X ( 3872 ) X(3872) and hidden charmed tetraquarks
You-You Lin, Ji-Ying Wang, Ailin Zhang · 2025
Read X ( 3872 ) X(3872) and hidden charmed tetraquarks by You-You Lin, Ji-Ying Wang, Ailin Zhang (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-23760.txt.
Introduction
You-You Lin and co-authors compute the masses of hidden charmed tetraquarks. These exotic particles pair a charm diquark with its antimatter twin. The work sits inside a constituent quark model. Using established potentials, the team first fixes the masses of the diquark building blocks. Then it works through the tetraquark family, from ground states up to higher excitations.
The results give an ordered mass ladder. Exotic quantum states sit higher on it. Radially excited states lie above 4300 MeV. Matching the ladder to known particles, the team suggests the X(3872) fits a tetraquark with one set of quantum numbers. They offer tentative homes for several other X, Y and Z states seen at colliders. A couple of candidates are ruled out.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | You-You Lin, Ji-Ying Wang, Ailin Zhang |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 42 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-23760
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
X ( 3872 ) X(3872) and hidden charmed tetraquarks You-You Lin, Ji-Ying Wang, Ailin Zhang Abstract In a constituent quark model, a hidden charmed tetraquark is assumed consisting of a c q cq diquark and an c ¯ q ¯ \bar{c}\bar{q} antidiquark or vice versa. The Semay-Silvestre-Brac potentials are employed to calculate the masses of c q cq (q=u, d) diquarks. The mass of the c q cq diquark or c ¯ q ¯ \bar{c}\bar{q} antidiquark with spin- 0 0 is predicted with ∼ 2175 \sim 2175 MeV, and the spin- 1 1 one is predicted with ∼ 2220 \sim 2220 MeV. The masses of hidden charmed tetraquarks from 1 S 1S to 2 P 2P excitations are systemically calculated in terms of the same potentials. It is found that the mass of hidden charmed tetraquark without radial excitation grows higher in 1 + − , 1 + + , 1 − − , 0 − + , 0 − − , 1 − + , ⋯ 1^{+-},~1^{++},~1^{--},~0^{-+},~0^{--},~1^{-+},~\cdots sequence, and the tetraquarks with exotic J P C = 0 − − , 1 − + J^{PC}=0^{--},~1^{-+} have higher masses. The hidden charmed tetraquarks with radial excitations have masses larger than 4300 4300 MeV. The 1 S − 1 P 1S-1P and 1 S − 2 S 1S-2S mass splittings of the hidden charmed tetraquarks are about 390 − 400 390-400 MeV and 550 − 570 550-570 MeV, respectively, which are about 70 70 MeV and 50 50 MeV smaller than those of normal charmonium. The 1 P − 2 P 1P-2P and 2 S − 2 P 2S-2P mass splittings are similar to those for conventional c c ¯ c\bar{c} charmonium mesons. Based on our predicted masses for hidden charmed tetraquarks, some XYZ exotics are analyzed and tentatively assigned. X ∗ ( 3860 ) X^{*}(3860) is possibly the 0 + + 0^{++} tetraquark. Z c ( 3900 ) Z_{c}(3900) and X ( 3940 ) X(3940) are possibly the 1 + − 1^{+-} tetraquarks, and X ( 3872 ) X(3872) is possibly a 1 + + 1^{++} tetraquark. X ( 4250 ) X(4250) may be a 0 − + 0^{-+} , 0 + + 0^{++} or 1 − + 1^{-+} tetraquark, X ( 4240 ) X(4240) may be a 0 − − 0^{--} tetraquark. With radial excitations, X ( 4350 ) X(4350) may be a 0 + + 0^{++} tetraquark, Z c ( 4430 ) Z_{c}(4430) may be a 1 + − 1^{+-} tetraquark, X ( 4630 ) X(4630) may be a 0 − + 0^{-+} or 1 − + 1^{-+} tetraquark, and X ( Y ) ( 4660 ) X(Y)(4660) may be the 1 − − 1^{--} tetraquark. Y ( 4008 ) Y(4008) or Y ( 4390 ) Y(4390) seems impossibly the 1 − − 1^{--} tetraquark. In experiments, it is also important to take into account the mixing of normal charmoniums with hidden-flavor charmonium-like exotics for the identification of a normal charmonium or a charmonium-like exotic. I Introduction A four-quark state consists of two quarks and two antiquarks. The concept of