Cosmological implications of hybrid metric-Palatini f ⁡ ( ℛ , ℛ μ ​ ν ​ ℛ μ ​ ν ) f(\mathcal{R},\mathcal{R}_{\mu\nu}\mathcal{R}^{\mu\nu}) gravity

Shahab Shahidi, Shiva Kayedi · 2025

Read Cosmological implications of hybrid metric-Palatini f ⁡ ( ℛ , ℛ μ ​ ν ​ ℛ μ ​ ν ) f(\mathcal{R},\mathcal{R}_{\mu\nu}\mathcal{R}^{\mu\nu}) gravity by Shahab Shahidi, Shiva Kayedi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-00241.txt.

Introduction

Shahab Shahidi and Shiva Kayedi test a tweaked theory of gravity against cosmic data in a 2025 study. Their hybrid model mixes two ways of bending space, metric and Palatini, and adds a term built from squared curvature that blocks the usual shortcut to a scalar form.

On a smooth expanding universe they find a way to solve for the link between points, then fit the model to measures of the Hubble rate. The fit matched the data well. Yet the model's slow-down and jerk curves stray from the standard cosmic model in clear ways. A statefinder check and an Om test help sort what kind of dark energy the model acts like. Future sky data could tell the two apart.

Catalog record

CREATORShahab Shahidi, Shiva Kayedi
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE47 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-00241

