The hydrodynamic thermal continuum, with applications to stratified atmospheres and 1D coronal loop models
Rony Keppens, Jordi De Jonghe, Adrian Kelly, Nicolas Brughmans, Hans Goedbloed · 2025
Read The hydrodynamic thermal continuum, with applications to stratified atmospheres and 1D coronal loop models by Rony Keppens, Jordi De Jonghe, Adrian Kelly, Nicolas Brughmans, Hans Goedbloed (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-23591.txt.
Introduction
Rony Keppens and four co-authors clarify a stability puzzle in a 2025 paper on layered gas, from stellar atmospheres to loops on the Sun. When heating and cooling do not balance, such gas can clump into cold blobs, the seed of solar rain and prominences.
The authors show, by math and by computer, that the wobble spectrum of such a layer holds a thermal continuum. That is a band of modes, each pinned to a thin slice of the layer. This band can be computed ahead from the heat-loss rule and its slopes. Their general equations also cover the sound and buoyancy modes of the layer. The work sorts out recent confusion about which routes to clumping are real.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Rony Keppens, Jordi De Jonghe, Adrian Kelly, Nicolas Brughmans, Hans Goedbloed |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 70 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-23591
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The hydrodynamic thermal continuum, with applications to stratified atmospheres and 1D coronal loop models Rony Keppens, Jordi De Jonghe, Adrian Kelly, Nicolas Brughmans, Hans Goedbloed Abstract Using both analytical and numerical means, we demonstrate that linear stability analysis of a hydrodynamic stratified atmosphere or a 1D coronal loop model in non-adiabatic settings features a thermal continuum corresponding to highly localized eigenfunctions. This thermal continuum can be precomputed, involving the net heat-loss function and its partial derivatives, and is the generalization of the thermal instability introduced by Parker 1953 . We account for a thermal imbalance, directly affecting thermal instability growthrates. We present completely general equations that govern all eigenmodes, including non-adiabatically affected p- and g-modes of the stratified settings. We intend to clarify how linear thermal instability is relevant for solar loops that show spontaneous in-situ condensations, and eliminate recent confusion on specific isochoric routes to linear instability alongside other thermal instability channels. The thermal continuum, previously identified as a crucial ingredient in magnetohydrodynamic eigenmode spectra for coronal loops and atmospheres, drives multithermal aspects across our universe, such as forming solar coronal rain and prominences, or cold cloud creation in intracluster to interstellar medium environments. I Introduction I.1 Motivation The solar corona is structured in myriads of magnetic loops and contains rarified plasma at million degrees Kelvin. However, observations reveal how spontaneous in-situ condensations show up nearly everywhere. In the strong coronal magnetic field, these cold (10000 K) and dense blobs are then guided to rain down curved magnetic loops, such that an essentially hydrodynamic evolution along a 1D loop often suffices to explain the physics. These coronal rain condensations are manifestations of an energy exchange between the plasma and the radiation field, where optically thin radiative losses preferentially act as a sink for internal energy. This makes the loop plasma liable to a runaway linear thermal instability, originally postulated by Parker 1953 . Observations, theory and numerical simulations meanwhile confirm the essential role played by thermal instability to instigate coronal rain or prominence formation ( Li et al. 2022 ; Donné & Keppens 2024 ) , and the very same physical ingredients return in model efforts on stellar prominences ( Daley-Yates & Jardine 2024 ) , galactic prominences ( Peng & Matsumoto 2017 ) , cold gas precipitation and survival in galactic stratified settings ( Tan et al. 2023 ; Wibking et al. 2025 ) , or in stellar or galactic outflows where the wind demonstrates multi-thermal structure ( Wareing et al. 2017 ) , as influenced or triggered by radiative effects. In this paper, we show that a rigorous mathematical analysis of the linearized non-adiabatic hydrodynamic equations reveals the presence of a thermal continuum in the essential spectrum of eigenmodes of a stratified atmosphere or coronal loop. We will show how p- and g-modes get modified by radiative losses, and that the usually uninteresting (at zero frequency) entropy mode turns into a continuous range of eigenfrequencies with ultra-localized (singular) eigenfunctions. This insight connects and clarifies findings on thermal