Asteroids fail to retain cometary impact signatures
Sarah Joiret, Guillaume Avice, Ludovic Ferrière, Zoë M. Leinhardt, Simon Lock, Alexandre Mechineau, Sean N. Raymond · 2025
Read Asteroids fail to retain cometary impact signatures by Sarah Joiret, Guillaume Avice, Ludovic Ferrière, Zoë M. Leinhardt, Simon Lock, Alexandre Mechineau, Sean N. Raymond (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-00753.txt.
Introduction
Sarah Joiret and co-authors ask why asteroids keep no trace of the comets that once rained on them, in a 2025 paper. Long ago, shifting giant planets likely sent a comet bombardment through the inner solar system. Vesta, a large asteroid, had already formed its crust by then. Rocks from Vesta that fall to Earth should carry comet gas if impacts left any behind.
The team combined gas measures in those rocks with collision simulations. Their dynamics show Vesta likely suffered many hits from large comets. Yet no comet xenon signature appears in the meteorites. The resolution is speed: the hits were so fast, and Vesta's gravity so weak, that comet matter escaped. Smaller asteroids should fare even worse, which sets a rule for any future comet signature claim.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sarah Joiret, Guillaume Avice, Ludovic Ferrière, Zoë M. Leinhardt, Simon Lock, Alexandre Mechineau, Sean N. Raymond |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 35 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-00753
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Asteroids fail to retain cometary impact signatures Sarah Joiret, Guillaume Avice, Ludovic Ferrière, Zoë M. Leinhardt, Simon Lock, Alexandre Mechineau, Sean N. Raymond Abstract A bombardment of comets is thought to have occurred in the inner solar system as a result of a dynamical instability among the giant planets after gas disk dispersal ( Tsiganis et al. 2005 ; Gomes et al. 2005 ; Nesvorný 2018 ) . Vesta, the second largest asteroid in the main asteroid belt, likely differentiated before gas disk dispersal, implying its crust witnessed the cometary bombardment ( Bizzarro et al. 2005 ; Schiller et al. 2011 ; Touboul et al. 2015 ; Hublet et al. 2017 ) . The composition of HED meteorites, which represent fragments of Vesta’s crust, could therefore have been altered by cometary impacts. Here we combine noble gas mass spectrometry measurements, N N -body simulations, collision rate calculations, and impact simulations to estimate the cometary contribution to Vesta. While our dynamical simulations indicate that Vesta likely underwent a significant number of collisions with large comets, we find no xenon cometary signature in HED meteorites. This apparent contradiction arises due to the fact that cometary impacts were at high speeds and Vesta’s weak gravitational attraction made it incapable of retaining cometary material. Smaller asteroids are even less likely to retain such material. Therefore, if a cometary xenon signature is ever detected in an asteroid belt object, it must have been acquired during formation, within the same source region as comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko, and have been implanted later into the asteroid belt. 125-characters sentence summary: Asteroids’ gravity is too weak to retain cometary material, explaining the absence of cometary xenon in HED meteorites. Introduction The current architecture of the solar system was largely shaped by the formation and early evolution of the giant planets. The formation of the giant planets led to a first bombardment of asteroids to the inner solar system ( Raymond & Izidoro 2017a ) . Comets were not significantly delivered to the inner solar system at this stage. A later, more disruptive event — the giant planet instability — occurred after gas disk dispersal and scattered comets to the inner and outer solar system ( Gomes et al. 2005 ; Tsiganis et al. 2005 ; Nesvorný 2018 ) , while also shifting the locations of mean motion and secular resonances across the asteroid belt ( Minton & Malhotra 2011 ) . During this second, more intense phase of bombardment, both asteroids and comets impacted the inner planetary bodies, likely contributing to their volatile inventories ( Marty et al. 2016 ; Marty et al. 2017 ) . The timing of the giant planet instability remains uncertain, but it is thought to have occurred within the