Majorana zero modes in semiconductor-superconductor hybrid structures: Defining topology in short and disordered nanowires through Majorana splitting
Haining Pan, Sankar Das Sarma · 2025
Read Majorana zero modes in semiconductor-superconductor hybrid structures: Defining topology in short and disordered nanowires through Majorana splitting by Haining Pan, Sankar Das Sarma (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-00128.txt.
Introduction
Haining Pan and Sankar Das Sarma wrote a 2025 physics paper on Majorana zero modes, exotic quasiparticles pursued as building blocks for quantum computers. These modes appear at the ends of a one-dimensional topological superconductor, and they always come in pairs. If the pair is well separated, the modes behave as non-Abelian anyons that can be braided to perform fault-tolerant quantum computation.
The protection depends on the overlap between the two modes being exponentially small, which keeps their energy splitting tiny. Real devices, however, use short and disordered nanowires, where the ideal picture blurs. Pan and Sarma use the Majorana splitting itself to define when such imperfect wires are truly in the topological regime. The criterion helps experimentalists judge whether their devices host genuine Majorana modes.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Haining Pan, Sankar Das Sarma |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 57 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-00128
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Majorana zero modes in semiconductor-superconductor hybrid structures: Defining topology in short and disordered nanowires through Majorana splitting Haining Pan, Sankar Das Sarma Abstract Majorana zero modes (MZMs) are bound midgap excitations at the ends of a 1D topological superconductor, which must come in pairs. If the two MZMs in the pair are sufficiently well-separated by a distance much larger than their individual localization length, then the MZMs behave as non-Abelian anyons which can be braided to carry out fault-tolerant topological quantum computation. In this ‘topological’ regime of well-separated MZMs, their overlap is exponentially small, leading to exponentially small Majorana splitting, thus enabling the MZMs to be topologically protected by the superconducting gap. In real experimental samples, however, the existence of disorder and the finite length of the 1D wire considerably complicates the situation leading to ambiguities in defining ‘topology’ since the Majorana splitting between the two end modes may not necessarily be small in disordered wires of short length. We theoretically study this situation by calculating the splitting in experimentally relevant short disordered wires, and explicitly investigating the applicability of the ‘exponential protection’ constraint as a function of disorder, wire length, and other system parameters. We find that the exponential regime is highly constrained, and is suppressed for disorder somewhat less than the topological superconducting gap. We provide detailed results and discuss the implications of our theory for the currently active experimental search for MZMs in superconductor-semiconductor hybrid platforms. I BACKGROUND and INTRODUCTION In 2000, Kitaev pointed out Kitaev 2001 that an infinitely long clean spinless p -wave superconducting 1D (lattice) system can be in two distinct phases: Trivial and topological, with a gapless quantum phase transition point separating the two. The topological phase has isolated midgap Majorana bound states (MBS) localized at each end of the wire. It is ‘topological’ since such isolated MBS are non-Abelian anyons manifesting intrinsic quantum degeneracy and nontrivial braiding statistics, which are protected by the bulk superconducting gap, as already pointed out by Read in the context of non-Abelian fractional quantum Hall states also in 2000. Read and Green 2000 The trivial phase, by contrast, has no isolated MBS as the Majorana modes pair up in forming regular fermionic states. The topological and trivial phases are separated by a gapless topological quantum phase transition (TQPT) in the parameter space of the Hamiltonian controlling the superconductivity. Kitaev also identified a ‘Pfaffian’ topological indicator, which vanishes at the TQPT (where the superconducting gap must also vanish with the gap below and above the TQPT respectively being trivial and topological) which was also discussed by Read, taking on the values of \pm 1 in the trivial/topological phase. These early works, along with the 2000 work of Sengupta et al . Sengupta et al. 2001 demonstrating that such a topological spinless p -wave superconductor with isolated