Conversion of photons to dileptons in the Kroll-Wada and parton shower approaches

Tomáš Ježo, ​​, Michael Klasen, and Alexander Puck Neuwirth · 2025

Read Conversion of photons to dileptons in the Kroll-Wada and parton shower approaches by Tomáš Ježo, ​​, Michael Klasen, and Alexander Puck Neuwirth (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-23162.txt.

Introduction

Tomáš Ježo, Michael Klasen, and Alexander Puck Neuwirth compare two ways to model how photons turn into lepton pairs in heavy-ion collisions, in work from 2025. These pairs probe the hot matter made in such collisions and the glow it emits. The classic formula for the conversion is decades old.

The rival route uses event generators with parton showers, which keep total rates consistent and add recoil and higher-order effects by construction. The team ran three generator variants against the classic formula. Shower results matched the pair spectrum better, above all at larger pair masses where space limits bite. The authors back showers as the sharper tool for this signal.

Catalog record

CREATORTomáš Ježo, ​​, Michael Klasen, and Alexander Puck Neuwirth
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE50 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-23162

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Conversion of photons to dileptons in the Kroll-Wada and parton shower approaches Preprint: MS-TP-25-18 Tomáš Ježo, ​​, Michael Klasen, and Alexander Puck Neuwirth Abstract The study of dileptons in high-energy heavy-ion collisions provides critical insights into the properties of the quark-gluon plasma and the thermal radiation emitted throughout its evolution. In the low-mass region, dileptons originate from both direct photon conversion and hadronic decays, with the Kroll-Wada equation traditionally used to relate direct real and direct virtual photon production. In this work, we explore the possibility of using parton shower event generators to model this conversion process, leveraging their unitary treatment of internal photon conversions that naturally preserves normalisation, as well as their ability to incorporate higher-order corrections, recoil kinematics, and realistic experimental selection criteria. We compare the Kroll-Wada approach to simulations using the Pythia8 simple shower, the Vincia sector shower, and the POWHEG+PYTHIA NLO event generator. Our results reveal that parton shower approaches offer improved accuracy in describing the dilepton spectrum, particularly towards larger invariant masses where phase-space suppression effects become relevant. 1 Introduction One of the central goals of high-energy heavy-ion physics is to unravel the nature of the quark-gluon plasma (QGP) and its evolution in relativistic collisions. Among the most valuable probes of this deconfined phase are electromagnetic signals, including real and virtual photons, which escape the medium without undergoing final-state interactions Rapp:2009yu ; Tserruya:2009zt . Dileptons, arising from virtual photon decays, provide a unique window into the space-time evolution of the system, as their invariant mass spectrum directly encodes information about the time evolution of the collision. The pre-equilibrium effects become evident around M_{ee}\gtrsim$2\text{\,}\mathrm{GeV}$ , followed by the expected formation of the QGP in the invariant mass range $1\text{\,}\mathrm{GeV}$\lesssim M_{ee}\lesssim$2\text{\,}\mathrm{GeV}$ , and finally the hadronic phase at later emission stages with M_{ee}\lesssim$1\text{\,}\mathrm{GeV}$ Rapp:1999ej ; Coquet:2021lca . However, measuring thermal photon signals in heavy-ion collisions presents considerable challenges, such as the small production cross section due to the electromagnetic coupling, and significant combinatorial and physical backgrounds from hadron decays. In hadronic collisions, the dielectron mass spectrum in the low and intermediate mass regions is well described by a combination of expected hadronic sources, known as the cocktail PHENIX:2008qav ; PHENIX:2009gyd ; STAR:2012dzw ; ALICE:2018fvj ; ALICE:2018gev . The low-mass region (LMR, M_{ee}<$1.1\text{\,}\mathrm{GeV}$ ) is primarily dominated by decays of light-flavoured vector mesons, while the intermediate-mass region (IMR, $1.1\text{\,}\mathrm{GeV}$<M_{ee}<$2.7\text{\,}\mathrm{GeV}$ ) is mostly influenced by semileptonic decays of charm and bottom hadrons, which are correlated through flavour conservation. Despite the significant backgrounds, notable signals of direct real or low-mass virtual photons, over the cocktail, have been observed in heavy-ion collisions at the SPS, RHIC and LHC CERES:1995vll ; CERESNA45:1997tgc ; CERES:2006wcq ; CERESNA45:2002gnc ; NA60:2006ymb ; NA60:2008ctj ; PHENIX:2008uif ; PHENIX:2009gyd ; STAR:2013pwb ; STAR:2015tnn ; PHENIX:2014nkk ; ALICE:2015xmh . These enhancements are well described by