A systematic bias in template-based RV extraction algorithms

A. M. Silva, N. C. Santos, J. P. Faria, J. H. C. Martins, E. A. S. Cristo, S. G. Sousa, P. T. P. Viana, É. Artigau, K. Al Moulla, A. Castro-González, D. F. M. Folha, P. Figueira, T. Schmidt, F. Pepe, X. Dumusque, O. D. S. Demangeon, T. L. Campante, X. Delfosse, B. Wehbe, J. Lillo-Box, A. R. Costa Si · 2025

Read A systematic bias in template-based RV extraction algorithms by A. M. Silva, N. C. Santos, J. P. Faria, J. H. C. Martins, E. A. S. Cristo, S. G. Sousa, P. T. P. Viana, É. Artigau, K. Al Moulla, A. Castro-González, D. F. M. Folha, P. Figueira, T. Schmidt, F. Pepe, X. Dumusque, O. D. S. Demangeon, T. L. Campante, X. Delfosse, B. Wehbe, J. Lillo-Box, A. R. Costa Si (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-23261.txt.

Introduction

André Silva and a large team of co-authors (2025) uncover a bias in how astronomers measure the wobble of stars. That wobble, the radial velocity, betrays orbiting planets, so meter-per-second errors matter. Two popular extraction methods build a template of the star's spectrum from the data themselves. The authors find a systematic error, several meters per second, correlating velocities with time, present in template-matching and line-by-line methods.

Working with the s-BART pipeline, they extract velocities from three datasets over four nights with the ESPRESSO and HARPS instruments. The effect shows up across a sample: nineteen stars and 4,124 spectra. The team probes how the data-built template injects the bias, and weighs sources. For a field hunting Earth-like planets by starlight, an unnoticed drift can invent planets or erase real ones.

Catalog record

CREATORA. M. Silva, N. C. Santos, J. P. Faria, J. H. C. Martins, E. A. S. Cristo, S. G. Sousa, P. T. P. Viana, É. Artigau, K. Al Moulla, A. Castro-González, D. F. M. Folha, P. Figueira, T. Schmidt, F. Pepe, X. Dumusque, O. D. S. Demangeon, T. L. Campante, X. Delfosse, B. Wehbe, J. Lillo-Box, A. R. Costa Si
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE78 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-23261

