Extrapolation in Regression Discontinuity Design Using Comonotonicity

Ben Deaner (UCL), Soonwoo Kwon (Brown) · 2025

Read Extrapolation in Regression Discontinuity Design Using Comonotonicity by Ben Deaner (UCL), Soonwoo Kwon (Brown) (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-00289.txt.

Introduction

Ben Deaner and Soonwoo Kwon proposed in 2025 a way to stretch cutoff-based causal estimates beyond the cutoff. Regression discontinuity designs compare people just above and below a treatment threshold, but policy often needs effects far from that line. With several background traits in play, the extrapolation usually rests on wishful assumptions.

Their key assumption is comonotonicity: traits tied to better untreated outcomes also track better treated ones. A local fitting method follows, and the target stays meaningful even if the assumption fails. The team tests the idea on mandatory summer school rules.

Catalog record

CREATORBen Deaner (UCL), Soonwoo Kwon (Brown)
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE112 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-00289

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Extrapolation in Regression Discontinuity Design Using Comonotonicity Ben Deaner (UCL), Soonwoo Kwon (Brown) Abstract We present a novel approach for extrapolating causal effects away from the margin between treatment and non-treatment in sharp regression discontinuity designs with multiple covariates. Our methods apply both to settings in which treatment is a function of multiple observables and settings in which treatment is determined based on a single running variable. Our key identifying assumption is that conditional average treated and untreated potential outcomes are comonotonic: covariate values associated with higher average untreated potential outcomes are also associated with higher average treated potential outcomes. We provide an estimation method based on local linear regression. Our estimands are weighted average causal effects, even if comonotonicity fails. We apply our methods to evaluate counterfactual mandatory summer school policies. Regression discontinuity design (RDD) provides a means for identifying causal effects without the need to isolate a source of exogenous variation in treatment. Instead, causal effects are identified under an a priori continuity assumption which is plausible in many empirical settings. Unfortunately, while causal inference in RDD design may be credible, its scope is limited. Standard RDD analysis can identify average causal effects only within the sub-population whose covariates place them on the margin between treatment and non-treatment. As such, identification of the causal impact of counterfactual policies is limited to those under which there is at most a marginal change in the treatment rule. To be more precise, consider the sharp RDD framework which is the focus of the present work. In sharp RDD, the binary treatment D is deterministic given some observable individual characteristics X . For example, treatment may be assigned if and only if a particular observable covariate known as the ‘running variable’ exceeds a certain threshold. In other cases treatment may be assigned by a more complicated rule that depends on multiple observables. Sharp RDD settings arise when receipt of an intervention is decided by some central authority purely on the basis of individual characteristics that are observed by both the authority and researcher. For example, eligibility for a particular welfare program may be decided according to a strict rule based on an individual’s age, income, household size, and marital status. Let Y be an outcome of interest and Y(d) the potential outcome from treatment level d . In RDD, treatment is entirely explained by the covariates, that is, the value of D depends entirely on whether X lies in a ‘treatment region’ or a ‘no-treatment region’. Under a continuity assumption, the conditional average treatment effect (CATE), given by E[Y(1)-Y(0)|X=x] , is identified for values of x that lie on the ‘frontier’ between the treatment and no-treatment regions. Without further assumptions, the CATE is not identified away from the frontier. In this work we provide a novel means for identifying causal effects away from the frontier in sharp RDD settings in which X is multivariate: that is, more than one covariate is available. We show that our approach is valid when a particular comonotonicity (in the sense of e.g., Schmeidler, 1989 ) condition holds. In its simplest form, our comonotonicity condition states that the mean untreated potential outcome is weakly greater conditional on a covariate value x that conditional on a value x^{\prime} , if and only if the conditional average treated potential outcome is also greater for value x than x^{\prime} . For example, if wealthier and older individuals have higher potential outcomes on average when they are not treated, they must also have higher average potential outcomes when treated. This assumption has testable implications. Under the standard RDD assumptions, both treated and untreated conditional average potential outcomes are identified along the frontier, and so one can assess whether the comonotonicity condition holds for covariate values on the frontier. The comonotonicity assumption suggests a straightforward means of extrapolating conditional average treatment effects away from the frontier. Given a vector of covariate values x that lie in say, the interior of the treatment region, we estimate the conditional average treated potential outcome for these values E[Y(1)|X=x] , which is equal to the conditional mean of the factual outcome E[Y|X=x] . We then find a point x^{*} on the frontier with the same associated conditional mean treated potential outcome. The conditional means of both treated and untreated potential outcomes are identified on the frontier under standard RDD assumptions. If such a point exists, then the conditional average treatment effect at x is identical to that at x^{*} . We develop a novel empirical approach based on our identification results. In particular, we develop a non-parametric method based on local linear regression. Notably, the methods do not require applied researchers to specify the frontier between the treatment and non-treatment region and thus our techniques are applicable even when treatment status is observed but the assignment rule is not a priori known. This facilitates implementation of our methods, an applied researcher need only input the outcomes, covariates, and treatments into a provided software package ¡¿, with no need to encode the formula for the treatment rule. Our estimator targets a particular weighted average of causal effects for individuals along the frontier. Thus our estimand is a weighted average of causal effects, regardless of whether comonotonicity holds. Comonotonicity then ensures that this weighted average is equal to the CATE at a chosen covariate value away from the frontier. We apply our methods to analyse the impact of mandatory summer school attendance. This empirical setting was previously analysed by Matsudaira, 2008 . We use our methods to examine heterogeneity in treatment effects. Related Literature This paper contributes to the extensive literature on RDD (see Cattaneo & Titiunik, 2022 for a recent review). A number of works use multivariate RDD to test a kind of selection-on-observables assumption. These include Battistin & Rettore, 2008 and Mealli & Rampichini, 2012 . A closely related approach is that of Angrist & Rokkanen, 2015 . Angrist & Rokkanen, 2015 extrapolate treatment effects away from the cut-off by assuming that, conditional on some covariates, a scalar running variable is unrelated to potential outcomes. Extrapolation from the cut-off using higher order derivatives is considered in DiNardo & Lee, 2011 . A full statistical analysis using first derivatives and extension to fuzzy RDD is given in Dong & Lewbel, 2015 who identify the impact of a marginal change in the threshold. Cattaneo et al., 2021 uses the existence of different cut-offs for certain sub-populations to extrapolate causal effects in univariate RDD under a type of parallel trends assumption. Another strand of the literature identifies causal effects in RDD away from the frontier by using auxiliary information, for example, Grembi et al., 2016 and Wing & Cook, 2013 . A number of other works consider RDD settings with one or more covariates in addition to a running variable. Calonico et al., 2019 and Noack et al., 2024 develop inference methods that can be applied to RDD setting with covariates, where the primary role of covariates is efficiency gain. In our work, we exploit the availability of additional covariates in order to identify richer causal objects rather than for statistical precision. Our paper also relates to the literature that considers multivariate running variables. For example, papers such as

Read the complete text