exponential distributions in the photons transverse momentum ( p_{T,\gamma} ), suggesting thermal radiation with average (effective) temperatures in the range from 0.2\text{\,}\mathrm{GeV}0.3\text{\,}\mathrm{GeV} PHENIX:2008uif ; PHENIX:2014nkk ; ALICE:2015xmh . In the intermediate-mass window, an excess over decay dielectrons has only been observed at the SPS NA60:2006ymb ; NA60:2008ctj ; NA60:2008dcb ; NA60:2007lzy . To distinguish the subtle thermal photon signal in this range at the LHC, where increased sensitivity to QGP thermal radiation is expected, understanding the dielectron yield originating from the hard production of photons is essential. A primary method for estimating dileptons in the LMR is the Kroll-Wada formalism Kroll:1955zu . The Kroll-Wada equation was originally developed to describe the photomesonic processes: \pi^{-}p\to ne^{+}e^{-} , \pi^{0}\to\gamma e^{+}e^{-} and \pi^{0}\to 2e^{+}2e^{-} . The internal conversion of a photon to a dilepton pair describes the rare decays of vector ( V\to Pl^{+}l^{-} ) and pseudoscalar mesons ( P\to Vl^{+}l^{-} ) with respect to the radiative decays ( A\to B\gamma ) ( Landsberg:1985gaz , Eq. (3.8)) . In the recent years the internal conversion method was applied in a broader context, relating any source of real photons to dileptons Reygers:2009tm . Thereby one obtains a mass distribution of dileptons particularly for the low-mass region, where conventional perturbation theory breaks down due to the extremely low scale. Often the transverse momentum is significantly larger than the invariant mass p_{T}^{ee}\gg M_{ee} , such that quantum chromodynamics (QCD) resummation allows for the inclusion of a tower of potentially large logarithms Fai:2003zc ; Kang:2008wv ; Kang:2009vi . The impact of the same \gamma\to f\bar{f} splittings on dilepton production around the Z mass was studied in Flower:2022iew , where it enters as a next-to-next-to-leading order quantum electrodynamics (QED) correction in the soft-photon resummation. Consequently, measuring dilepton pairs allows to measure the cross section of direct-photon production, which is not overshadowed by the large background of decay photons. The final dilepton spectrum in the LMR is a combination of direct photons and a cocktail of light and heavy flavour hadron decays PHENIX:2008qav ; ALICE:2018fvj . The only fit parameter entering is the ratio of direct to inclusive photons r . It determines the normalization of the direct photon yield, that is given by the Kroll-Wada equation. In this work we explore using shower Monte Carlo (MC) event generators as an improvement to the Kroll-Wada equation. The Kroll-Wada equation is expected to be the lowest order expansion ( \gamma\to e^{+}e^{-} ) of the parton shower (PS) probability. Such a PS approach offers greater flexibility and precision compared to the Kroll-Wada equation, since it incorporates higher-order contributions in both the hard production process as well as subsequent emissions after the photon splitting, preserves the total rate through a unitary treatment of internal conversions, accounts for sensitivity to the definition of the fiducial region and detector simulations, and allows for direct comparison with experimental data. In particular we compare the Kroll-Wada equation to the Pythia8 version 8.313’s 1 1 1 We encountered a bug related to the enhanced radiations that is fixed starting from the indicated version. simple shower Bierlich:2022pfr and Vincia dipole shower models Brooks:2020upa . Finally, we demonstrate how the POWHEG BOX V2 Nason:2004rx ; Frixione:2007vw next-to-leading order (NLO) directphoton Jezo:2016ypn event generator can be used in conjunction with Pythia to simulate dileptons without an explicit need to determine the normalization of the theoretical prediction in a fit to data. This method is universal and can also be applied to other photon production mechanisms, for example direct photon production associated with two jets 2 2 2 An event generator for this process is also available in directphotonjj Jezo:2024wsc . . The current study intends to complement our recent study in Ref. Andronic:2024rfn in which the same computational approach was used to obtain precise predictions for the M_{ee} spectrum in the IMR. This paper is structured as follows. First in section 2 , we present the Kroll-Wada equation in its typical form. We derive it from the Altarelli-Parisi splitting function in section 2.2 and in the Vincia dipole shower formalism Brooks:2020upa in section 2.3 . In section 3 we compare the PS approach to the Kroll-Wada equation to PHENIX ( section 3.1 ) and ALICE ( section 3.2 ) data. Finally, we conclude in section 4 . 2 Dielectron pairs from photons Photons are an important source of dielectron pairs in LHC experiments. One prominent production mechanism is the external photon conversion ,

Read the complete text