Attributing the point symmetric structure of core-collapse supernova remnant N132D to the jittering jets explosion mechanism

Noam Soker · 2025

Read Attributing the point symmetric structure of core-collapse supernova remnant N132D to the jittering jets explosion mechanism by Noam Soker (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-00757.txt.

Introduction

A supernova remnant's point-symmetric shape points to jets at its birth, Noam Soker argues in a 2025 paper. The remnant is N132D, left by a core-collapse supernova. Soker identifies a point-symmetric morphology with two symmetry axes. One short axis runs from the northwest ear through the center of the iron-rich emission on the other side, and the second follows the long dimension.

The outer zones' symmetry correlates with that of the oxygen-rich gas near the center. Surrounding gas cannot shape that inner material, so the symmetry is a property of the explosion mechanism itself. That matches the jittering jets explosion mechanism, where energetic pairs of opposite jets shape the torus of oxygen-rich gas and the large-scale structure.

Catalog record

CREATORNoam Soker
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE36 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-00757

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Attributing the point symmetric structure of core-collapse supernova remnant N132D to the jittering jets explosion mechanism Noam Soker Abstract I identified a point-symmetric morphology in the core-collapse supernova (CCSN) remnant (CCSNR) N132D, composed of two symmetry axes: the short symmetry axis extending from the northwest ear and through the center of the iron-rich emission on the other side, and the second along the long dimension of N132D and coincides with the extension of the central oxygen-rich gas to the northeast. Namely, the point-symmetry of the outer zones of CCSNR N132D correlates with that of the oxygen-rich gas near the center. The surrounding gas cannot shape the inner oxygen-rich material, implying that the point-symmetric morphology is a property of the explosion mechanism, as predicted by the jittering jets explosion mechanism (JJEM). The oxygen-rich material is known to be in a torus. According to the JJEM, an energetic pair of opposite jets, more or less perpendicular to the plane of the torus, has shaped the torus; this pair is along the short symmetry axis. Another energetic pair, perpendicular to the first one, shaped the elongated, large-scale structure of CCSNR N132D. I discuss how the JJEM accounts for two perpendicular pairs of jets and the unequal jets in each pair. CCSNR N132D is the fifteenth CCSNR with an identified point-symmetric morphology attributed to the JJEM. Because the neutrino-driven mechanism cannot explain such morphologies, this study further strengthens the claim that the JJEM is the primary explosion mechanism of CCSNe. keywords supernovae: general – stars: jets – ISM: supernova remnants – stars: massive 1 Introduction Studies in the last two years have been discussing two competing core-collapse supernova (CCSN) explosion mechanisms, the delayed neutrino explosion mechanism (e.g., Andresen et al. 2024 ; Boccioli & Fragione 2024 ; Burrows et al. 2024 ; Janka & Kresse 2024 ; van Baal et al. 2024 ; Wang & Burrows 2024 ; Bamba et al. 2025 ; Boccioli et al. 2025 ; Eggenberger Andersen et al. 2025 ; Huang et al. 2025 ; Imasheva et al. 2025 ; Laplace et al. 2025 ; Maltsev et al. 2025 ; Maunder et al. 2024 ; Müller et al. 2025 ; Nakamura et al. 2025 ; Sykes & Müller 2025 ; Janka 2025 ; Paradiso & Coughlin 2025 ; Wang & Burrows 2025 ) and the jittering jets explosion mechanism (JJEM), which is the frame of the present study. The JJEM asserts that the primary explosion mechanism of the majority, and likely all, CCSNe involves pairs of jets (e.g., Soker 2010 ; Papish & Soker 2011 ). The magnetorotational explosion mechanism is much older, but significantly differs from the JJEM. In the magnetorotational explosion mechanism, one pair of jets along a fixed axis explodes the star. To maintain a fixed angular momentum axis along which the accretion disk launches a pair of jets, the progenitor of the CCSN must be rapidly rotating (e.g., Shibagaki et al. 2024 ; Zha et al. 2024 ; Shibata et al. 2025 and references to much older papers therein). The