Stability of Thin Shell and Wormhole Configurations: Schwarzschild, Schwarzschild - (Anti-) de Sitter, and FLRW Spacetimes

Travis Seth Rippentrop, Avijit Bera, Mustapha Ishak · 2025

Read Stability of Thin Shell and Wormhole Configurations: Schwarzschild, Schwarzschild - (Anti-) de Sitter, and FLRW Spacetimes by Travis Seth Rippentrop, Avijit Bera, Mustapha Ishak (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-00315.txt.

Introduction

Travis Seth Rippentrop, Avijit Bera, and Mustapha Ishak wrote a physics paper in 2025 on thin shells in space-time. A thin shell is a surface where two space-time regions join. Such shells can form black holes or wormholes, tunnels that link far places. The team asked which of these joinings stay stable when nudged.

They test joins built from four known space-time types, in many mixes. They chart the stable zones as charts of mass ratios and throat sizes. They also build a sorting scheme for the shapes of those charts. All the wormholes they studied proved unstable in the region where cause and effect hold. Black hole shells fared better in some zones. The maps give a full guide to this family of joins.

Catalog record

CREATORTravis Seth Rippentrop, Avijit Bera, Mustapha Ishak
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE42 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-00315

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Stability of Thin Shell and Wormhole Configurations: Schwarzschild, Schwarzschild - (Anti-) de Sitter, and FLRW Spacetimes Preprint: APS/123-QED Travis Seth Rippentrop, Avijit Bera, Mustapha Ishak Abstract The stability of thin shell wormholes and black holes to linearized spherically symmetric perturbations about a static equilibrium is analyzed. Thin shell formalism is explored and junctions formed from combinations of Schwarzschild, Schwarzschild - de Sitter, and Schwarzschild - anti-de Sitter, as well as Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) spacetimes are considered. The regions of stability for these different combinations are thoroughly described and plotted as a function of mass ratios of the Schwarzschild masses and radii of the wormhole throats. A taxonomy of the qualitative features of the various configurations and parameter spaces is developed, illustrating the stability regions when present. The considered wormholes are all found to be unstable in the causal region. I Introduction Einstein’s field equations allow for the mathematical existence of wormholes as exact solutions. A theoretical framework of constructing wormhole solutions is the thin shell or the Darmois-Israel formalism established in Darmois 1927 ; Israel 1966 and used extensively elsewhere Poisson and Visser 1995 ; Musgrave and Lake 1996 ; Visser 1996 ; Ishak and Lake 2002 . This method involves the assumption that the throat of a wormhole is infinitesimally short and the energy density therein is confined to an infinitesimally thin region known as the thin shell. Using these assumptions, it is possible to derive an equation of motion for the radius of the wormhole throat using the difference in the extrinsic curvature at the throat. From this, stability conditions can be derived using an effective potential based on the equation of motion of the throat, see e.g. Musgrave and Lake 1996 ; Ishak and Lake 2002 . Detailed information on the thin-shell formalism in general relativity can be found in, e.g. Visser 1996 ; Lobo and Crawford 2005 ; Lobo 2004 and references therein. The thin shell approach has had wide applications in general relativity and has been the subject of many studies. An initial study of the stability of the thin shell Schwarzschild wormhole about a static solution can be found in Poisson and Visser 1995 . Since then many others have utilized similar techniques with varying spacetime metrics and conditions. Some studies have introduced a cosmological constant through the Schwarzschild - de Sitter, and Schwarzschild - anti-de Sitter spacetimes, e.g. Ishak and Lake 2002 ; Wang and Meng 2017 ; Lemos and Lobo 2004 ; Lobo and Crawford 2004 ; Lemos et al. 2003 ; Salti et al. 2023 . Other studies have utilized charged wormholes (Reissner–Nordström) Eiroa 2008 ; Mazharimousavi and Halilsoy 2015 ; Eiroa and Simeone 2011 ; Eiroa and Figueroa Aguirre 2016 ; Kim and Lee 2001 ; Rahaman et al. 2006 , rotating wormholes Tsukamoto and Kokubu 2018 ; Kashargin and Sushkov 2011 , or Bardeen de-sitter wormholes Alshal et al. 2024 . Furthermore, the