Separating polynomial invariants over non-closed fields of finite abelian groups

Mátyás Domokos · 2025

Read Separating polynomial invariants over non-closed fields of finite abelian groups by Mátyás Domokos (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-22889.txt.

Introduction

Mátyás Domokos wrote a 2025 mathematics paper on how simple the polynomials can be that tell apart the orbits of a group action. Invariant polynomials stay fixed under a group's symmetries; a separating set need only distinguish different orbits, not capture everything. Over the rational numbers, fields that are not algebraically closed complicate the picture.

Domokos proves that for any representation of a prime-order group over the rationals, invariants of degree at most three already separate all orbits. He also generalizes a known degree bound for finite abelian groups from closed fields to ordinary ones like the reals and rationals. Small separating sets make symmetry computations far cheaper.

Catalog record

CREATORMátyás Domokos
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE57 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-22889

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Separating polynomial invariants over non-closed fields of finite abelian groups Mátyás Domokos Abstract . It is proved that for any finite dimensional representation of a prime order group over the field of rational numbers, polynomial invariants of degree at most 3 3 separate the orbits. A result providing an upper degree bound for separating invariants for representations of finite abelian groups over algebraically closed base fields of non-modular characteristic is generalized for the case of base fields that are not algebraically closed (like the fields of real or rational numbers). 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary 13A50; Secondary 13P15, 20C15, 94A12 1. Introduction This work is largely motivated by [ 1 ] , where the authors develop an approach to multireference alignment using invariant theory. Multireference alignment is a basic problem in applied mathematics, which arose in connection with structural biology, image recognition, and signal processing (see e.g. the introduction of [ 2 ] ). It was shown in [ 23 ] that the sample complexity of multireference alignment is related to the orbit recovery problem for the cyclic group \mathrm{C}_{n} acting by cyclic shifts on the space \mathbb{R}^{n} . In particular, in [ 1 , Theorem 4.1] a Galois theoretic proof is given for the fact that for the regular representation over \mathbb{R} of a finite abelian group, the field of rational invariants is generated by polynomial invariants of degree at most 3 (and hence generic orbits can be separated by polynomial invariants of degree at most 3 ). This is in fact a special case of a theorem on the regular representation of an arbitrary finite group (see [ 1 , Remark 4.3] , [ 16 ] ; a generalization is given in [ 3 ] ), but here first we shall focus on the special case of cyclic groups of prime order p . It is proved in [ 4 , Proposition 3.13] that for a faithful finite dimensional real representation of \mathrm{C}_{p} , polynomial invariants of degree smaller than p are not sufficient to separate the orbits. In sharp contrast with that result, our Theorem 4.1 says that different orbits in \mathbb{Q}^{p} under the regular representation of \mathrm{C}_{p} can always be separated by invariants of degree at most 3 . As a consequence, the same conclusion holds for any finite dimensional representation of \mathrm{C}_{p} over the field \mathbb{Q} of rational numbers. As far as we know, this is the first example in the literature of a finite group whose separating Noether number over an infinite field \mathbb{F} is not equal to its separating Noether number over the algebraic closure of \mathbb{F} (see Section 2 for the definition of the separating Noether number). Also our Theorem 4.1 gives the first example of a field \mathbb{F} and an infinite set of pairwise non-isomorphic groups such that the separating Noether numbers over \mathbb{F} of the groups in the given set stay below a uniform upper bound. Note that a similar scenario does not occur for the ordinary Noether number (defined in terms of generating invariants, as opposed to separating invariants), because [ 8 , Theorem 2.1] (and [ 24 ] in the modular case) imply that for any field \mathbb{F} , any infinite set of pairwise non-isomorphic finite groups contains an element with arbitrarily large Noether number. The study of separating invariants over the field of rational numbers may have interest from the point of view of applications, because the numerical data in applications are rational (have finite decimal representation), so the orbit recovery problem over \mathbb{Q} has relevance. We provide a theoretical explanation for the phenomenon revealed by Theorem 4.1 by placing it into a more general context. In fact a second motivation for this paper is that while degree bounds for separating invariants of finite abelian groups over the complex field are relatively well understood (see [ 12 ] , [ 26 ] , [ 27 ] , [ 28 ] ), only sporadic information is available about the exact degree bounds for real representations of these groups. It is desirable to fill in this gap in the literature, because several applications require to work over the real field (see for example the problems mentioned in the introduction of [ 6 ] , or see [ 7 ] ). Recall that every representation of a finite abelian group over an algebraically closed base field of non-modular characteristic decomposes as a direct sum of 1 -dimensional representations, and therefore the corresponding algebra of polynomial invariants is generated by monomials. Separating sets of monomials were characterized in [ 12 ] (see [ 13 ] and [ 15 ] for similar results on not necessarily finite diagonalizable group actions). Here in Theorem 5.4 we work out the generalization of this result appropriate for representations of finite abelian groups over non-algebraically closed base fields, where we can not diagonalize a representation. Theorem 5.4 clarifies the reason why the degree bound for separating invariants is smaller in general, than the corresponding degree bound when we replace the base field by its algebraic closure. We begin in Section 2 by recalling some basic concepts and notation of invariant theory. In Section 3 we deduce from an observation on the block monoid Proposition 3.2 , which is a variant of [ 1 , Theorem 4.1] about generically separating invariants on the complex regular representation of a finite abelian group. This is then used to prove Theorem 4.1 on the regular representation of \mathrm{C}_{p} over the field \mathbb{Q} of rational numbers. We conclude Section 4 by Proposition 4.4 and Proposition 4.5 , showing that Theorem 4.1 does not generalize for cyclic groups of composite order, or for non-abelian groups. In Section 5 we first recall in Proposition 5.1 the classification of irreducible representations of a finite abelian group G over a not necessarily algebraically closed base field of non-modular characteristic. We state and prove Theorem 5.4 giving a sufficient condition for a set of monomials (defined over the algebraic closure of the base field \mathbb{F} ) to separate the orbits in the regular representation of G over \mathbb{F} , and deduce in Corollary 5.6 an improved bound on the separating Noether number of G over \mathbb{F} . This improvement is illustrated by a concrete example in Proposition 5.8 and Section 6 . 2. Preliminaries in invariant theory Let us recall some standard notation of invariant theory. Throughout this paper G will be a finite group, and \mathbb{F} a field whose characteristic does not divide the order of G . Let V be a finite dimensional vector space over \mathbb{F} , endowed with a representation of G on V ; that is, we are given a homomorphism \rho from G into the group \mathrm{GL}(V) of invertible linear transformations of V . Sometimes we shall refer to a representation as the pair (V,\rho) , or we say that V is an \mathbb{F}G -module. Write \mathbb{F}[V] for the coordinate ring of V . This is a polynomial algebra in \dim_{\mathbb{F}}(V) commuting variables endowed with the standard grading (where the variables have degree 1 ). The variables are thought of as the coordinate functions on V with respect to a chosen basis, and the elements of \mathbb{F}[V] represent \mathbb{F} -valued

Read the complete text