A Multimessenger Strategy for Downselecting the Orientations of Galactic Close White Dwarf Binaries
Naoki Seto · 2025
Read A Multimessenger Strategy for Downselecting the Orientations of Galactic Close White Dwarf Binaries by Naoki Seto (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-01250.txt.
Introduction
Naoki Seto puts forth a way to pin down how close white dwarf pairs are set in space in this two thousand twenty-five astrophysics paper. The planned space-based gravitational wave detector LISA will watch many such pairs in our galaxy. Waves alone leave a fourfold lack of clarity, though. It sits in the side views of the pairs' angular momentum vectors. That cap limits what the waves tell of how the orbits line up.
Seto shows that time facts from light-based views cut much of that doubt. Radial velocity shifts and light curves can be watched next to the wave signal. They cut the lack of clarity from fourfold to twofold. This multi-messenger plan gives a sound path to tighter reads on how galactic white dwarf pairs are set. It also shows how wave and light views add to each other in the LISA era.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Naoki Seto |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 16 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-01250
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Multimessenger Strategy for Downselecting the Orientations of Galactic Close White Dwarf Binaries Naoki Seto Abstract The planned space-based gravitational wave detector, LISA, will provide a fundamentally new means of studying the orbital alignment of close white dwarf binaries. However, due to the inherent symmetry of their gravitational wave signals, a fourfold degeneracy arises in the transverse projections of their angular momentum vectors. In this paper, we demonstrate that by incorporating timing information from electromagnetic observations, such as radial velocity modulations and light curves, this degeneracy can be reduced to twofold. pacs PACS number(s): 95.55.Ym 98.80.Es,95.85.Sz I introduction Do the orbital angular momenta of Galactic binaries statistically align with Galactic structures? For over 100 years, astrometric and radial velocity data have served as fundamental observational resources for investigating this question (see, e.g., Chang 1929 for early studies). In a recent detailed study, Agati et al. Agati et al. 2015 analyzed 95 binaries within 18 pc of the Sun and found that their angular momenta are consistent with being randomly oriented. More recently, in 2023, Tan et al. Tan et al. 2023 examined the orientations of the symmetry axes of 14 planetary nebulae that host (or are inferred to host) short-period binaries around the Galactic bulge. They reported that the axes are not randomly oriented but tend to be parallel to the Galactic plane. Planetary nebulae consist of gas expelled during the formation of white dwarfs, and the observed 14 axes are considered to coincide with the orbital axes of their associated binaries. Tan et al. Tan et al. 2023 proposed that the Galactic magnetic field at the time of binary formation may be responsible for this observed anisotropy. This finding contrasts sharply with the results of Agati et al. Agati et al. 2015 , who analyzed local binaries, highlighting the need for further observational studies on this issue. The Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA) is designed to have optimal sensitivity to gravitational waves (GWs) in the 0.1-10 mHz range and is anticipated to detect approximately 10^{4} Galactic close white dwarf binaries (CWDBs) emitting nearly monochromatic GWs Seoane et al. 2023 (see also Ruan et al. 2020 for Taiji and Luo et al. 2016 for TianQin). At relatively high frequencies above \sim 3 mHz, CWDBs will likely be individually resolved throughout the Galaxy Seoane et al. 2023 . In contrast, at lower frequencies, the number of CWDBs per frequency bin is expected to be much greater than unity, with only a small fraction near the Sun being resolvable. The unresolved sources contribute to the confusion foreground noise Seoane et al. 2023 . Due to dissipative effects, most of these CWDBs are expected to have nearly circular orbits. Since both the generation and measurement of GWs are inherently geometrical, LISA will provide a fundamentally new means of studying the orbital orientations of Galactic binaries Seto 2024a ; Seto 2024b . Unfortunately, due to the intrinsic symmetry of their gravitational waveforms, there is a fourfold degeneracy in estimating the transverse projections of orbital orientations, a well-known issue in the GW community (see, e.g., Cornish and Larson 2003 in the context of Galactic binaries). For instance, suppose LISA detects an edge-on CWDB located near the Galactic plane, with its angular momentum aligned parallel to the plane. The fourfold degeneracy would prevent us from determining whether the binary’s orientation is truly parallel or instead perpendicular to the Galactic plane. Consequently, relying solely on LISA data imposes significant limitations on our ability to analyze the orientations of CWDBs Seto 2024a ; Seto 2024b . Meanwhile, CWDBs emit electromagnetic (EM) signals in addition to GWs Seoane et al. 2023 . In the LISA era, CWDBs will be key observational targets for multimessenger astronomy. Their sky positions can be estimated from the amplitude and Doppler modulations induced by the motion of the GW detectors Cutler 1998 . At GW frequencies above f_{\rm gw}\sim 1 mHz, Doppler modulation generally becomes more useful. For an observational time longer than 2 years, the typical size of the error ellipsoid in the sky is estimated to be \sim 0.5\,{\rm deg}^{2}(\rho/50)^{-2}(f_{\rm gw}/5\,{\rm mHz})^{-2} , where \rho is the signal-to-noise ratio Takahashi and Seto 2002 . The light curves and the radial velocity data of CWDBs are modulated by orbital motion and should be relatively easy to observe (see, e.g., Burdge et al. 2019 ). In particular, nearly edge-on CWDBs will exhibit distinct eclipsing patterns, making them ideal candidates for follow-up EM observations. Indeed, according to Korol et al. Korol et al. 2017 , as many as \sim 100 eclipsing CWDBs (nearly at edge-on configurations) could be observed simultaneously by LISA and the Vera C. Rubin Observatory. The majority of these \sim 100 CWDBs will be at distances less than \sim 4 kpc and thus belong to the disk component, comprising a small fraction of the \sim 10^{4} resolved CWDBs (see also Littenberg et al. 2013 ). In this paper, we explore the possibility of reducing the fourfold degeneracy of the angular momentum vector, by leveraging multimessenger observations of CWDBs. We revisit the time profile of their GW signals, incorporating orbital phase information partially inferred from basic EM data. We then propose a simple method to reduce the fourfold degeneracy to twofold. In our explanation of the fourfold degeneracy, we considered the example of a hypothetical edge-on binary system located near the Galactic plane, with its angular momentum aligned parallel to the plane. Our reduction method enables us to eliminate the two spurious orientation solutions that are perpendicular to the plane. The approach presented in this paper could further motivate deeper follow-up searches for CWDBs detected by LISA, extending beyond those exhibiting eclipsing patterns. II GW from a circular binary In this section, we review the GW emission from a circular binary and discuss how to estimate its orbital orientation based on the observed GW signal. II.1 Orbital motion Let us consider a circular binary consisting of two stars, \alpha and \beta . We denote its orbital separation by a and the masses of the stars by m_{\alpha} and m_{\beta} , respectively. The orbital frequency is given by f=\frac{1}{2\pi}\left(\frac{GM_{T}}{a^{3}}\right)^{1/2} (1) where the total mass is M_{T}=m_{\alpha}+m_{\beta} . We introduce the coordinate system XYZ , as shown in Fig. 1. The binary orbits in the XY -plane (around the origin), and the orientation vector {\vec{e}}_{j} of its angular momentum is directed along the Z -axis. The positions of the two masses are given by \displaystyle(x_{\alpha},y_{\alpha},z_{\alpha}) \displaystyle= \displaystyle a\frac{m_{\beta}}{M_{T}}(\cos\Phi_{\rm s}(t),\sin\Phi_{\rm s}(t),0), (2) \displaystyle(x_{\beta},y_{\beta},z_{\beta}) \displaystyle= \displaystyle-a\frac{m_{\alpha}}{M_{T}}(\cos\Phi_{\rm s}(t),\sin\Phi_{\rm s}(t),0), (3) where the orbital phase of the binary is \Phi_{\rm s}(t)=2\pi ft+\varphi_{\rm s}. (4) II.2 Observed GW Next we discuss GW emission from the binary. Since CWDBs have small post-Newtonian parameters O(10^{-3}) in the LISA band, we can apply the quadrupole formula (with the exception of possible rare cases Seto 2025 ). Figure 1: Configuration of a binary and an observer. The binary rotates in the XY -plane with its orientation vector {\vec{e}}_{j} pointing toward the Z -axis. At the observer, we introduce the orthonormal vectors ({\vec{e}}_{N},{\vec{e}}_{\theta},{\vec{e}}_{\phi}) . We consider an observer at (r,\theta,\phi) in the spherical coordinate system (see Fig. 1). The polar angle \theta corresponds to the inclination angle. We have \theta=\pi/2 for the edge-on and \theta=\{0,\pi\}