midgap MBS would manifest perfect Andreev reflection with a conductance quantization of \frac{2e^{2}}{h} , were done for pristine long wires, where topology is uniquely defined. (We note that it is well-known that such midgap zero energy bound states cannot occur in regular s -wave superconductors by virtue of the fermion doubling theorem — in s -wave superconductors, in-gap quasiparticles are the usual particle-hole symmetric electrons and holes with energies above or below the midgap.) What happens to topology in finite and/or disordered systems? The important question of the operational definition of how these topological ideas developed for pristine and infinite systems apply to real experimental systems in the laboratory was not discussed at all in these early pioneering publications. Kitaev 2001 ; Read and Green 2000 ; Sengupta et al. 2001 A superconductor is uniquely defined by one energy scale, the gap ( \Delta ), and one length scale, the coherence length ( \xi ), and the obvious implication is that if the disorder strength ( \sigma ) and the wire length ( L ) are much smaller and much larger than \Delta and \xi respectively, the system is topological. For very short wires ( L\ll\xi ) and very strong disorder ( \Delta\ll\sigma ), topology cannot be defined, and there is no MBS or topological superconductivity. Quite coincidentally, again in 2000, another important (and independent) work Motrunich et al. 2001 showed that such topological p -wave superconductivity in an infinite 1D system is destroyed by strong disorder through a quantum phase transition taking the system from a topological superconductor at weak disorder to a localized insulator at strong disorder. Thus, very strong disorder ( \Delta\ll\sigma ) necessarily destroys topology, although topology survives weak disorder. It is also clear that very short wires ( L\ll\xi ) cannot host isolated MBS since the two end MBS would overlap, creating ordinary fermionic Andreev bound states (ABS) shifted from zero energy and are nontopological. This shift in energy from zero energy corresponds to the ‘Majorana splitting’ energy as the overlap between the two MBS at two ends split their zero-energy character, but for low enough overlap, i.e. when the two MBS are separated by L\gg\xi , the splitting is exponentially small \sim\exp(-L/\xi) , implying the topological protection of MBS. But this exponential topological protection applies only when L\gg\xi , and for short wires, topology becomes ill-defined. The same is true for strong disorder, where the length L corresponds to the electron localization length, which is suppressed below the wire length, again leading to the effective short-wire situation since the localization length becomes comparable to or shorter than the coherence length \xi . A key motivation of Ref. Kitaev 2001 was the possibility of using the isolated end MBS for topological quantum computation Nayak et al. 2008 , provided a 1D topological superconductor can be found. This can be done by suitably manipulating the MBS in their degenerate quantum subspace, defined by both MBS occupied or empty, as indicated by their parity, provided they are located sufficiently far from each other. In this scenario, the topological protection is ‘exponential’, i.e., the overlap between the two MBS at the ends leads to an exponentially small energy splitting going as \exp(-L/\xi) in the L\gg\xi regime. Since in many situations, the coherence length (which in the topological superconducting state implies the size of the MBS localization at the end, thus controlling their end-to-end overlap suppressing the Majorana identity—for strong overlap the states are simply ABS) itself goes as \frac{1}{\Delta} . The superconducting gap \Delta controls the topological protection—the larger the gap, the shorter the coherence length, and hence the stronger the protection through the \exp(-L/\xi) factor in the Majorana splitting. However, such exponential regimes may not exist in short wires or even in longer wires with strong disorder. No direct experimental measurement of \xi is feasible, so in realistic situations, we do not know if the L\gg\xi topological condition is satisfied. The subject of MBS-carrying 1D topological superconductors remained academic and theoretical since nobody knew how to create such a system practically, and the early focus on non-Abelian anyons was entirely on the even-denominator fractional quantum Hall effect, where such quasiparticles should exist, but have not yet been observed because of various experimental difficulties. Das Sarma et al. 2005a ; Nayak et al. 2008 In fact, the subject of MBS in 1D topological superconductors was essentially ignored for the first