Entanglement, Trace Anomaly and Confinement in QCD

Kiminad A. Mamo · 2025

Read Entanglement, Trace Anomaly and Confinement in QCD by Kiminad A. Mamo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-00176.txt.

Introduction

Kiminad Mamo reframes quark confinement as a surface effect in this 2025 paper on quantum chromodynamics. Confinement keeps quarks and gluons locked inside particles like protons. Mamo places their shared information on a sphere around the hadron. At that radius, the split between inside and outside reaches peak entanglement, a linked quantum state.

Lattice results for gravity-related form factors fix both the sphere's radius and a density tied to the trace anomaly. From those, Mamo derives a slope and an entropy that grows in a straight line with rapidity. The entropy push flips sign at the sphere, holding colored parts on it. World scattering data are checked against the idea. The test adds to, rather than replaces, the classic area-law test.

Catalog record

CREATORKiminad A. Mamo
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE27 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-00176

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Entanglement, Trace Anomaly and Confinement in QCD Kiminad A. Mamo Abstract We formulate confinement in QCD as an entropic surface phenomenon. Quark and gluon quantum information is localized on a transverse two–dimensional sheet of radius R E ​ E R_{\!EE} ; at this radius the QCD vacuum—partitioned by a hadron into interior and exterior regions—reaches its maximal entanglement entropy. Lattice‑QCD determinations of scalar (trace) gravitational form factors of hadrons fix both R E ​ E R_{\!EE} and the transverse trace‑anomaly density ρ h ​ ( R E ​ E ) \rho_{h}(R_{\!EE}) with percent‑level accuracy, enabling a parameter‑free mechanical entropy S E ​ E ​ ( y ) = c h ​ y S_{\!EE}(y)=c_{h}\,y growing linearly with rapidity y y . The associated entropy gradient changes sign at R E ​ E R_{\!EE} : it repels colour fields for r < R E ​ E r<R_{\!EE} and attracts them for r > R E ​ E r>R_{\!EE} , trapping partons at all scales—UV and IR—in contrast to Wilson’s area law, which probes only long distances. Squaring the entropy density as required by unitarity yields σ ∝ y δ \sigma\!\propto\!y^{\delta} . World data demand δ = 2 \delta=2 for elastic p ​ p ​ ( p ​ p ¯ ) pp\,(p\bar{p}) scattering and heavy‑quark photoproduction, but a softer δ = 0.387 \delta=0.387 for ϕ \phi photoproduction, all two orders of magnitude below the Froissart–Martin bound. These results provide the first confinement criterion derived directly from non‑perturbative QCD, unifying the trace anomaly, entanglement entropy, and high‑energy scattering within a single, quantitative framework. Introduction.— Why do coloured quarks and gluons never emerge from hadrons? The textbook answer invokes an area law for large Wilson loops, which diagnoses a linear confining potential in the IR Wilson 1974 . Yet that criterion carries no information about ultraviolet (UV) dynamics, where asymptotic freedom reigns. Here we propose a scale‑independent alternative: confinement is the localization of quark and gluon quantum information on a transverse sheet of radius R_{\!EE} . The sheet is fixed by the universal term Rosenhaus and Smolkin 2014 ; Ben-Ami et al. 2015 S_{\!EE}^{\rm univ}=2\pi\ln\!\bigl(R/\epsilon\bigr)\int_{\Sigma_{\perp}}\!\sqrt{h}\,\langle T^{\mu}_{\ \mu}\rangle, (1) which ties the entanglement entropy to the QCD trace anomaly on a 2-dimensional transverse entangling surface \Sigma_{\perp} Bombelli et al. 1986 ; Srednicki 1993 ; Solodukhin 2008 ; Casini and Huerta 2009 ; Casini et al. 2011 ; Rosenhaus and Smolkin 2014 ; Ben-Ami et al. 2015 . [see Appendix for derivation of Eq. ( 1 )] Percent-level lattice QCD calculations of the scalar (trace) gravitational form factors (GFFs) Shanahan and Detmold 2019 ; Hackett et al. 2024 ; Hackett et al. 2023 ; Wang et al. 2024 provide a direct, non-perturbative handle on \langle T^{\mu}_{\ \mu}\rangle . Independent experimental extractions corroborate these values: (i) the quark-sector GFF is obtained from deep-virtual Compton scattering at Jefferson Lab Burkert et al. 2018 , analysed with the dispersive–factorisation approaches of Diehl and Ivanov 2007 ; Anikin and Teryaev 2008 ; Pasquini et al. 2014 ; (ii) the gluon-sector GFF is deduced from near-threshold J/\psi photoproduction Duran et al. 2023 using both holographic-QCD Mamo and Zahed 2020 ; Mamo and Zahed 2022 and an NRQCD–GPD factorisation scheme Sun et al. 2021 . We impose two physical renormalisation conditions (i) Maximal‑entropy radius: R=R_{\!EE} where S_{\!EE} peaks for the hadron. (ii) Lorentz‑contracted cutoff: \epsilon=R_{\!EE}e^{-y} for boost rapidity y=\arcosh\gamma . The second condition is precisely the BFKL factorisation scale \mu^{2}=R_{\!EE}^{-2}e^{2y} Kuraev et al. 1977 ; Balitsky and Lipatov 1978 —and, after all‑order resummation, is equivalent to the DGLAP scheme Lipatov 1997 ; Altarelli et al. 2000 ; Ciafaloni et al. 2004 . No new parameters are introduced. These choices cancel the logarithm in Eq. ( 1 ), giving a finite mechanical entropy S_{\!EE}(y)=c_{h}\,y,\qquad c_{h}=8\pi^{2}R_{\!EE}^{2}\rho_{h}(R_{\!EE}), (2) see also Stoffers and Zahed 2013 ; Liu and Zahed 2019 , and Kharzeev and Levin 2017 for alternative derivations of the linear in y growth of S_{EE}(R) in a 2D CFT. Hence, under the physical renormalisation conditions specified above, Eq. ( 2 ) represents the hadron’s entanglement entropy: it vanishes at rest ( y=0 ), indicating a pure state, and increases linearly with the boost rapidity y , signalling the emergence of a mixed state. The entropy gradient \partial_{R}S_{\!EE} of ( 2 ) changes sign at R_{\!EE} : repulsive for r<R_{\!EE} , attractive for r>R_{\!EE} . Quarks and gluons are therefore trapped on the 2‑D surface r=R_{\!EE} at all momentum scales—a literal entropic realization of confinement, as visualized by the zero‐crossing of Fig. 2 . The sign‑changing entropy gradient is an intrinsic property of the QCD vacuum, akin to Casimir stresses on curved manifolds, and not a by‑product of the 2^{++} – 0^{++} resonances admixture that governs the three‑dimensional EMT pressure inside a hadron Polyakov 2003 ; Mamo and Zahed 2021 ; Cao et al. 2025 ; Broniowski and Ruiz Arriola 2024 ; Broniowski and Arriola 2025 ; Lorcé and Schweitzer 2025 . The entropic ansatz relates an elastic 2\!\to\!2 cross section to the mechanical entropy of the colour field produced in the collision Liu et al. 2023 ; Low and Yin 2025 . Imposing unitarity reduces this relation to a single–scale power law, \sigma(s)\propto\,y^{\delta}, (3) where the channel–dependent exponent \delta measures how efficiently the process samples the ultraviolet anomaly density on the information wall. For reactions dominated by compact configurations—elastic pp\,(p\bar{p}) scattering and heavy vector–meson photoproduction ( J/\psi , \Upsilon )—the data prefer the maximally allowed value \delta=2 , reproducing the celebrated \ln^{2}\!s growth while still lying at least two orders of magnitude beneath the Froissart–Martin bound Froissart 1961 ; Martin 1963 . The more infrared–sensitive \phi channel couples less strongly to the ultraviolet anomaly density and selects a softer exponent, \delta_{\phi}=0.387 . With a single normalization factor per channel, Eq. ( 3 ) reconciles all available data from threshold up to multi-TeV energies throughout, and never approaches closer than about 10 % to the Froissart–Martin ceiling. Ref. Dosch et al. 2024 , following the exponential entropic ansatz of Ref. Kharzeev and Levin 2017 for DIS structure functions, models total cross sections as \sigma\propto e^{\delta y} . Although this form reproduces vector–meson photoproduction data at high energies, it fails near threshold and overshoots the Froissart–Martin unitarity bound in the y\!\to\!\infty limit. By contrast, our power‑law ansatz \sigma\propto y^{\delta} describes both threshold and high‑energy photoproduction data with a single exponent and remains well below the Froissart–Martin limit across the full kinematic range, as illustrated in Figs. 3a – 3c . The rest of this Letter proceeds as follows: (i) lattice inputs and anomaly densities; (ii) mechanical entropy and the entropic force; (iii) cross‑section phenomenology; (iv) conclusions and outlook. Trace Anomaly and Lattice Inputs.— Entropic confinement depends only on the transverse anomaly density \rho_{h}(r_{\perp})=\langle T^{\mu}{}_{\mu}(x_{\perp})\rangle . Modern lattice data Shanahan and Detmold 2019 ; Pefkou et al. 2022 ; Hackett et al. 2024 ; Hackett et al. 2023 ; Wang et al. 2024 and perturbative counting rules Brodsky and Farrar 1973 ; Brodsky and Chertok 1976 ; Brodsky and Lepage 1981 ; Brodsky and Hiller 1983 ; Tong et al. 2021 ; Tong et al. 2022 fix the necessary scalar form factors: Nucleon ( J=\tfrac{1}{2} ).— With t=(P^{\prime}-P)^{2} , \bar{P}=(P^{\prime}+P)/2 , \displaystyle\langle P^{\prime}|T_{i}^{\mu\nu}|P\rangle \displaystyle=\bar{u}(P^{\prime})\!\Bigl[A_{i}(t)\gamma^{(\mu}\bar{P}^{\nu)}+D_{i}(t)\frac{q^{\mu}q^{\nu}-g^{\mu\nu}q^{2}}{4m_{N}}\Bigr]u(P), (4) and the trace

Read the complete text