Minimal Construction of Graphs with Maximum Robustness

Haejoon Lee, Dimitra Panagou · 2025

Read Minimal Construction of Graphs with Maximum Robustness by Haejoon Lee, Dimitra Panagou (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-00415.txt.

Introduction

Haejoon Lee and Dimitra Panagou studied how to build maximally robust networks with as few links as possible in twenty twenty-five. Robustness notions from consensus theory measure how well a network of agents agrees despite some agents misbehaving. Higher robustness tolerates more bad actors but usually demands dense wiring, costly for systems with limited range, energy, or bandwidth.

The authors first prove tight necessary conditions on the edge count any graph needs for maximum robustness, in both the r and the paired (r,s) senses. They then construct two families of graphs that provably hit maximum robustness with minimal edges. Comparisons with known robust structures and simulations show the designs hold up. The results guide building resilient swarms and sensor networks on a wiring budget.

Catalog record

CREATORHaejoon Lee, Dimitra Panagou
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE79 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-00415

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Minimal Construction of Graphs with Maximum Robustness Haejoon Lee, Dimitra Panagou Abstract The notions of network r r -robustness and ( r , s ) (r,s) -robustness have been earlier introduced in the literature to achieve resilient control in the presence of misbehaving agents. However, while higher robustness levels provide networks with higher tolerances against the misbehaving agents, they also require dense communication structures, which are not always desirable for systems with limited capabilities and energy capacities. Therefore, this paper studies the fundamental structures behind r r -robustness and ( r , s ) (r,s) - robustness properties in two different ways. (a) We first explore and establish the tight necessary conditions on the number of edges for undirected graphs with any nodes must satisfy to achieve maximum r r - and ( r , s ) (r,s) -robustness. (b) We then use these conditions to construct two classes of undirected graphs, referred as to γ \gamma - and ( γ , γ ) (\gamma,\gamma) -Minimal Edge Robust Graphs (MERGs), that provably achieve maximum robustness with minimal numbers of edges. We finally validate our work through some sets of simulations. I Introduction Distributed multi-agent systems have many practical uses, ranging from information gathering [ 1 ] , target tracking [ 2 ] , to collaborative decision making [ 3 ] . A fundamental multi-agent systems’ objective is consensus, under which multiple agents reach agreement on common state values. However, it is known that performance of consensus deteriorates significantly when one or more misbehaving agents share wrong, or even adversarial, information with the system. Resilient consensus in the presence of misbehaving agents has been studied extensively [ 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 ] . In [ 4 , 6 , 8 ] , an algorithm called Weighted Mean-Subsequence-Reduced (W-MSR) was introduced to allow the non-misbehaving agents (often called normal ) to reach consensus despite the presence of misbehaving agents. Unlike approaches such as those in [ 12 , 13 , 14 ] , which rely on trust assessments - often at the cost of increased computational complexity - W-MSR instead achieves resilient consensus through a rule-based filtering strategy that discards extreme values. When applied to graphs satisfying the topological properties of r -robustness or (r,s) -robustness, W-MSR guarantees that normal agents can converge to a value within the convex hull of their initial conditions, even in the presence of a bounded number of adversaries. In general, a higher robustness in a communication graph allows normal agents to tolerate a larger number of misbehaving agents while achieving consensus through the W-MSR algorithm [ 4 ] . Consequently, maximizing the robustness of a graph is highly desirable. However, achieving higher robustness by definition requires a higher number of edges, often referred to as edge counts. This results in dense and complex graph structures, which can pose challenges for certain systems due to practical constraints such as limited communication range, bandwidth, and energy. This clear tradeoff between robustness levels and edge counts motivates our interest in finding the fundamental structures behind these robust graphs. We first discover the smallest edge counts possible to achieve maximum levels of robustness. Leveraging this, in this paper, we then introduce and construct two classes of graphs that achieve the maximum robustness with a minimal set of edges for any given number of nodes. Several studies have attempted to indirectly address the tradeoff between robustness and edge counts by relaxing the connectivity of graphs. Some have explored time-varying network topologies to reduce connectivity requirements [ 15 , 16 , 17 ] . In [ 18 ] , the concept of trusted agents, who are always deemed fault-free, is introduced to maintain robustness with fewer edges. Furthermore, robustness of multi-hop communication graphs has been investigated in [ 19 ] . While these works aim to relax the connectivity requirements for r - and (r,s) -robustness to some extent, their results still remain constrained by the structures fundamental to the robustness definitions. A deeper understanding of the fundamental or minimal graph structures that preserve r - and (r,s) -robustness would further provide insights into these methods for effectively reducing these connectivity constraints. Despite its merits, identifying the fundamental structures for given levels of robustness is particularly challenging due to its combinatorial nature. In fact, determining r robustness is a coNP-complete problem [ 8 ] . Although algorithms for computing exact robustness exist [ 20 , 21 ] , they scale poorly with the number of nodes. This computational bottleneck makes brute-force search approaches impractical. Although there have been works to speed up computations with sampling-based [ 22 ] , heuristics [ 23 ] , or machine learning-based approaches [ 24 ] , they either provide approximations without guarantees or require specific assumptions about graph topologies. In addition, other works under-bound a given graph’s robustness with its algebraic connectivity \lambda_{2} (the second smallest eigenvalue of a graph’s Laplacian matrix) [ 25 , 26 ] or with its minimum degree [ 27 , 28 ] , which are generally simpler and faster to compute. However, these bounds can be too loose for many graph structures, limiting its practicality in general applications. To circumvent the combinatorial issue, many researches have focused on the construction and analysis of specific graph classes with predetermined r - and (r,s) -robustness properties. A complete graph with n nodes is \lceil\frac{n}{2}\rceil -robust, indicating that \lceil\frac{n}{2}\rceil is the maximum level of r -robustness any graph of n nodes can achieve [ 4 ] . Authors of [ 29 ] presented a class of circulant digraphs whose robustness levels are directly related to their connectivity parameter k . A preferential-attachment method is investigated in [ 6 , 4 , 8 ] for scalable robust graph constructions. The authors in [ 30 ] study the construction of a class of undirected r -robust graphs with minimum number of nodes to achieve certain robustness. Furthermore, robustness levels of various graph structures, such as geometric and random graphs [ 31 , 32 , 8 , 33 , 34 ] have been explored. Still, understanding the fundamental structural properties of general r - and (r,s) -robust graphs remains an open problem. While the authors in [ 35 ] have established the lower bounds on edge counts and construction mechanisms for undirected (2,2) -robust graphs with any number of nodes, these results do not generalize to other robustness levels. In [ 6 , 4 ] , the minimum degree requirements for r - and (r,s) -robust graphs are presented. Nevertheless, these bounds are local in the sense that they only apply to individual nodes. The concept of minimal edge sets for (r,s) -robust graphs has been introduced in [ 36 ] , though specific scalable construction mechanisms are not discussed. I- 1 Contributions In this paper, we explicitly explore the necessary structural properties of graphs with maximum r - and (r,s) -robustness, building upon our previous work [ 37 ] , in which we have constructed graphs that achieve maximum r -robustness with a minimal set of edges. In this paper, we aim to paint the complete picture of the tradeoff between the robustness levels and

Read the complete text