Impact of Outreach on Physics Student Development: Qualitative Results from a National Survey

Jonathan D. Perry, Carlee Garrett, Isabella Oaks, James Hirons, Toni Sauncy, Jonan P. Donaldson, Susan White, Rachel L Ivie, Tatiana Erukhimova · 2025

Read Impact of Outreach on Physics Student Development: Qualitative Results from a National Survey by Jonathan D. Perry, Carlee Garrett, Isabella Oaks, James Hirons, Toni Sauncy, Jonan P. Donaldson, Susan White, Rachel L Ivie, Tatiana Erukhimova (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-22700.txt.

Introduction

Jonathan Perry and a team of co-authors report survey results from twenty twenty-five on physics outreach. Outreach means students running informal physics events for people outside the field. Small studies at single schools have linked such work to growth in students. Gains named include a stronger sense of identity in physics, more learning, and a greater feeling of belonging.

The open question was whether those gains show up only at schools with strong programs. This work used a national survey sent out through student physics groups. The team studied answers to three open-ended questions from students who had led outreach. Readers get a wider view of what running such events does for the students themselves.

Catalog record

CREATORJonathan D. Perry, Carlee Garrett, Isabella Oaks, James Hirons, Toni Sauncy, Jonan P. Donaldson, Susan White, Rachel L Ivie, Tatiana Erukhimova
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE54 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-22700

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Impact of Outreach on Physics Student Development: Qualitative Results from a National Survey Jonathan D. Perry, Carlee Garrett, Isabella Oaks, James Hirons, Toni Sauncy, Jonan P. Donaldson, Susan White, Rachel L Ivie, Tatiana Erukhimova Abstract The role of student experiences in physics beyond the classroom which support their development has been the subject of exciting research in recent years. Results, typically from small studies at single institutions, have illustrated that facilitating informal physics experiences for non-scientists can enhance student disciplinary identity, learning, sense of belonging, and more. However, it is essential to examine whether these impacts are the sole provenance of institutions with well-developed outreach programs or if they may be shared by institutions anywhere. This work reports on the analysis and findings of responses to three open-ended questions presented to students who indicated they had engaged in facilitating outreach programs as part of a national survey distributed through the Society of Physics Students network in spring 2023. Employing a network analysis with Girvan-Newman clusters revealed six core themes of student experiences: community participation , resilience , transformation , audience dialog , disciplinary development , and disciplinary connectedness . The first four of these clusters were observed to be highly interconnected, providing evidence that the impacts and experiences within them are interrelated with other clusters, particularly interactions with the audience, which is a central feature of informal physics programs. In particular, student experiences highlighted that facilitating informal physics programs enhanced their resilience and belonging, grew their physics identity, provided opportunities to develop essential career skills, and cultivated a growth mindset. I Introduction Physics departments across the country aim to enrich the educational experience of physics majors and prepare them for their careers. While high-quality coursework and lab activities are central priorities, students often benefit from impactful experiences beyond the classroom. One such experience is engaging students with extracurricular activities such as physics outreach, also called public engagement or informal physics programs, that university students facilitate. These programs can differ significantly in size and frequency Bell et al. 2009 ; Council et al. 2015 , but they give physics majors opportunities to share their enthusiasm for physics and astronomy with the public, helping them see themselves as active members of the physics community Bergerson et al. 2014 ; Hansen et al. 2025 ; Clark et al. 2016 ; Fracchiolla et al. 2020 ; Garner et al. 2018 ; Garrett et al. 2023 ; Hinko and Finkelstein 2012 ; Perry et al. 2021 ; Randolph et al. 2022 ; Rethman et al. 2021 ; Tillinghast et al. 2020 ; Perry et al. 2024 . Less structured than coursework, outreach programs offer physics majors opportunities beyond the traditional focus of physics coursework, such as leadership, creativity, teamwork, and communication. According to studies by the American Physical Society (APS) and the American Association of Physics Teachers (AAPT), these skills have been identified as a high priority for physics programs to prepare students for careers in the 21st century Heron and McNeil 2016 ; McNeil and Heron 2017 ; Mulvey and Pold 2020 ; Pold and Mulvey 2015 ; Sarkar et al. 2016 . In fact, communication remains regarded as one of the main skills that contributes to the employability of students in STEM Heron and McNeil 2016 ; Leshner 2007 ; noa 2017 ; Foster et al. 2010 . A recent survey from the American Institute of Physics’s (AIP) Statistical Research group shows that more than 80% of physics bachelor’s degree holders who graduated in 2019 or 2020 report that they work as a member of a team daily in their job aip . By bringing physics beyond the classroom, students are expected to engage with material in different ways and gain opportunities to interact with a variety of personnel from their home departments. One of the major facets of these programs is students engaging in self-explanation of physics concepts Rethman et al. 2021 ; Finkelstein and Mayhew 2008 ; Hinko and Finkelstein 2012 ; Hinko et al. 2014 ; Hansen et al. 2025 which has been noted to enhance their learning Garrett et al. 2023 . Students also gain the opportunity to work side by side with graduate students, researchers, and professors to create and facilitate public engagement which may help them build professional networks and identity. Serving as ambassadors for physics helps them stay motivated and interested in their major. They get recognition as STEM professionals by the general public, their professors, and their peers Rethman et al. 2021 ; Randolph et al. 2022 ; Perry et al. 2021 ; Perry et al. 2024 ; Perry et al. 2025 . These often impactful and transformative experiences in communicating physics to diverse populations allow students to gain new perspectives and develop self-recognition as physics professionals. By explaining physics to others, students can improve their conceptual understanding. In other words, facilitating outreach physics programs helps students build a disciplinary identity and a sense of belonging within their major and the physics community—factors found to be impactful for student retention and success in the field Lewis et al. 2016 ; Yeager et al. 2016a ; James et al. 2020 ; Williams et al. 2021 ; Dobbins 2020 ; Walton and Cohen 2007 . In our pilot study at Texas A&M University, we surveyed and interviewed students who facilitated five physics outreach programs, ranging from short student-created demonstration videos to a large-scale Physics Festival attended by thousands Rethman et al. 2021 . Our dataset included 117 survey responses and 35 semi-structured interviews, representing both undergraduate and graduate students. The results were inspiring: students who participated in physics outreach reported growth in their physics identity, a stronger sense of belonging within the physics community, and the development of essential 21st-century career skills. Specifically, they reported improvements in communication, teamwork, networking, and design skills. However, our results, as well as other available research, were limited to individual departments and a small number of engaged physics majors. Addressing this gap by surveying a larger number of students engaged in outreach from diverse type of institutions is important. If the Physics Education Research community has compelling data showing that engaging physics majors in facilitating outreach programs can help them build their disciplinary identity and sense of belonging within the physics community, while also enhancing their career readiness by fostering teamwork, communication, and design skills—this could be of significant interest to many physics departments. These benefits, which enhance students’ university experience by involving them in outreach facilitation, can be achieved by physics departments of any size without requiring significant financial investment or major curriculum changes. In this paper, we present the results of our first nationwide study. Building on our pilot study survey Rethman et al. 2021 and leveraging collaborative expertise from Texas Lutheran University, Texas A&M University, the University of Texas at Austin, and the Statistical Research Group of the American Institute of Physics, we developed a new survey instrument incorporating both closed- and open-ended questions Perry et al. 2025 . To maximize responses from undergraduate physics students, we distributed the survey to individual physics majors through the national network of the Society of Physics Students (SPS). This effort resulted in a robust dataset of 704 responses, allowing for a

Read the complete text