Distinguishing Siegel modular forms

Arvind Kumar and Ariel Weiss · 2025

Read Distinguishing Siegel modular forms by Arvind Kumar and Ariel Weiss (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-22264.txt.

Introduction

Arvind Kumar and Ariel Weiss prove a test for telling deep number-theory objects apart by their fingerprints. The objects, Siegel modular forms, are highly symmetric functions prized in modern number theory. Each carries a list of numbers, one per prime, called Hecke eigenvalues. A classic result says matching lists mean matching forms; this paper asks about looser links.

Suppose the two lists obey any fixed polynomial relation at many primes. The authors prove the forms must then be the same up to a standard twisting and a scale factor. Their proof studies the symmetry group tied to the pair and shows it is as large as possible unless the forms are linked. The method also covers the older elliptic case, unifying both under one argument.

Catalog record

CREATORArvind Kumar and Ariel Weiss
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE67 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-22264

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Distinguishing Siegel modular forms Arvind Kumar and Ariel Weiss Abstract . Let f f and f ′ f^{\prime} be genus 2 2 cuspidal Siegel paramodular newforms. We prove that if their Hecke eigenvalues a p a_{p} and a p ′ a_{p}^{\prime} satisfy a non-trivial polynomial relation P ⁡ ( a p , a p ′ ) = 0 P(a_{p},a_{p}^{\prime})=0 for a set of primes p p of positive density, then f f and f ′ f^{\prime} are twists of each other by a Dirichlet character. In particular, if both forms have trivial nebentypus, then they differ by a quadratic twist. This result extends the strong multiplicity one theorem, which handles the case P ⁡ ( x , y ) = x − y P(x,y)=x-y , to arbitrary polynomial relations. Our proof analyses the image of the product Galois representation attached to the pair ( f , f ′ ) (f,f^{\prime}) : we show that this image is as large as possible, unless f f is a twist of f ′ f^{\prime} . Our results also apply to elliptic modular forms. They therefore provide a unified method for distinguishing both elliptic and Siegel modular forms based on their Hecke data, including their Hecke eigenvalues, Satake parameters, Sato–Tate angles, and the coefficients of their L L -functions. We apply our methods to recover and generalise a range of existing results and to prove new ones in both the elliptic and Siegel settings. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary: 11F80, 11F46; Secondary: 11R45 1. Introduction Let f and f^{\prime} be genus 2 , cuspidal Siegel paramodular newforms. Suppose that for almost all primes p , their Hecke eigenvalues a_{p} and a_{p}^{\prime} satisfy a fixed polynomial relation P(a_{p},a_{p}^{\prime})=0 . What is the relationship between f and f^{\prime} ? If P(x,y)=x-y , then this question is answered by the strong multiplicity one theorem [ 33 , 34 , 10 ] , which states that a_{p}=a_{p}^{\prime} for almost all primes p if and only if f is a scalar multiple of f^{\prime} . But for other polynomials, this conclusion fails. For example, a form and its quadratic twists have Hecke eigenvalues satisfying a_{p}^{2}={a_{p}^{\prime}}^{2} for all p , yet are not scalar multiples. In this paper, we show that twists are the only possible exceptions: if a_{p} and a_{p}^{\prime} satisfy a non-trivial polynomial relation for a positive proportion of primes, then f and f^{\prime} must be twists of each other by a Dirichlet character. This result can be viewed as a refinement of the strong multiplicity one theorem: even partial algebraic information about a form’s Hecke eigenvalues is sufficient to determine it up to twist. We now state our result more precisely. Assume that f and f^{\prime} have weights (k_{1},k_{2}) and (k_{1}^{\prime},k_{2}^{\prime}) —i.e. weights \Sym^{k_{1}-k_{2}}\det^{k_{2}} and \Sym^{k_{1}^{\prime}-k_{2}^{\prime}}\det^{k_{2}^{\prime}} —with k_{1}\geq k_{2}\geq 2 and k_{1}^{\prime}\geq k_{2}^{\prime}\geq 2 , levels N and N^{\prime} , and characters \epsilon and \epsilon^{\prime} . Suppose that f and f^{\prime} are of general type (type (G) in the notation of [ 33 ] ), and that neither has complex multiplication (CM), real multiplication (RM), or arises as a symmetric cube lift. Let \pi,\pi^{\prime} be the corresponding cuspidal automorphic representations of \GSp_{4}(\mathbf{A}_{\mathbf{Q}}) . Theorem 1.1 . Let P(a,a^{\prime})\in\overline{\mathbf{Q}}[a,a^{\prime}] be any non-zero polynomial. Suppose that for a set of primes p of positive upper density P(a_{p},a_{p}^{\prime})=0. Then (k_{1},k_{2})=(k_{1}^{\prime},k_{2}^{\prime}) and there is