Deconstructing the Origins of Interfacial Catalysis: Why Electric Fields are Inseparable from Solvation

Solana Di Pino, Debarshi Banerjee, Marta Monti, Gonzalo Díaz Mirón, Giuseppe Cassone, Ali Hassanali · 2025

Read Deconstructing the Origins of Interfacial Catalysis: Why Electric Fields are Inseparable from Solvation by Solana Di Pino, Debarshi Banerjee, Marta Monti, Gonzalo Díaz Mirón, Giuseppe Cassone, Ali Hassanali (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-23988.txt.

Introduction

Solana Di Pino and co-authors question a popular claim about water surfaces in a paper from two thousand twenty-five. Some reactions speed up hugely in tiny water droplets, and large electric fields at the surface are often blamed. The team tests whether those fields are really special.

Using simulations of phenol in water and a learning method that links field and solvation, they find the surface field is not unusual compared with bulk water. The field also changes within about ten trillionths of a second, far faster than most reactions. It turns out the field on the test molecule is set mostly by nearby water. The authors urge caution about the field's role.

Catalog record

CREATORSolana Di Pino, Debarshi Banerjee, Marta Monti, Gonzalo Díaz Mirón, Giuseppe Cassone, Ali Hassanali
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE50 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-23988

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Deconstructing the Origins of Interfacial Catalysis: Why Electric Fields are Inseparable from Solvation Solana Di Pino, Debarshi Banerjee, Marta Monti, Gonzalo Díaz Mirón, Giuseppe Cassone, Ali Hassanali Abstract In the last decade, there has been a surge of experiments showing that certain chemical reactions undergo an enormous boost when taken from bulk aqueous conditions to microdroplet environments. The microscopic basis of this phenomenon remains elusive and continues to be widely debated. One of the key driving forces invoked are the specific properties of the air-water interface including the presence of large electric fields and distinct solvation at the surface. Here, using a combination of classical molecular dynamics simulations, the chemical physics of solvation, and unsupervised learning approaches, we place these assumptions under close scrutiny. Using phenol as a model system, we demonstrate that the electric field at the surface of water is not anomalous or unique compared to bulk water conditions. Furthermore, the electric field fluctuations de-correlate on a timescale of ∼ \sim 10 ps implying that their role in activating much slower chemical reactions remains inconclusive. We deploy a recently developed unsupervised learning approach, dubbed information balance, which detects in an agnostic fashion the relationship between the electric field and solvation collective variables. It turns out that the electric field on the hydroxyl group of the phenol is mostly determined by phenol hydration including the proximity and orientation of nearby water molecules. We caution that the growing attention of the role that electric fields have garnered in enhancing chemical reactivity at the air-water interface, may not reflect their actual importance. I Introduction The structural, dynamical and dielectric properties of aqueous interfaces have been implicated for a wide range of problems ranging from atmospheric chemistry limmer2024 ; jungwirth2006 to the origins of life vaida2021prebiotic ; lopezfranciscoreview2020 . Over the last decade or so there have been a flurry of studies suggesting that chemical reactions can be significantly accelerated near water interfaces compared to when they occur in the bulk lopezfranciscoreview2020 . Sharpless and co-workers coined the term ‘on-water’ catalysis observing that some organic chemistry reactions dramatically speeded up when conducted in water suspensions compared to organic solvents as well as in neat conditions sharpless2005 . The consistent experimental observation is that moving from bulk water to microdroplet conditions, leads to the speed of certain chemical reactions zare2018 ; zareangewandte2015 ; cooks2011 ; Lee_Banerjee_Nam_Zare_2015 ; gordon2025 . This enhancement is thought to occur at the boundary between water and air where the chemical reactants may experience different underlying physical driving forces. The molecular origins that lead to the enhanced catalysis remains a topic of lively debate in the literature. There have been several factors that are currently being examined in the community to rationalize the origins of the enhanced chemical reactivity including the presence of large electric fields and their fluctuations (ranging between 10^{9}-10^{10} V/m) field12023 ; field22020 ; martinscosta2023 ; xiong2020 ; Hao2022 , interfacial solvation