stability of wormholes has also been considered for modified theories of gravity such as F(R) Eiroa and Figueroa Aguirre 2016 ; Figueroa-Aguirre 2023 , Einstein-Guass-Bonnet Kokubu et al. 2015 ; Kokubu and Harada 2020 ; Thibeault et al. 2006 , and Hadara (Conformal Killing) gravity Alshal et al. 2024 . There has also been a study on the stability of various wormhole types when constrained by current cosmological observations Wang and Meng 2017 . Surprisingly, fewer studies Sakai and Maeda 1994 ; LA CAMERA 2011 ; Pérez and Neto 2023 ; Sahu 2024 have utilized the Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker metric, which we include in our paper along with other spacetimes. In this paper, we explore and systematize the study of the stability conditions of spherically symmetric thin shell spacetime junctions considering linearized perturbations about a static equilibrium. It is demonstrated that stability exists in the casual region (where the perturbation sound speed is real and sub-luminal) for black holes. However, for all wormhole constructions that are explored, stability is found to be present only far outside this region. The structure of the paper is described as follows. In Section II , we begin by establishing and summarizing the thin shell formalism, using the equation of motion of the radius of the throat to derive stability conditions. In Section III , the stability conditions are applied to wormhole and black hole junctions composed of Schwarzschild, Schwarzschild - de Sitter, and Schwarzschild anti-de Sitter spacetimes. A taxonomy of major categories is defined, and mathematical conditions related to the geometry of the stability regions for each category are derived (this portion will build and expand Ishak and Lake 2002 . Next, in Section IV we consider the construction of wormholes and black holes using the Friedmann–Lemaître–Robertson–Walker (FLRW) metric and a Schwarzschild or Schwarzschild - (anti-) de Sitter metric. We derive the extrinsic curvature and use thin shell formalism to give and categorize the stability conditions of these junctions. The taxonomic conditions from the earlier section are generalized to apply to this latter section. In Section V , we present our analysis with plots and discussion. And finally, in Section VI a summary and concluding remarks are provided. II Formalism (a) Black hole (b) Wormhole Figure 1 : Schwarzschild – Schwarzschild Junction: For the black hole, M\neq 0 everywhere and there is no stability flip. Stability region is always underneath the surface, partially intersecting the Causal Region ( i.e. , 0<P^{\prime}/\sigma^{\prime}<1 ). For the wormhole, there is an asymptote and stability region is above surface A and below surface B. (a) Black hole (b) Wormhole Figure 2 : Schwarzschild - de Sitter – Schwarzschild Junction: Plot has been expanded out to show horizons. The de Sitter Horizon is visible, as expected for a junction containing a \Lambda>0 2 2 2 The horizon occurs at R/m^{+}\approx 54 which is close to \alpha_{\rm dS}\approx 54.77 for C=0.001 – see text . For the black hole, stability is defined by the vertical surface bifurcating the plot where M=0 . Stability regions are below surface A and above surface B. A Schwarzschild - de Sitter – Schwarzschild junction implies [C]=-0.001 which does not fulfill the asymptote condition for any beta. Stability regions for the wormhole are below surface B and above surface A which is too small to be visible in this plot. (a) Black hole (b) Wormhole Figure 3 : Schwarzschild Anti-de Sitter – Schwarzschild Junction: Black hole has an asymptote as [C]=0.001 which does fulfill the asymptote condition. Stability regions for black hole below A and above B. Though not shown, wormhole at high R is very similar to Schwarzschild – Schwarzschild and does not possess a de Sitter Horizon. Stability regions are above A and below B. (a) Black hole (b) Wormhole Figure 4 : Schwarzschild – Schwarzschild - de Sitter Junction: Black hole is similar to Schwarzschild - anti-de Sitter – Schwarzschild (FIG. 3 ) with a similar asymptote, though in this case the de Sitter Horizon is also present. Again [C]=0.001 in this case, fulfilling the asymptote condition. Stability regions for black hole below A and above B. Wormhole case at large R is similar to Schwarzschild - de Sitter – Schwarzschild (FIG. 2 ). Stability regions are above A and below B. (a) Black hole (b) Wormhole Figure 5 : Schwarzschild

Read the complete text