Dirichlet character \chi such that \pi\simeq\pi^{\prime}\otimes\chi . In particular, if \epsilon=\epsilon^{\prime}=1 then f is a scalar multiple of a quadratic twist of f^{\prime} . More generally, we show that an algebraic relation among any of the Hecke eigenvalues of a Siegel modular form f is sufficient to determine it up to twist. The Hecke algebra of f is generated by T(p) , T(p^{2}) , and the diamond operator \Delta(p) . The T(p) -Hecke eigenvalues a_{p} of a Siegel modular form f are the coefficients of its spinor L -function (1.1) \displaystyle L_{\mathrm{spin}}(f,s) \displaystyle=\prod_{p}L_{p,\mathrm{spin}}(f,s)=L(\epsilon^{2},2s-u+1)\sum_{n\geq 1}a_{n}n^{-s} where u=k_{1}+k_{2}-3 , and for p\nmid N , by [ 2 ] *(5.64) and [ 6 ] *pp. 1499, we have L_{p,\mathrm{spin}}(f,s)=(1-a_{p}p^{-s}+(a_{p}^{2}-a_{p^{2}}-\epsilon(p^{2})p^{u-1})p^{-2s}-a_{p}\epsilon(p^{2})p^{u}p^{-3s}+\epsilon(p^{4})p^{2u}p^{-4s}))^{-1}. Let (1.2) b_{p}=\frac{a_{p}^{2}-a_{p^{2}}}{\epsilon(p^{2})p^{u}}-\frac{1}{p}-1. Then b_{p} satisfies the equation (b_{p}+1)\epsilon(p^{2})p^{u}=a_{p}^{2}-a_{p^{2}}-\epsilon(p^{2})p^{u-1} and is the coefficient of the standard L -function of f , L_{\std}(f,s)=\sum_{n\geq 1}b_{n}n^{-s}. We prove the following more general result, from which Theorem 1.1 follows immediately: Theorem 1.2 . Let P(s,s^{\prime},a,b,a^{\prime},b^{\prime})\in\overline{\mathbf{Q}}[s,\frac{1}{s},s^{\prime},\frac{1}{s^{\prime}},a,b,a^{\prime},b^{\prime}] be a non-zero polynomial. Assume that P is coprime to s^{\kappa}-{s^{\prime}}^{\kappa^{\prime}} , where \kappa,\kappa^{\prime} are integers defined in ( 1.3 ). Suppose that for a set of primes p of positive upper density P(\epsilon(p^{2})p^{k_{1}+k_{2}-3},\epsilon^{\prime}(p^{2})p^{k_{1}^{\prime}+k_{2}^{\prime}-3},a_{p},b_{p},a_{p}^{\prime},b_{p}^{\prime})=0. Then (k_{1},k_{2})=(k_{1}^{\prime},k_{2}^{\prime}) and there is Dirichlet character \chi such that \pi\simeq\pi^{\prime}\otimes\chi . In particular, if \epsilon=\epsilon^{\prime}=1 then f is a scalar multiple of a quadratic twist of f^{\prime} . The coprimality condition on P is necessary to rule out trivial polynomial relations that can arise from the weights and characters of f and f^{\prime} . This result strengthens the observation in [ 26 , 10 ] on the strong multiplicity one theorem, where the authors note that it is “remarkable” that the eigenvalues a_{p} alone suffice to determine f , despite the fact that the Hecke algebra is not generated by T(p) . We show that an algebraic relation involving any of the Hecke eigenvalues for just a positive proportion of primes suffices to determine the form up to twist. Remark 1.3 . The conclusion that \pi\simeq\pi^{\prime}\otimes\chi can presumably be strengthened to f=f^{\prime}\otimes\chi , but we are not aware of a reference that constructs arbitrary twists of paramodular newforms. However, if f and f^{\prime} both have trivial nebentypus character, then the conclusion \pi\simeq\pi^{\prime}\otimes\chi implies that f is a scalar multiple of a quadratic twist of f^{\prime} . Indeed, in this case \pi and \pi^{\prime} have trivial central character, so \chi^{2}=1 , and the construction of quadratic twists of paramodular newforms is given in [ 15 ] . Remark 1.4 . If the levels N and N^{\prime} are squarefree, then the conclusion \pi\simeq\pi^{\prime}\otimes\chi implies that \chi is trivial, and hence that f is a scalar multiple of f^{\prime} . In Section 2 , we demonstrate how Theorems 1.1 and 1.2 can be used to prove a broad range of results that distinguish Siegel modular forms by their Hecke data. In addition to proving new results, we strengthen the results of [ 17 , 18 , 39 ] , and extend the scope of previous results from the elliptic modular setting to the setting of Siegel modular forms [ 27 , 29 , 28 , 16 , 23 , 24 , 12 , 25 , 44 ] . We also note that both theorems and their applications easily generalise to the case of elliptic modular forms, with analogous proofs (see Section 1.4 ). In the remainder of the introduction, we outline the proof of Theorem 1.2 . 1.1. Galois representations attached to Siegel modular forms To prove Theorem 1.2 , we reinterpret algebraic relations between Hecke eigenvalues as relations occurring in the images of Galois representations attached to Siegel modular forms. For each prime \ell , there exists a semisimple Galois representation \rho_{\ell}\colon\Gal(\overline{\mathbf{Q}}/{\mathbf{Q}})\to\GSp_{4}(\overline{\mathbf{Q}}_{\ell}) associated to f . This representation is unramified outside \ell N , and if p\nmid\ell N , then the characteristic polynomial of \rho_{\ell}(\Frob_{p}) agrees with the Euler factor of L_{\mathrm{spin}}(f,s) at p . In particular,

Read the complete text