four-quark state was first mentioned by Gell-Mann, and four-quark states were subsequently studied in hadron scattering amplitudes. The discovery of X(3872) stirred people’s great interest on four-quark states. X(3872) was first observed in exclusive decays B^{\pm} with X(3872)\to\pi^{+}\pi^{-}J/\Psi by Belle Choi et al. 2003 , where \pi^{+}\pi^{-} is found to be dominated by a \rho^{0} with isospin symmetry violating. Later, the isospin violating channel X(3872)\to\rho^{0}J/\psi Aaij et al. 2023 was observed. A surprising \pi^{+}\pi^{-}\pi^{0}J/\Psi mode was also reported by Belle Abe et al. 2005 , but subsequent experiments by Belle Shen et al. 2010 ; Wang et al. 2011 did not observe such a 3\pi J/\psi decay mode in the radiative decays of \Upsilon(1S) and \Upsilon(2S) . However, the isospin conserving channel X(3872)\to\omega J/\psi was observed Abe et al. 2005 ; del Amo Sanchez et al. 2010 ; Ablikim et al. 2019 . The isospin, G parity and J^{PC} quantum numbers of X(3872) have finally been determined with I^{G}(J^{PC})=0^{+}(1^{++}) Navas et al. 2024 . For its exotic properties different from a conventional c\bar{c} meson, X(3872) has been extensively studied and assigned in all possible models. Many experiments have also been performed for its different features in different facilities Acosta et al. 2004 ; Aubert et al. 2005a ; Abulencia et al. 2007 ; Aubert et al. 2009 ; Bhardwaj et al. 2011 ; Chatrchyan et al. 2013 ; Aaij et al. 2013 ; Ablikim et al. 2014 ; Aaij et al. 2015 ; Aaij et al. 2020a . So far, there are many interpretations of X(3872) based on different concerns from different perspectives. X(3872) was assigned with a (c\bar{q})(q\bar{c}) -like hadronic molecule in Refs. Close and Page 2004 ; Voloshin 2004a ; Tornqvist 2004 ; Voloshin 2004b ; Braaten and Kusunoki 2004 ; Wong 2004 ; Hogaasen et al. 2006 ; Braaten and Lu 2007 ; Ortega et al. 2010 ; Liu et al. 2019a ; Liu et al. 2019b , and with a tetraquark state consisting of a cq diquark and an \bar{c}\bar{q} antidiquark in Refs. Maiani et al. 2005 ; Ebert et al. 2006 ; Terasaki 2007 ; Dubnicka et al. 2010 ; Kleiv et al. 2013 ; Maiani et al. 2014 ; Zhao et al. 2014 ; Anwar et al. 2018 ; Grinstein et al. 2024 . It was interpreted as a hybrid charmonium in Ref. Li 2005 , and as an adjoint charmonium in Ref. Braaten 2013 . X(3872) was interpreted as a normal \chi_{c1}(2P) charmonium in Ref. Barnes and Godfrey 2004 , and as a mixing state, for example, a normal c\bar{c} charmonium mixing with D\bar{D}^{*}+\bar{D}D^{*} Suzuki 2005 or a diquark-antidiquark mixing with a molecule Yang et al. 2009 . It was also interpreted as kinematic or threshold effects from virtual particles Kalashnikova 2005 ; Kalashnikova and Nefediev 2009 ; Danilkin and Simonov 2010 . Among these different interpretations, the hadronic molecule interpretation of X(3872) was once most popularly advocated. There were also some investigations on how to distinguish different interpretations. With a study of the line shape of X(3872) , the hadronic molecule interpretation may be distinguished from the virtual charm mesons interpretation Braaten and Lu 2008 . Through the mass spectrum, different patterns for the XYZ states in the hadro-charmonium picture, the tetraquark picture as well as the hadronic molecular picture have been explored Cleven et al. 2015 . Through an effective range defined through the low energy expansion of the scattering phase, the compact tetraquark nature and the loosely bound molecular one to a state can be discriminated Esposito et al. 2022 . Polosa et al. suggested that a measure of the ratio R=\frac{B(X\to\psi^{\prime}\gamma)}{B(X\to\psi\gamma)} for radiative decays of X(3872) can serve as a strong indication to discriminate between the molecular and compact interpretations Grinstein et al. 2024 . In pp collisions, some observables were proposed to serve as