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A systematic bias in template-based RV extraction algorithms A. M. Silva, N. C. Santos, J. P. Faria, J. H. C. Martins, E. A. S. Cristo, S. G. Sousa, P. T. P. Viana, É. Artigau, K. Al Moulla, A. Castro-González, D. F. M. Folha, P. Figueira, T. Schmidt, F. Pepe, X. Dumusque, O. D. S. Demangeon, T. L. Campante, X. Delfosse, B. Wehbe, J. Lillo-Box, A. R. Costa Silva, J. Rodrigues, J. I. González Hernández, T. Azevedo Silva, S. Cristiani, H. M. Tabernero, E. Palle, B. Lavie, A. Suárez Mascareño, P. Di Marcantonio, C. J. A. P. Martins, N. J. Nunes, A. Sozzetti Abstract Context. The radial velocity (RV) method plays a key role in modern-day astrophysics. One of the most common techniques to extract precise RVs from state-of-the-art spectrographs is template-matching (TM) algorithms. They have been shown to perform better than cross correlation (CCF) methods in cooler stars (e.g., M dwarfs) and multiple implementations have appeared over the past years. More recently, line-by-line (LBL) approaches offer an alternative avenue to extract RVs by analyzing individual spectral lines. Aims. In this paper we identify and explore a previously unidentified, multi meter-per-second, systematic correlation between time and RVs inferred through TM and LBL methods. We evaluate the influence of the data-driven stellar template in the RV bias and hypothesize on the possible sources of this effect. Methods. We first use the s-BART pipeline to extract RVs from three different datasets gathered over four nights of ESPRESSO and HARPS observations. Then, we demonstrate that the effect can be recovered on a larger sample of 19 targets, totaling 4124 ESPRESSO observations spread throughout 38 nights. We also showcase the presence of the bias in RVs extracted with the SERVAL and ARVE pipelines. Lastly, we explore the construction of the stellar template through the 5 years of ESPRESSO observations of HD10700, totalling more than 2000 observations. Results. We find that a systematic quasi-linear bias affects the RV extraction with slopes that vary from ∼ \sim -0.3 m ​ s − 1 ​ h − 1 {\rm m}\ {\rm s}^{-1}\ {\rm h}^{-1} to ∼ \sim -52 m ​ s − 1 ​ h − 1 {\rm m}\ {\rm s}^{-1}\ {\rm h}^{-1} in our sample. This trend is not observed in CCF RVs and appears when all observations of a given star are collected within a short time-period (timescales of hours). We show that this systematic contamination exists in the RV time-series of two different template-matching pipelines, one line-by-line pipeline, and that it is agnostic to the spectrograph. We also find that this effect is connected with the construction of the stellar template, as we are able to mitigate it through a careful selection of the observations used to construct it. Our results suggest that a contamination of micro-telluric features, coupled other sources of correlated noise, could be the driving factor of this effect. We also show that this effect does not impact the usual usage of template-matching for the detection and characterization of exoplanets. Other short-timescale science cases – such as, asteroseismology, transit and atmospheric characterization – can however be severely affected. 1 Introduction The field of exoplanets has seen a massive growth over the past three decades, with 5849 1 1 1 Information from March 11th, 2025; Refer to https://exoplanetarchive.ipac.caltech.edu for updated number. detections of exoplanetary signals. Despite this impressive growth, the discovery and characterization of an ”Earth-analog” still remains a major challenge, driving improvements in both instrumentation and data analysis techniques. A major work-horse of the field is the radial velocity (RV) method, based on the measurement of variations of a star’s velocity along the line of sight. This is done through the measurement of displacements in the location of the spectral lines, in comparison to their expected position. Often, RV extraction is done through the Cross Correlation Function (CCF) method – based on the cross-correlation between stellar spectra and a (weighted) binary mask ( Baranne et al. 1996 ; Pepe et al. 2002a ) – but this is not always the optimal approach. In cooler stars (e.g., M dwarfs) the template matching (TM) algorithm typically yields better results, leading to smaller RV scatters and improved RV precision, as seen in different implementations, e.g, HARPS-TERRA ( Anglada-Escudé & Butler 2012 ) , NAIRA ( Astudillo-Defru 2015 ) , and SERVAL ( Zechmeister et al. 2018 ) . Template matching is a data-driven method, based on the construction of a high-SNR stellar model from available observations of a given star, which is then aligned with the individual observations. Usually, TM methods share a common set of characteristics: i) chromatically-independent RV shifts, where each spectral order is assumed to be an independent measurement of the same underlying phenomenon; ii) the stellar template (model) is capable of accurately describing every observation of a given star. s-BART 2 2 2 Publicly availabe at https://github.com/iastro-pt/sBART ( Silva et al. 2022 ) tackled the assumption of chromaticity, as the RV signal of exoplanets is independent of the wavelength at which it is measured. This is done by imposing a wavelength-independent RV shift – common to all spectral orders – to describe the differences between the stellar model and observations. Since its inception, s-BART has used for the discovery and characterization of several systems across different state-of-the-art spectrographs ( Faria et al. 2022 ; Palethorpe et al. 2024 ; Balsalobre-Ruza et al. 2025 , e.g.,) . In order to refine template matching avenues we have seen a push towards a careful selection of the lines that are used for RV extraction. The line-by-line (LBL) methods ( Dumusque 2018 ; Artigau et al. 2022 , e.g.,) share a common working principle with TM methods: a high-SNR stellar model is constructed from the data and, afterwards, RVs are estimated through their analysis. This process is carried out for each individual spectral line and, at the end, a selection is made in order to remove the ones that present a larger variability. In exoplanetary RV blind-searches, or in the follow-up of transiting exoplanets, observations are typically carried out over multiple months. This allows to properly sample the orbital period of the orbiting companions and to characterize any stellar signals. However, some science cases require a much shorter cadence of observations, such as transmission or emission spectroscopy studies ( Wyttenbach et al. 2015 ; Costa Silva et al. 2024 , e.g., ) , or asteroseismology analysis ( Bouchy et al. 2005 ; Campante et al. 2024 , e.g,) . Similarly, the RV detection of planets with unusually ultra-short periods ( Adams et al. 2021 ; Castro-González et al. 2025 , e.g, P_{\rm orb} < 12 h,) can be achieved through very short observing baselines. These datasets are typically collected within a single night, or over a few consecutive nights. A priori , one would expect the RV extraction through a template-based algorithm – TM or LBL – to perform similarly for different observing strategies. However, in this paper we show that this is not necessarily the case. In particular, we present a systematic bias in the RV extraction through template-based algorithms when the stellar model is constructed from observations collected within a short time-span, e.g., within a night. This bias appears in two TM pipelines,

Read the complete text