Simply slicing knots

Anthony Conway, Patrick Orson, Mark Pencovitch · 2025

Read Simply slicing knots by Anthony Conway, Patrick Orson, Mark Pencovitch (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-00431.txt.

Introduction

A knot can sometimes be capped off by a disc inside a four-dimensional space, a property called being sliced. Anthony Conway and co-authors give conditions for that capping in this 2025 paper, working in a simply connected four-manifold whose edge is the ordinary sphere. The disc they build is locally flat, and the space left around it has a tidy, finite cyclic loop structure.

They also settle when such discs exist after stabilizing, meaning the manifold may first be fattened with standard pieces. Necessary and sufficient conditions are given for the stable case. Slicing questions sit at the heart of four-dimensional topology, where intuition from lower dimensions keeps failing. Clean criteria, the authors show, can still be found.

Catalog record

CREATORAnthony Conway, Patrick Orson, Mark Pencovitch
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE125 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-00431

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Simply slicing knots Anthony Conway, Patrick Orson, Mark Pencovitch Abstract . Given a simply-connected 4 4 -manifold with boundary the 3 3 -sphere, this paper establishes sufficient conditions for a knot in the boundary to be sliced by a locally flat disc in the 4 4 -manifold, whose complement has finite cyclic fundamental group. In addition, necessary and sufficient conditions are described to ensure that such discs exist stably, that is after taking the connected sum of the 4 4 -manifold with copies of S 2 × S 2 S^{2}\times S^{2} . 1. Introduction Given a 4 -manifold N with boundary S^{3} , one can ask which knots K\subset S^{3} bound locally flat slice discs D\subset N with a given disc group \pi_{1}(N\setminus D) . When the disc group is abelian, we call D a simple slice disc. Freedman proved that a knot K\subset S^{3} bounds a locally flat slice disc in D^{4} with disc group \mathbb{Z} if and only if it has Alexander polynomial one [ Fre82 , FQ90 ] . More generally, a knot K\subset S^{3} admits such a slice disc in a simply-connected, compact 4 -manifold N if and only if its Blanchfield form is presented by a size b_{2}(N) nondegenerate hermitian matrix A(t) such that A(1) represents the intersection form of N [ CPP25 ] . We call a knot G -slice in N if it bounds a locally flat slice disc with disc group isomorphic to G . In this article, we investigate which knots are \mathbb{Z}_{d} -slice in simply-connected 4 -manifolds, for d\neq 0 . The criteria we obtain to guarantee a simple slice disc exists will depend on the relative homology class of the hypothesised disc, so this article could also be thought as asking when a given nonzero class x\in H_{2}(N,\partial N) of divisibility d is represented by a simple slice disc (which will necessarily be a \mathbb{Z}_{d} -disc) with boundary a given K . Our main results provide sufficient conditions for this to occur (Theorem 1.1 ) as well as a necessary and sufficient conditions for this to occur stably, i.e. for there to exist an integer k\geq 0 so that K bounds a disc D\subset N\#^{k}(S^{2}\times S^{2}) representing the class x\oplus 0\in H_{2}(N\#^{k}(S^{2}\times S^{2})) (Theorem 1.10 ). In the case that d is a prime power, and provided a disc exists for some k , we give a formula computing the smallest such k in terms of the algebraic topology of N and the Levine-Tristram signature of K (Corollary 1.13 ). Results of the type we obtain in this article, but realising given absolute homology classes by closed submanifolds, were proved in a series of papers by Lee and Wilczyński [ LW90 , LW93 , LW97 ] . Our method of proof has a similar structural approach, and uses their algebraic splitting theorem [ LW93 , Theorem 6.1] as a crucial mechanism to guarantee the slice discs described above in the stable manifold N\#^{k}(S^{2}\times S^{2}) survive the process of destabilising back to N . 