non-equilibrium states, waves affected by thermal misbalance, and the present confusion on the role of isochoric versus isobaric thermal instabilities ( Waters & Stricklan 2025 ) . I.2 Spectroscopy in ideal (magneto)hydrodynamic settings In ideal magnetohydrodynamics (MHD), categorizing all linear waves and instabilities accessible to a particular equilibrium configuration is known as magnetohydrodynamic spectroscopy ( Goedbloed et al. 2019 ) . This spectrum is quantified by normal mode eigenfrequencies \omega arising from assuming an exponential \exp(-i\omega t) temporal variation for all linear quantities. Since ideal MHD is time-reversible, the entire spectrum located throughout the complex \omega -plane has an up-down symmetry: for every overstable or purely unstable mode \omega=\omega_{R}+i\omega_{I} (with \omega_{I}>0 ), there is a corresponding damped counterpart \omega_{R}-i\omega_{I} that is also part of the spectrum. In equilibrium configurations that obey an essentially one-dimensional force balance, such as in a gravitationally stratified atmosphere with height variation only, a key role in MHD spectroscopy is played by real-valued (hence, stable) continuous ranges in the spectrum, which locate on the \omega_{R} -axis. In MHD settings, these form pairs of backward and forward Doppler-shifted slow and Alfvén continua, so we have four continua that may overlap. Since MHD counts seven wave families, its essential spectrum is further aware of the infinite (real) frequency \omega\rightarrow\pm\infty accumulation points for fast modes, and a separate Eulerian entropy continuum that locates throughout the range of Doppler shifts. In the ideal hydrodynamic limit, where we expect five wave families, the Eulerian entropy continuum remains, and we find two overlapping flow continua at the same Doppler range, related to singular Eulerian velocity perturbations as discovered by Case 1960 , augmented with the infinite (real) frequency accumulation points for sound waves. When no background flow is considered in the state that is spectrally analyzed, all three overlapping hydrodynamic continua collapse to marginal frequency \omega=0 , since Doppler shifts vanish. In what follows, we will assume zero flow in the background state, but show how the marginal \omega=0 entropy mode becomes a crucial (and continuous) ingredient of the hydrodynamic spectrum, when non-adiabatic effects are included. I.3 The thermal continuum in magnetohydrodynamics When non-ideal effects, such as resistivity, thermal conduction, or viscosity, are incorporated, we lose time-reversibility in (M)HD, such that the up-down symmetry in the complex eigenfrequency plane gets broken. In this paper, we focus attention to a particular non-adiabatic effect, namely we allow a deviation of entropy-conserving evolutions. Specifically, when a source or sink term for internal energy that represents the (assumed instant and local) optically thin radiative losses is incorporated, van der Linden et al. 1991 showed that in a cylindrical, static MHD equilibrium configuration, the governing ordinary differential equations for normal modes contain a thermal continuum. This continuum can be purely unstable (i.e. only have nonvanishing \omega_{I}>0 ) and is coupled to both MHD slow continua, which are also affected by non-adiabatic processes. This thermal continuum is in fact the non-adiabatic counterpart of the Eulerian entropy continuum, and directly generalizes the thermal instability that was postulated to exist in uniform, but radiating plasma by Parker 1953 . Indeed, under typical solar coronal conditions, the radiative losses act destabilizing, with a potential for runaway condensations to form as a direct result. Cylindrical flux ropes were analyzed in van der Linden & Goossens 1991a and slab configurations were treated in van der Linden & Goossens 1991b . The analysis accounted for anisotropic thermal conduction, with both field-aligned (parallel) heat conduction as well as finite perpendicular thermal conduction \kappa^{c}_{\perp} , across the magnetic surfaces. Using numerically computed spectra, it was demonstrated that finite perpendicular thermal conduction replaces the thermal continuum by a dense set of discrete thermal modes. I.4 Goal and organization of this paper The fate of especially this thermal continuum, is as yet undocumented for purely hydrodynamical settings. We do so in this paper, where we recover some of the MHD findings by simply inspecting their zero magnetic field limit. We will at the same time incorporate gravitational stratification, which in the case of stellar seismology brings in the familiar p- and g-modes, for pressure and gravity driven oscillations. It is our goal to present the most general equations governing a gravitationally stratified, non-adiabatically evolving gas or plasma, and