and anisotropy of chemical reactants induced by the air-water boundary martins2023electrostatics ; shibdas2023 ; cookssolvation2020 , the surface activity of protons or hydroxide ions colussi2021 ; BANERJEE2023117024 and finally, geometric confinement effects Lee_Banerjee_Nam_Zare_2015 ; zhang2022 . A particular reaction that has caught significant attention is the one leading to the formation of hydrogen-peroxide ( H_{2}O_{2} ) in microdroplets observed by the Zare group zare2019 . Over the past few years, the Mishra group has shown through a series of careful and systematic studies that the high yields of H_{2}O_{2} originally observed by the Zare group arise not from the presence of intrinsic fields at the interface, but rather from impurities such as ozone or dissolved oxygen mishra2021 ; mishra2022 ; mishra2024 ; eatoo2025 . The importance of dissolved oxygen as a source of both H_{2}O_{2} and hydroxyl radicals has also recently been pointed out by other studies asserghine2025 . On the other hand, the Head-Gordon group using molecular simulations, have implicated large electric fields and partial solvation as playing a key role in the creation of hydroxyl radicals at the air-water interface gordonohradical2022 . The potential role of interfacial electric fields is partly rooted on the evidence that strong external static electric fields are sometimes capable of producing catalytic effects. In fact, experimental evidence has shown that electrostatic potential gradients can selectively enhance and catalyze Diels-Alder reactions Aragones and other industrially significant transformations Huang . Complementary insights into the effects of strong electric fields have come from quantum chemical computations on isolated molecules Shaik1 ; Shaik2 ; Shaik2016 and from extensive simulations on condensed-phase systems Cassone_ChemSci17 ; Cassone_TopCatal . These strong external artificial fields on the order of \sim 10^{9}-10^{10} V/m align in magnitude with the local electric fields naturally occurring in condensed matter Saggu ; Boxer ; Fried_15 and are therefore thought to introduce catalytic activity. A recent study by Xie and coworkers showed using ab initio molecular dynamics simulations coupled with free energy calculations, that the barrier for a certain Diels-Alder reaction was actually slightly higher at the air-water inteface and that the intrinsic fields and their fluctuations did not help speed up the reaction jing2024jacs . The rate of a chemical reaction is typically determined by the slowest degree of freedom that shapes the lowest free energy path going from the reactant to the product laioparrinello2002 . For a chemical process that occurs in solution, solvation can play an important role in, e.g., stabilizing the transition-state or facilitating charge-transfer events such as proton or electron transfer hassanali2011 ; bagchi1989 ; mundy2018 . It is known that the fluctuations of molecular dipoles in liquid water can produce fields larger than 10^{10} V/m Geissler , whereas in aqueous solutions Chalmet_JCP2001 ; Saikally_PNAS2005 ; Ruiz-Lopez_PNAS2021 ; Cassone_JPCL23 and in presence of solvated ions Sellner ; Kathmann_check local field intensities exceeding \sim 3\times 10^{10} V/m have been reported. Besides, electric field strengths on the order of 10^{9} V/m have been suggested to persist at the air-water interface xiong2020 ; Zare_PNAS2023 ; martins2023electrostatics . If these electric fields play a central role in chemical reactions, the timescales associated with their fluctuations must also be taken into consideration. In addition, since electric fields are ultimately rooted in charge density distributions arising from the water molecules oriented at the interface, can they really be de-coupled from solvation? In this work, we tackle the question of the interplay between electric fields and solvation using phenol as a test case. Electric fields at interfaces and how they modulate surface potentials has been a very active area of theoretical investigation using both classical and first principles approaches kathamnn2008 ; kathmann2011 . Our choice of using phenol is rooted in the fact that the phenolic chemical group is abundantly found in organic matter and plays a crucial role in the creation of aerosols hendrix2024 . Furthermore, due to its complex acid-base chemistry, it can also undergo various types of chemical reactions hendrix2024 . Tahara and co-workers recently demonstrated that the photodissociation of phenol occurs several orders of magnitude faster than in the bulk Kusaka2021 . The precise origins of this effect remain unknown, although it is very likely tuned by specific details of how the ground and excited-state potential energy surfaces evolve differently for phenol in the bulk and at the interface,

Read the complete text