requirement for a rapidly rotating pre-collapse core makes this mechanism rare. Therefore, the magnetorotational explosion mechanism attributes most CCSNe to the neutrino-driven mechanism, and I classify it as part of the neutrino-driven mechanism. According to the JJEM, N_{\rm 2j}\simeq 5-30 pairs of jittering jets that intermittent accretion disks (or belts) around the newly born neutron star (NS) launch on a timescales of \tau_{\rm ex}\approx 0.1-10~\rm{s} explode all CCSNe (for a list of the parameters of the JJEM see Soker 2024a ); time is measured from shock bounce, i.e., the formation time of the shock at the newly born NS. In rare cases when the pre-explosion core is rapidly rotating, the jittering of the pairs of jets is at very small angles around the pre-explosion angular momentum axis. Practically, it is a fixed-axis explosion, some of which end with a black hole remnant. The variations in the axes of the pairs of jittering jets might be fully or partially stochastic. The two jets in a pair might substantially differ in their opening angle and power (e.g., Bear et al. 2024 ), and might be at an angle smaller than 180^{\circ} , namely, not exactly opposite (e.g., Shishkin et al. 2025 ). Angular momentum fluctuations in the convection zones of the collapsing core that instabilities above the NS (for instabilities turbulence in the gain region, see, e.g., Abdikamalov et al. 2016 ; Kazeroni & Abdikamalov 2020 ; Buellet et al. 2023 ) amplify cause the stochastic variations in the angular momentum axis directions of the accreted gas that launches the jets along these axes (e.g., Gilkis & Soker 2014 ; Gilkis & Soker 2016 ; Shishkin & Soker 2021 ; Shishkin & Soker 2023 ; Wang et al. 2024 ). Neutrino heating plays a role by adding energy to the jets ( Soker 2022a ) . However, most of the energy originates from the jittering jets, which serve as the primary driver of the explosion. In a recent review ( Soker 2024b ) , I summarized the state of debate between these two alternative explosion mechanisms as of 2024. The neutrino-driven mechanism encounters problems and difficulties that the community often overlooks. I list four issues. (1) There are qualitative and quantitative disagreements between simulations of different research groups (e.g., Janka 2025 ), like on which stellar models explode and which do not. (2) Some modeling of CCSNe deduce explosion energies of E_{\rm exp}\gtrsim 2\times 10^{51}~\rm{erg} (e.g., Moriya et al. 2025 ), more than the neutrino-driven mechanism can supply. Many magnetar models of superluminous CCSNe require explosion energies of E_{\rm exp}\gtrsim 3\times 10^{51}~\rm{erg} that imply explosion by jets (e.g., Soker & Gilkis 2017 ; Kumar 2024 ), a conclusion overlooked by most magnetar modelers. (3) The neutrino mechanism predicts that some massive stars fail to explode, in contradiction with studies that suggest that there is only a small or no population of failed CCSNe (e.g., Byrne & Fraser 2022 ; Strotjohann et al. 2024 ; Beasor et al. 2024 ; Healy et al. 2024 ). Boccioli et al. 2025 suggested that the neutrino-driven mechanism can overcome this difficulty. (4) The most severe and challenging problem the neutrino-driven mechanism encounters is explaining the point-symmetric morphologies of CCSN remnants (CCSNRs; Section 2 ). This problem likely rules out the neutrino-driven mechanism as the primary mechanism of the explosion. On the other hand, the JJEM predicts that many CCSNRs exhibit point-symmetric morphologies, as recent three-dimensional hydrodynamical simulations demonstrate ( Braudo et al. 2025 ) . For this reason, identifying point-symmetric CCSNRs is of high significance in determining the explosion mechanism. In Section 3 , I claim that SNR N132D is another CCSNR with a point-symmetric morphology that supports the JJEM. Because many researchers are unaware of these difficulties or purposely ignore them in papers and review talks, the community overrates the neutrino-driven mechanism, as I discuss in the Summary of this study (Section 4 ). 2 Identifying point-symmetry by eyes The pairs of opposite jets that explode the star in the JJEM might shape pairs of structural features in the descendant CCSNR. I emphasize that in most CCSNe these jets are not relativistic ( Guetta et al. 2020 suggest that most CCSNe

Read the complete text