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Cosmological implications of hybrid metric-Palatini f ⁡ ( ℛ , ℛ μ ​ ν ​ ℛ μ ​ ν ) f(\mathcal{R},\mathcal{R}_{\mu\nu}\mathcal{R}^{\mu\nu}) gravity Shahab Shahidi, Shiva Kayedi Abstract The hybrid metric-Palatini gravity with Lagrangian density L = R + f ⁡ ( ℛ , ℛ μ ​ ν ​ ℛ μ ​ ν ) L=R+f(\mathcal{R},\mathcal{R}_{\mu\nu}\mathcal{R}^{\mu\nu}) is considered, where R R is the metric Ricci scalar and ℛ μ ​ ν \mathcal{R}_{\mu\nu} is the Palatini Ricci tensor. Contrary to the standard hybrid metric-Palatini theory, because of the term ℛ μ ​ ν ​ ℛ μ ​ ν \mathcal{R}_{\mu\nu}\mathcal{R}^{\mu\nu} in the action, the model can not be analytically transformed to a scalar-tensor theory. However, on top of a maximally symmetric space-times like the FRW universe, there is a way to solve for a metric compatible connection which we will follow in this paper. The cosmological implications of the resulting model will then be fully considered. The best fit values of the model and cosmological parameters will be obtained by confronting the model with the recent observational data on the Hubble parameter. We will see that the observational data can be explained very good in this model, but, significant deviations from the standard Λ \Lambda CDM model could be seen in derivatives of the Hubble parameter q q , j j and s s . We will perform a statefinder analysis for the model and show that its behavior differs from that of the Λ \Lambda CDM model. Also, we will consider the recently proposed O ​ m Om diagnostics to categorize the dark energy type of the model and obtain the ω \omega -varying alternative of the model that mimics the Hubble flow. I Introduction Late-time observations of the type Ia supernovae super suggests that the universe is experiencing an accelerated expanding phase at present times. This conclusion is also approved by the observations of the baryon acoustic oscillations BAO . As a first attempt to explain the accelerated expansion of the universe, one can restore the cosmological constant proposed originally by Einstein firsteinstein . This, together with the addition of cold dark matter to the energy budget of the universe, will form the standard \Lambda CDM model on which all observations are based LCDM . Despite that the \Lambda CDM model is theoretically simple, minimal and beautiful, it suffers from both observational and theoretical issues like the cosmological constant problem CCproblem , the coincidence problem coniprob and the H_{0} and \sigma_{8} tensions tensions . These issues together with our theoretical curiosities, encourages us to explore for more advanced alternatives to Einstein general relativity which are collectively known as the generalized theories of gravity. The generalized theories of gravity can be achieved in several ways. The first possibility includes theories with modified gravity/geometry, like the f(R) gravities fR , higher dimensional models brane , massive gravity theories massive , Weyl geometric models weyl , Finsler geometries finsler , etc. Beside observational constraints, the main concern in modified gravity theories is the presence of ghost instabilities, which restricts the form of the final action ghost . The second possibility includes addition of more matter fields to the Einstein’s theory which is known as modified matter gravities. This can be done by adding other fields like the scalar/vector theories scalarvector , generalizing the matter Lagrangian itself to include non-standard functions of the matter Lagrangian, the trace of the energy momentum tensor, etc. generalmatter or adding derivatives of the matter Lagrangian derivative . The main problem in this category is to correctly define the energy momentum tensor secondderivativepaper . Another possibility to generalize the Einstein general relativity which makes more attention recently, includes coupling between matter and geometry sectors, generally called the matter-geometry coupling theories. More famous Lagrangians include f(R,T) fRT , f(R,L_{m}) fRLm , f(R,T,R_{\mu\nu}T^{\mu\nu}) fRTRT and f(R,T,L_{m}) fRTLm models. There is however a debate that these types of theories can not be considered independent. They are either unstable or lie in the generalized matter category mukohyama . The debate is replied in replytomukoohyama where the authors explain what is special in these type of theories and why they are stable and independent. One of the first generalizations of the Einstein’s general relativity, that lies in the first category, is to consider an independent affine connection instead of the metric-driven Christoffel connection. The resulting theory, known as the Palatini model, is proved to be equivalent to the Einstein’ theory if one considers the Einstein-Hilbert action as a starting point palatini . However, one obtains a different theory for more general action generalPalatini . The Palatini approach can then be though as an alternative viewpoint to all generalized theories of gravity palatinipapers . Recently, another idea was developed that the action contains both viewpoints together hybridmetricpalatini . In this hybrid metric-Palatini model, one write the action as \displaystyle S=\int d^{4}x\sqrt{-g}\,\Big[\kappa^{2}\big(R+\mathcal{R}\big)+L_{m}\Big], where the first Ricci scalar is constructed from the metric tensor and the connection is the Christoffel symbol, and the second Ricci scalar is constructed from the metric tensor and an independent affine connection. This can also be generalized to R+f(\mathcal{R}) , where f is an arbitrary function hybridmetricpalatini , or further to f(R,\mathcal{R}) generalizedHMP . Extensive studies have been done in the literature exploring cosmological cosHMP , balck holes BlackHMP and theoretical theoHMP aspects of the theory. In summary, these types of theories can be seen as a multi scalar-tensor generalization of the Einstein general relativity hybridmetricpalatini . In this paper, we will generalize the hybrid metric-Palatini idea to contain extra higher order terms in the Palatini sector. As a result we will consider a Lagrangian of the form R+f(\mathcal{R},\mathcal{R}_{\mu\nu}\mathcal{R}^{\mu\nu}) , where the Palatini Ricci tensor is explicitly included in the theory. The main difference between this model and the original hybrid metric-Palatini model is that here, there is no scalar-tensor alternative. In fact, because of the existence of \mathcal{R}_{\mu\nu} in the action, the secondary metric is not conformally related to the original metric, make it impossible to find a scalar-tensor alternative for the model. In this sense, the present model has a reacher structure compared to the original hybrid metric-Palatini model. We will see the result of this extension in the cosmological predictions of the universe. The present model can explain the recent observational data very good; at the lower orders it is very similar to the \Lambda CDM model. However, in order to explore more the differences between this model and the \Lambda CDM model, we will perform higher order analysis, including the statefinder and the Om diagnostics. As a result the model is different from \Lambda CDM model but can explain the observations as well. The paper is organized as follows: In the nest section we will present the model and try to simplify it on top of a maximally symmetric space-times. In section III we will obtain the cosmological equations and perform the likelihood analysis to obtain the cosmological and model parameters in confrontation with the observational data on the Hubble parameter from the cosmic chronometers and Pantheon+ datasets. We will then explore the cosmological implications of the model in details and perform the higher derivative diagnostics to compare the model with \Lambda CDM model. In the last section, we will

Read the complete text