1.1. Simple slice discs Given a 4 -manifold N with \partial N\cong S^{3} , and x\in H_{2}(N,\partial N) , we denote by x\cdot x the algebraic self-intersection number of the unique class in H_{2}(N) that maps to x . Our first main result provides sufficient conditions for a knot to bound a simple disc representing a given homology class. Theorem 1.1 . Let N be a compact, oriented, simply-connected 4 -manifold with boundary S^{3} . Let x\in H_{2}(N,\partial N) be a nonzero class of divisibility d , and suppose K\subset S^{3} is a knot such that H_{1}(\Sigma_{d}(K))=0 . The following are equivalent: • The knot K is sliced by a simple disc in N representing x . • (1) \operatorname{Arf}(K)+\operatorname{ks}(N)+\frac{1}{8}(\sigma(N)-x\cdot x)\equiv 0\ \text{ mod }2 if x is characteristic, and (2) b_{2}(N)\geq\max_{0\leq j<d}|\sigma(N)-\frac{2j(d-j)}{d^{2}}\,x\cdot x+\sigma_{K}(e^{\frac{2\pi ij}{d}})| . Here, \operatorname{ks}(N) and \sigma(N) respectively denote the Kirby-Siebenmann invariant and signature of N , whereas \sigma_{K}\colon S^{1}\to\mathbb{Z} is the Levine-Tristram signature of K . For x characteristic, \sigma(N)-x\cdot x is divisible by 8 because the intersection form of N is nonsingular; see e.g. [ GS99 , Proposition 1.2.20] . A class x\in H_{2}(N,\partial N) is characteristic if x\cdot a=a\cdot a mod 2 for every a\in H_{2}(N) and ordinary otherwise. Remark 1.2 . The case x=0 is excluded from Theorem 1.1 , but we note that, since simple discs in N have group \mathbb{Z} if and only if they are nullhomologous (see e.g. [ CP23 , Lemma 5.1] ), the results of [ CPP25 ] already provide necessary and sufficient algebraic conditions for the existence of a simple slice disc. Over the past couple of years, a lot of attention has gone into investigating when a knot bounds a nullhomologous slice disc (i.e. when a knot is H -slice ) in a given 4 -manifold [ CN20 , MMSW23 , MMP24 , IMT25 , MP23 , KMRS24 ] . More recently, there has also been some interest in the case of nonzero classes [ Ren24 , Qin24 ] . Most of these articles focus on smooth obstructions, so Theorem 1.1 can be thought of as a topological counterpart to these recent results. We now highlight some examples and consequences of Theorem 1.1 for small values of d . The case d=1 In the case d=1 of Theorem 1.1 , or equivalently the case that x is primitive, the hypotheses simplify considerably. The condition H_{1}(\Sigma_{d}(K))=H_{1}(S^{3})=0 holds vacuously, as does the second condition, since it reduces to the inequality b_{2}(N)\geq|\sigma(N)| . Corollary 1.3 . Let N be a compact, oriented, simply-connected 4 -manifold with boundary S^{3} , let x\in H_{2}(N,\partial N) be a nonzero primitive class, and let K\subset S^{3} be a knot. • For x ordinary, K is sliced by a simple disc in N representing x . • For x characteristic, K is sliced by a simple disc in N representing x if and only if \operatorname{Arf}(K)+\operatorname{ks}(N)+\frac{1}{8}(\sigma(N)-x\cdot x)\equiv 0\ \text{ mod }2. This corollary recovers [ KPRT24 , Corollary 1.15] , which, given a closed simply-connected 4 -manifold X , concerns sliceness in X^{\circ}:=X\setminus\operatorname{Int}(B^{4}) . Corollary 1.4 . For X\neq S^{4},\mathbb{C}P^{2},*\mathbb{C}P^{2} simply-connected, every knot K\subset\partial X^{\circ} is slice in X^{\circ} . Proof. We prove that H_{2}(X^{\circ}) contains a nonzero primitive ordinary class. If X is spin, any nonzero primitive class is ordinary. In the nonspin case, since X\neq\mathbb{C}P^{2},*\mathbb{C}P^{2} by hypothesis, work of Freedman [ Fre82 ] ensures that b_{2}(X)>1 . We therefore obtain a direct sum decomposition H_{2}(X^{\circ})=\langle x,y\rangle\oplus H^{\prime} for some abelian group H^{\prime} and x,y\in H_{2}(X^{\circ}) , and one verifies that among the primitive classes x,y and x+y , at least one is ordinary. The result now follows from Corollary 1.3 , noting that H_{2}(X^{\circ})\cong H_{2}(X^{\circ},\partial X^{\circ}) . ∎ The proof of Corollary 1.4 shows that every knot bounds a disc in X^{\circ} which represents a primitive homology class; the inclusion of the adjective “primitive” can also be deduced from the proof of [ KPRT24 , Corollary 1.5] . As an example application, note that since 1\in\mathbb{Z}\cong H_{2}(\mathbb{C}P^{2}) is characteristic, Corollary 1.3 shows that a knot K bounds a primitive disc in (\mathbb{C}P^{2})^{\circ} if and only if \operatorname{Arf}(K)=0 mod 2 , recovering [ MMRS24 , Theorem 1.2] . Example

Read the complete text