Deducing the Talbot Effect from Electrodynamics

Gabriel Ybarra Marcaida · 2025

Read Deducing the Talbot Effect from Electrodynamics by Gabriel Ybarra Marcaida (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-00820.txt.

Introduction

Gabriel Ybarra Marcaida derives the Talbot effect from Maxwell's equations in a 2025 paper. The Talbot effect is the self imaging of a grating at set distances. Past accounts rest on wave rules set apart from full electrodynamics.

Marcaida builds a model straight from Maxwell's laws and solves it in closed form. In the far limit, the solution matches the classic one in the literature. The near axis limit shows how the rational Talbot pattern arises. He names an ideal grating spread that would give those patterns. A proof shows real gratings meet that ideal in the square sense.

Catalog record

CREATORGabriel Ybarra Marcaida
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE60 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-00820

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Deducing the Talbot Effect from Electrodynamics Gabriel Ybarra Marcaida Abstract Abstract We propose a model based on Maxwell’s equations to describe the Talbot effect. After solving the model analytically, we prove that its solution is equivalent to the one amply found in the literature in the asymptotic limit. By considering the paraxial limit, we showcase how the rational Talbot effect arises, and derive an ideal paraxial distribution that would give such effects. We give a proof of L^{2} -convergence to these ideal distributions for any such grating. The universal nature of the Talbot effect makes our findings pertinent for a variety of physical systems and technological applications. 1 Introduction Lord Talbot discovered in 1836 that in the near field of a diffraction grating a (Talbot) plane depicting a clear replica of the diffraction grating appeared without the need of using lenses, a phenomena that occurred at periodic distances away from the grating [ 1 ] . Half a century later, Lord Rayleigh showed in [ 2 ] that this periodic distance, which he baptised as the Talbot distance , could be computed through the relation z_{T}=2d^{2}/\lambda , where \lambda is the wavelength of the source of light and d is the distance between gratings. It was later found that self-images with a smaller period –or intermediary Talbot patterns– appear at every rational multiple of the Talbot distance. This is now called the fractional Talbot effect [ 3 , 4 , 5 ] . At any distance z=\frac{p}{q}\,\frac{z_{T}}{2} , where both p and q are coprime integers, q well-defined subimages will be formed. q is called the order of the Talbot subimage. Further progress was made in 1996 in a paper by Berry and Klein [ 6 ] . First, they showed that the phases of the Talbot images are related to the quadratic Gauss sums, a number-theoretical object. Secondly, and maybe more interestingly, they proved that the gratings with sharp-edge slits produce fractal intensity graphs at irrational multiples of the Talbot distance. Moreover, an effect analogous to Talbot’s can be found in other media like Bose-Einstein condensates [ 7 , 8 ] , spin-waves [ 9 ] , water [ 10 , 11 , 12 ] or acoustic waves [ 13 ] , among others. In particular, a temporal Talbot effect arises in quantum mechanics, where it is known as the quantum revival of the wave function . The rational Talbot effect can be used to construct a universal set of quantum gates and test the D -dimensional Bell inequalities, as was shown in [ 14 , 15 ] . Another use of the fractional Talbot effect is that it allows for the factorisation of integers, as explained in [ 16 ] . More recently, it was shown in [ 17 ] that the Dirac equation exhibits exact quantum revivals, which might find application in solid state physics. Similar effects can also be found in systems described by the non-linear Schrödinger equation. This equation connects the Talbot effect to other phenomena like rogue waves, which are spontaneous and huge surface waves [ 18 ] , or the evolution of vortex filaments [ 19 ] . Simulations of the evolution of the vortex filaments, where we can see the self-imaging phenomenon, are available at [ 20 ] . All of this shows that our findings are not only relevant for