Examining Reject Relations in Stimulus Equivalence Simulations
Alexis Carrillo, Asieh Abolpour Mofrad, Anis Yazidi, Moises Betancort · 2025
Read Examining Reject Relations in Stimulus Equivalence Simulations by Alexis Carrillo, Asieh Abolpour Mofrad, Anis Yazidi, Moises Betancort (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-00265.txt.
Introduction
Alexis Carrillo, Asieh Abolpour Mofrad, Anis Yazidi, and Moises Betancort probe, in a 2025 paper, whether computer models truly learn a skill called stimulus equivalence. In such tests, a learner must treat linked items as equal even when that link was never taught directly. A snag is the reject relation: ruling items out can fake the right answers.
The team ran matching-to-sample simulations with three kinds of neural networks across eighteen setups, plus a simple chance-based agent as a yardstick. Some networks scored high on the equality tests when reject cues and biased wrong choices were present. Yet the simple agent matched them, which suggests the networks leaned on plain association, not true equivalence. The authors urge stricter tests for such claims.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Alexis Carrillo, Asieh Abolpour Mofrad, Anis Yazidi, Moises Betancort |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 69 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-00265
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Examining Reject Relations in Stimulus Equivalence Simulations Alexis Carrillo, Asieh Abolpour Mofrad, Anis Yazidi, Moises Betancort Abstract Simulations offer a valuable tool for exploring stimulus equivalence (SE), yet the potential of reject relations to disrupt the assessment of equivalence class formation is contentious. This study investigates the role of reject relations in the acquisition of stimulus equivalence using computational models. We examined feedforward neural networks (FFNs), bidirectional encoder representations from transformers (BERT), and generative pre-trained transformers (GPT) across 18 conditions in matching-to-sample (MTS) simulations. Conditions varied in training structure (linear series, one-to-many, and many-to-one), relation type (select-only, reject-only, and select-reject), and negative comparison selection (standard and biased). A probabilistic agent served as a benchmark, embodying purely associative learning. The primary goal was to determine whether artificial neural networks could demonstrate equivalence class formation or whether their performance reflected associative learning. Results showed that reject relations influenced agent performance. While some agents achieved high accuracy on equivalence tests, particularly with reject relations and biased negative comparisons, this performance was comparable to the probabilistic agent. These findings suggest that artificial neural networks, including transformer models, may rely on associative strategies rather than SE. This underscores the need for careful consideration of reject relations and more stringent criteria in computational models of equivalence. Keywords: Stimulus Equivalence, Reject Relations, Simulation, Computational Models, Artificial Neural Networks 1 Introduction Simulations are valuable tools for analyzing the fundamental processes of Stimulus Equivalence (SE) and for generating novel hypotheses suitable for experimental analysis ( Tovar et al., 2023 ) . These simulations enable researchers to systematically control and manipulate virtual environments and computational agents to investigate critical variables influencing equivalence class formation, a complex phenomenon often difficult to analyze within traditional laboratory settings ( Lyddy and Barnes-Holmes, 2007 ; Mofrad et al., 2020 ; Carrillo and Betancort, 2023 ) . This capacity for controlled manipulation can enhance our functional analysis of equivalence class formation and may lead to the development of more effective behavior-analytic interventions for educational and clinical applications ( Tovar and Westermann, 2017 ) . SE is a behavioral phenomenon characterized by the emergence of untrained stimulus relations. Specifically, when an organism is trained on a limited set of conditional discriminations, they may exhibit responding to a larger set of relations, including those not directly trained ( Sidman and Tailby, 1982 ; Sidman, 1994 ; Sidman, 2000 ) . In SE, organisms respond interchangeably to arbitrary and dissimilar stimuli as if those stimuli shared equivalent functions. The formation of equivalence classes enables the transfer of stimulus functions, such that a change in function for one member of an equivalence class will affect responding to all other members within that class ( Green and Saunders, 1998 ) . Arbitrary Matching-to-Sample (MTS) is a procedure used to train conditional discriminations and to assess emergent relations in SE ( Arntzen, 2012 ; Sidman and Tailby, 1982 ) . In an MTS procedure, a sample stimulus is presented, followed by two or more comparison stimuli. The participant is required to select the comparison stimulus that corresponds to the sample. Correct responses are typically reinforced; incorrect responses may result in punishment or the absence of feedback ( Green and Saunders, 1998 ; Sidman, 2009 ) . To establish an equivalence class with M members, M-1 conditional discriminations are trained as baseline relations between sample stimuli and comparison stimuli. Equivalence class formation is demonstrated when all class members function as sample stimuli, exerting stimulus control within three-term contingencies in which all class members serve as discriminative stimuli. This control is assessed through the demonstration of reflexivity, symmetry, and transitivity. Consistent exhibition of these properties across all class members constitutes robust evidence for the establishment of a functional equivalence class ( Arntzen, 2012 ; Green and Saunders, 1998 ; Sidman, 1994 ; Sidman, 2000 ) . Simulating SE involves training machine learning algorithms to replicate behaviors observed in human SE experiments ( Tovar et al., 2023 ) . These simulations employ various learning paradigms, including supervised ( Carrillo and Betancort, 2023 ) , unsupervised ( García-García et al., 2010 ) , and reinforcement-learning approaches ( Mofrad et al., 2020 ; Mofrad et al., 2021 ) . Artificial neural networks (ANN), particularly Feedforward Networks (FFNs), have been frequently used as architectures in these simulations ( Barnes and Hampson, 1993 ; Tovar and Chávez, 2012 ; Vernucio and Debert, 2016 ; Tovar and Westermann, 2017 ; Ninness et al., 2018 ) , with more recent studies also utilizing transformer-based models ( Carrillo and Betancort, 2024 ) . Key methodological considerations and influencing variables in this research area include Training Structures (TS), the role of select and reject relations, and the specific algorithms employed as agents. TS refer to the specific arrangement in which conditional discriminations are presented during training and the trials used to assess equivalence class formation ( Saunders and Green, 1999 ) . In the formation of a four-member class (A, B, C, D), baseline pairs are selected as follows: A linear series (LS) presents stimuli in a sequential order (e.g., A-B, B-C, C-D). A many-to-one (MTO) structure presents multiple sample stimuli that are matched to a single comparison stimulus (e.g., B-A, C-A, D-A). A one-to-many (OTM) structure presents a single sample stimulus that is matched to multiple comparison stimuli (e.g., A-B, A-C, A-D) ( Arntzen, 2012 ; Ayres-Pereira and Arntzen, 2021 ) . Figure 1 presents the baseline pairs (solid arrows) and their corresponding test pairs for the TS, as presented in Carrillo and Betancort, 2024 . Figure 1 : Basic training structures for a class of four members (A, B, C, D). Baseline relations are shown in black solid arrows. Emergent relations for testing are reflexivity (self loop) in dashed grey arrows; symmetry in black dashed arrows; and transitivity in black dotted arrows Correct selection of the comparison stimulus in MTS procedures can be driven by select relations (Sample/S+) and reject relations (Sample/S-) ( Green and Saunders, 1998 ) . Select and reject relations are two types of conditional discriminations that can be trained in baseline relations in an MTS task. A select relation refers to the learned association between a sample stimulus and the matching, or correct, comparison stimulus. This association is established through the selection of the matching stimulus with the consequence of a reward. An organism exhibiting a select relation consistently responds to the correct comparison stimulus when presented with a sample stimulus, indicating which comparison stimuli are appropriate matches for that sample. A reject relation is an association between a sample stimulus and a non-matching comparison stimulus, leading to no reward or punishment, thus signaling an incorrect choice. Participants tend to respond away from this comparison in the presence of the related sample ( Carrigan Jr. and Sidman, 1992 ; Johnson and Sidman, 1993 ) . Figure 2 presents the potential relations that can be established in a trial. Figure 2 : Example of a trial for the training of the A1-B1 pair with 3 comparison stimuli where B3 and B4 are incorrect comparison. Select relation is shown as a solid black arrow and reject relations as dashed grey arrows. Response indicate the action associated to the selection of a comparison. Control by the negative stimulus occurs