above 2~\text{GPa} , oxygen atoms form a simple body-centered cubic structure, known as ice VII Bridgman 1937 ; Kamb 1965 . It transforms into the proton-ordered ice VIII [Fig. 1 (a)] Pruzan et al. 1990 ; Pruzan et al. 1992 ; Goncharov et al. 1999 at low temperatures, exhibiting unit cell slightly elongation along the c -axis Besson et al. 1994 ; Pruzan et al. 2003 ; Fukui et al. 2022 . Extensive studies have shown that at pressures over 60~\text{GPa} , water’s molecular structure breaks down, transforming into an atomic solid, labeled as ice X [Fig. 1 (b)], where hydrogen atoms occupy in the center of two oxygen atoms, forming a symmetric hydrogen configuration Schweizer and Stillinger 1984 ; Hirsch and Holzapfel 1986 ; Lee et al. 1992 ; Lee et al. 1993 ; Aoki et al. 1996 ; Goncharov et al. 1996 ; Struzhkin et al. 1997 ; Song et al. 1999 ; Benoit et al. 1998 ; Bernasconi et al. 1998 ; Loubeyre et al. 1999 ; Caracas 2008 ; Lin et al. 2011 ; Meier et al. 2018 ; Li et al. 2024 ; Cherubini et al. 2024 ; Komatsu et al. 2024 ; Monacelli et al. 2025 . The symmetrization of hydrogen bonds is a fundamental phenomenon, providing insights into the behavior of hydrogen-bonded systems under extreme conditions. Figure 1: (a) The sketch of ice VIII, visualized using VESTA Momma and Izumi 2011 . The illustration shows only part of the VIII unit cell, which contains oppositely polarized configurations for net-zero polarization. (b) Ice X. (c) The potential energy surface is calculated using various density functional theory functionals. All hydrogen atoms are moved along the O-O direction, with their positions defined in (a) while the oxygen atoms remain fixed. (d) The energy difference of ice X and ice VIII computed with various density functionals are compared with QMC results. Under the Born-Oppenheimer approximation, the transition mechanism from ice VII/VIII to X is well understood Bernasconi et al. 1998 ; Komatsu et al. 2024 ; Kuwahata and Tachikawa 2024 , being a localized process independent of thermodynamics. This transition is driven by the evolution of the double-well potential energy surface (PES) experienced by hydrogen atoms situated between two oxygen atoms, as illustrated in Fig. 1 (c). At low pressures, hydrogen atoms are confined to one of the wells by a barrier on the order of several electron volts ( eV ). By 60~\text{GPa} , this barrier decreases to the scale of a few hundred meV Pruzan et al. 2003 ; Caracas 2008 ; Lin et al. 2011 ; Bronstein et al. 2014 , enabling quantum tunneling of hydrogen atoms and facilitating the formation of ice X. Above 120~\text{GPa} , the PES transforms into a single well, and the hydrogen atom becomes fully localized at the midpoint, resulting in a highly symmetrical hydrogen structure understood well in classical picture Kuwahata and Tachikawa 2024 ; Cherubini et al. 2024 . Table 1: Transition pressures for the VII/VIII-X phase transition as obtained using various nuclear and electronic methods. {}^{\text{a}} Linear combination of two displaced Gaussian wavefunctions. Reference Year Nuclear method Electronic method Transition pressure (GPa) Schweizer and Stillinger 1984 1984 Non-Gaussian {}^{\text{a}} (variational) Empirical (Morse potential) 45 Lee et al. 1992 1992 Gaussian (variational) GGA (Becke 1988) 49 Benoit et al. 1998 1998 Non-Gaussian (PIMD) GGA (Becke 1988) 72 Kang et al. 2013 2013 Non-Gaussian (PIMD) GGA (PBE-D2) 61.6 Bronstein et al. 2014 2014 Non-Gaussian (Quantum thermal bath) GGA (PBE) 65 Kuwahata and Tachikawa 2024 2024 Non-Gaussian (PIMD) GGA (revPBE-D3) 61 Cherubini et al. 2024 2024 Non-Gaussian (PIMD) GGA (PBE) 43 Cherubini et al. 2024 2024 Gaussian (SSCHA) GGA (PBE) 51 Present work 2025 Non-Gaussian (NCT) meta-GGA (SCAN) 60.6 Spectroscopic experiments have identified the transition to ice X occurring at pressures between 58 and 62~\text{GPa} Aoki et al. 1996 ; Goncharov et al. 1996 ; Struzhkin et al. 1997 ; Song et al. 1999 , but theoretical calculations exhibit considerable discrepancies Schweizer and Stillinger 1984 ; Lee et al. 1992 ; Benoit et al. 1998 ; Kang et al. 2013 ; Bronstein et al. 2014 ; Kuwahata and Tachikawa 2024 ; Cherubini et al. 2024 , as shown in Tab. 1 . Early studies have found the limitations of the local density approximation (LDA) for hydrogen bonds, with generalized gradient approximation (GGA) more accurate Lee et al. 1992 ; Lee et al. 1993 . Subsequent work Benoit et al. 1998 using the path-integral molecular dynamics (PIMD) technique with GGA and predicted P_{c}=72~\text{GPa} . Recently, Ref. Cherubini et al. 2024 employed the stochastic self-consistent harmonic approximation (SSCHA) with a machine learning potential from the Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof (PBE) Perdew et al. 1996 functional, estimating P_{c}=51~\text{GPa} . However, their PIMD simulations surprisingly yielded a much lower value of P_{c}=43~\text{GPa} , further deviating from experimental results. These observations highlight the necessity of accurately determining nuclear quantum effects, anharmonic dynamics, and electronic structure calculations in high-pressure ice. We compare various density functional theory (DFT) functionals, along with quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) Li et al. 2022 calculations, to assess their influence. To capture quantum anharmonicity and thermal effects, we implement the Neural Canonical Transformation (NCT) approach Xie et al. 2022 ; Xie et al. 2023 ; Zhang et al. 2024 ; Zhang et al. 2025 . This method combines a normalizing flow model Dinh et al. 2015 ; Dinh et al. 2017 ; Papamakarios 2019 ; Papamakarios et al. 2021 ; Saleh et al. 2025 to describe phonon excited-state wavefunctions with a probability model for energy level occupations, enabling joint optimization of free

Read the complete text