first 100 million years after gas disk dispersal, possibly even immediately after ( Morbidelli et al. 2018 ; Nesvorny et al. 2018 ; Mojzsis et al. 2019 ; Quarles & Kaib 2019 ; Ribeiro et al. 2020 ; Liu et al. 2022 ; Hunt et al. 2022 ; Edwards et al. 2024 ) . To understand solar system formation it is necessary to determine the effect that this instability - following which collision probabilities with comets were highest in the inner solar system - had on the terrestrial planets and asteroids. Xenon has emerged as an effective tool for discriminating chondritic and cometary contributions to planetary bodies, owing to the distinctive isotopic signatures of chondrites and the recent first measurement from comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko ( Marty et al. 2017 ; Bekaert et al. 2017 ; Pernet-Fisher et al. 2020 ; Zhang et al. 2024 ) . This measurement is thought to be at least somewhat representative of a population of comets because its isotopic characteristics — particularly the deficits in heavy isotopes - align with long-standing expectations for cometary material inferred from the unexplained features of Earth’s primordial atmospheric xenon ( Marty et al. 2016 ) . Indeed, the xenon signature in Earth’s primordial atmosphere, known as U-Xe ( Pepin 1991 ; Pepin 1994 ) , is best interpreted as a mixture comprising approximately 22% cometary (67P/C-G) xenon and 78% chondritic xenon ( Marty et al. 2017 ) . Consequently, the identification of a U-Xe-like signature in a planetary object can be reasonably taken as evidence of cometary contribution. Noble gas isotopic analysis can also be applied to understand impact histories on other planetary bodies, such as Vesta. Howardite, eucrite and diogenite (HED) meteorites are thought to originate from Vesta’s crust ( McCord et al. 1970 ; Consolmagno & Drake 1977 ; De Sanctis et al. 2012 ) . These three types of meteorites constitute the largest sampling available for any differentiated asteroid ( McSween et al. 2011 ) . Their formation ages limit the completion of Vesta’s core–mantle differentiation and crust crystallization to 1 Myr and 3 Myr after the condensation of calcium-aluminium rich inclusions (CAIs) respectively ( Bizzarro et al. 2005 ; Schiller et al. 2011 ; Touboul et al. 2015 ; Hublet et al. 2017 ) . Because the differentiation likely occurred prior to gas disk dispersal, estimated at < 4-5 Myr after CAIs in the case of the solar system ( Wang et al. 2017 ; Weiss & Bottke 2021 ; Hunt et al. 2022 ) , Vesta’s crust should have witnessed the bombardment caused by the giant planet instability. In previous work, the highly siderophile elements (HSEs) budget in HED meteorites was used to infer the intensity and evolution of the chondritic impact rate on Vesta since core-mantle differentiation ( Turrini et al. 2018 ; Zhu et al. 2021 ) . Similarly, their xenon isotopic signature could, in principle, record the cometary impact rate on their parent body ( Marty et al. 2017 ) , if this cometary signature can be retained. In the 1990s, a detection of U-Xe was claimed in the diogenite Tatahouine ( Michel & Eugster 1994 ) . However, later measurements on the same meteorite refuted these results ( Busemann & Eugster 2002 ) . Finding a U-Xe signature, or any xenon signature comprising a cometary component, in HED meteorites would provide evidence of the cometary bombardment on Vesta. We note that Ceres — the largest object in the asteroid belt — has not yet been linked to any known meteorite group, limiting our ability to apply similar geochemical approaches to its history. Vesta is thought to have formed in the terrestrial planet region before being implanted into the asteroid belt early in its history ( Bottke et al. 2006 ; Raymond & Izidoro 2017b ; Mastrobuono-Battisti & Perets 2017 ; Zhu et al. 2021 ; Deienno et al. 2024 ; Deienno et al. 2025 ) . Vesta is part of an asteroid family - Vestoids - that share similar orbits and are thought to have formed from the fragmentation of a common parent body after two major impact events ( Marzari et al. 1996 ; Schenk et al. 2012 ) . Because the Vesta family is relatively tightly clustered in the asteroid belt, the events that disrupted the Vestoids parent body likely occurred after the giant planet instability and main bombardment episodes ( Nesvorný et al. 2008 ; Brasil et al. 2016 ) . In addition, Vesta