diffraction optics, but for a wide variety of research areas and technological applications. The theoretical approach to the Talbot effect is rather similar in all the papers cited above. Indeed, a scalar theory is used, whose solution is given by solving the Helmholtz equation. This solution is (see [ 21 , 6 ] ) U(x,z)=\sum_{n}\hat{g}_{n}\cos{k_n x}\times\begin{cases}e^{-iz\sqrt{\omega^{2}-k_{n}^{2}}},&0<k_{n}\leq\omega\\ e^{-z\sqrt{k_{n}^{2}-\omega^{2}}},&\omega<k_{n}<\infty,\end{cases} (1.1) where k_{n}=\dfrac{2\pi}{d}n and \hat{g}_{n} is a Fourier coefficient that depends on the grating. This agrees with the solution obtained by instead considering the Fresnel integral, as was proven in [ 22 ] . The problem with this approach is that it relies on solving the Helmholtz equation with Kirchhoff conditions, which means that we impose the value of the field and its derivative on the screen. But Poincaré showed that imposing these two conditions simultaneously leads to a wave that vanishes everywhere [ 23 , 24 ] ! Alternatively, Sommerfeld radiation condition must be used, which states that incoming waves are unphysical and must be discarded [ 25 ] . Although being physically sensible, this approach lacks mathematical justification. Our contributions to the topic are three. First, we propose a time-dependent model based on classical electrodynamics, which we solve exactly and which allows us to identify the field that is described by ( 1.1 ) as the electromagnetic four-potential A^{y} . Critically, this model does not need us to impose Kirchhoff’s boundary conditions nor Sommerfeld’s radiation condition. Next, we prove that our solution agrees with the well-known ( 1.1 ) in the limit t\to\infty . And, finally, we prove the L^{2} convergence of the solution to the ideal distribution in the paraxial limit. The paper is organised as follows. In Section 2 we give a well-posed PDE problem which describes the Talbot effect, which we justify by considering classical electrodynamics an Talbot’s experimental setting. Next, we obtain in Section 3 an analytical solution to this model that establishes the formation and evolution of the Talbot effect. In Section 4 we show that we can recover ( 1.1 ) by considering the asymptotic temporal behaviour of our solution, thus giving a stronger physical and mathematical footing to Talbot’s effect. In Section 5 we use a numerical approach to study the solutions to the wave equation for several parameters, from which we extract what the Talbot effect looks like in the zero wavelength –or paraxial– limit. We propose in Section 6 a distribution that shows an exact rational Talbot effect and prove that the solution to the wave equation converges in the L^{2} sense to it in the paraxial limit for a wide class of gratings. In Section 7 , we study the thin grating case, which relates to the fractal Talbot effect and derive an ideal distribution that describes it. Finally, we show that this distribution displays dark paths , that is, paths along which there is total darkness. 2 Our model First of all, we propose a differential equation and a set of boundary conditions that replicate Lord Talbot’s experiment’s features. This should define a function u(t,x,y,z) that describes the Talbot effect in the region z\geq 0 . This effect appears when a plane wavefront of light is diffracted by an infinite set of equally spaced and identical slits. As we are dealing with electromagnetic waves, we would like our solution to be compliant with Maxwell’s theory. In order to do this, we recall that we may define the electromagnetic four-potential A^{\mu}=(\phi,\mathbf{A}) from which we can recover the electric and magnetic fields through the relations \mathbf{E}=-\nabla\phi-\partial_{t}\mathbf{A},\quad\mathbf{B}=\nabla\crossproduct\mathbf{A}, where we are using natural units ( c=1 ). Maxwell equations for the four-potential are \partial_{\nu}(\partial^{\nu}A^{\mu}-\partial^{\mu}A^{\nu})=J^{\mu}, (2.1) where J^{\mu}=(\rho,\mathbf{J}) is the electromagnetic four-current. We may work in the Lorenz gauge, \partial_{\mu}A^{\mu}=0 , for which ( 2.1 ) reduces to \partial_{\nu}\partial^{\nu}A^{\mu}=J^{\mu}. Now, in our case there are no electromagnetic sources, as we expect those to be somewhere in

Read the complete text