Stretch to stretch, dust to dust: low-value local H 0 H_{0} measurement from two-population modelling of type Ia supernovae
Radosław Wojtak, Jens Hjorth · 2025
Read Stretch to stretch, dust to dust: low-value local H 0 H_{0} measurement from two-population modelling of type Ia supernovae by Radosław Wojtak, Jens Hjorth (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-22150.txt.
Introduction
Radosław Wojtak and Jens Hjorth remeasure the local expansion rate with split supernova families in a 2025 paper. Type Ia supernovae, calibrated by Cepheid stars, anchor the local Hubble constant. Their brightness correction leans on a stretch measure that falls into two humps, hinting at two families.
The remodel treats the two families apart, in both inborn traits and dust dimming in their host galaxies. Family roots may differ, and their home settings differ as well. Letting each family carry its own correction shifts the local rate downward against the standard single-family read. The work adds a population lens to a famous measurement dispute.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Radosław Wojtak, Jens Hjorth |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 65 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-22150
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Stretch to stretch, dust to dust: low-value local H 0 H_{0} measurement from two-population modelling of type Ia supernovae Radosław Wojtak, Jens Hjorth Abstract Aims. We revisit the local Hubble constant measurement from type Ia supernovae calibrated with Cepheids (SH0ES) by remodelling the supernova data using two supernova populations emerging from the observed bimodal distribution of the SALT2 stretch parameter. Our analysis accounts for population differences in both intrinsic properties (related to possible initial conditions, including supernova progenitor channels) and host-galaxy extinction (expected from well-known environmental differences associated observationally with the two populations). Methods. Based on a two-population Bayesian hierarchical modelling of the SALT2 light-curve parameters from the Pantheon+ compilation, we simultaneously constrain intrinsic and extrinsic properties of both supernova populations, match probabilistically the calibration supernovae with the corresponding population in the Hubble flow, and derive the Hubble constant. Results. The difference between the two supernova populations is primarily driven by their mean absolute magnitudes and total-to-selective extinction coefficients. This is related but not equivalent to the traditional mass-step correction (including its broadening for reddened supernovae). The mean extinction coefficient of the supernova population used to propagate distances from the calibration galaxies to the Hubble flow is found to be consistent with the Milky Way-like interstellar dust model with R B ≈ 4 R_{\rm B}\approx 4 and substantially higher than the extinction model assumed in the SH0ES measurement. Allowing for possible differences between reddening in the calibration galaxies and the corresponding population in the Hubble flow, we obtain H 0 = 70.59 ± 1.15 H_{0}=70.59\pm{1.15} km s -1 Mpc -1 . For the most conservative choice assuming equal prior distributions, we find H 0 = 71.45 ± 1.03 H_{0}=71.45\pm{1.03} km s -1 Mpc -1 . Conclusions. Our reanalysis of type Ia supernovae results in a reduction of the discrepancy with the CMB-based Planck value of H 0 H_{0} by at least 30 per cent ( 3.5 σ 3.5\sigma ) and up to 50 per cent ( 2.2 σ 2.2\sigma ). We discuss the correspondence between our result and similar low-value estimates previously obtained from about 10 nearest calibration galaxies. 1 Introduction The Hubble constant measurement from the Supernova H0 for the Equation of State (SH0ES) programme ( Riess et al. 2022 ) is about 5\sigma discrepant with the CMB-based measurement from Planck observations assuming a flat \Lambda CDM cosmological model. Complementary CMB constraints ( Qu et al. 2025 , e.g. lensing power spectrum,) , measurements from independent instruments ( Balkenhol et al. 2023 , e.g. the South Pole Telescope,) or fitting the Planck data with alternative likelihood models ( Efstathiou et al. 2024 ) yield results which are consistent with the Planck cosmological model. This leaves very little room either for hidden systematic effects in the CMB observations or for pre-recombination modifications of the standard model devised to increase the Hubble constant derived from the CMB. A growing number of independent studies point to possible underestimated systematic uncertainties in the SH0ES measurement. The main focus has been put on observational tests or alternative modelling of the Cepheid data sector ( Freedman et al. 2025 ; Kushnir & Sharon 2025 ; Högås & Mörtsell 2025 , see e.g.) . However, particularly concerning although not fully appreciated are intrinsic anomalies found in the supernova data and associated with an overestimation of the Hubble constant ( Wojtak & Hjorth 2022 ; Perivolaropoulos & Skara 2023 ; Wojtak & Hjorth 2024 ; Gall et al. 2024 ; Hoyt et al. 2025 ) . These anomalies can be traced back, either directly ( Wojtak & Hjorth 2024 ) or indirectly (see section 5 and discussion therein), to the unresolved problem of how to model environmental effects on type Ia supernova brightness in a way that is both accurate and consistent with basic astrophysical properties such as interstellar extinction expected in supernova host galaxies. It has long been known that type Ia supernova properties vary across host-galaxy types and local stellar environments. Following early evidence for a relation between the width (decline rate) of type Ia supernova light curves and host-galaxy stellar populations ( Hamuy et al. 2000 ) , observations revealed tight correlations between this light curve parameter and the host-galaxy stellar age ( Sullivan et al. 2006 ) , the supernova progenitor age ( Howell et al. 2009 ) or the local specific star formation rate ( Rigault et al. 2013 ; Rigault et al. 2020 ) . Host galaxies modulate also supernova peak magnitudes, with variations which are not captured by first order standardisation methods such as the Tripp calibration ( Tripp 1998 ) . The relation is commonly studied as a (non-linear) correlation between supernova peak magnitude and the host-galaxy stellar mass ( Kelly et al. 2010 ; Sullivan et al. 2010 ; Smith et al. 2020 ) . Similar or statistically more significant correlations were also shown for other host-galaxy properties, for example the local specific star formation rate ( Rigault et al. 2020 ) . The physical nature of this multifaceted relation between type Ia supernova properties and their environment is not fully understood. Some models attempt to reduce the problem solely to the effect of extinction and its dependence on host galaxy properties ( Brout & Scolnic 2021 ; Popovic et al. 2023 ) . However, independent analyses of type Ia supernova data ( Wojtak et al. 2023 ; González-Gaitán et al. 2021 ; Grayling et al. 2024 , see e.g.) , tests against attenuation properties measured from host galaxy observations ( Duarte et al. 2023 ) or simulations of extinction in type Ia supernova sight lines ( Hallgren et al. 2025 ) , and modelling the role of the progenitor age ( Wiseman et al. 2021 ) point to a relevant contribution from supernova intrinsic properties correlated with the host-galaxy environment. Due to the fact that Cepheids are observed only in young late-type galaxies, the SH0ES programme introduces a strong implicit selection bias in type Ia supernova environments. With type Ia supernovae from the Hubble flow found in galaxies of all morphological types, the calibration galaxies (those with observed Cepheids and type Ia supernovae) do not constitute a representative sample of the Hubble flow. The SH0ES team attempts to mitigate the selection bias by restricting the Hubble flow to galaxies resembling those in the calibration sample ( Riess et al. 2022 ) . However, their extinction model is trained on the unrestricted Hubble flow data and then extrapolated to the calibration galaxies ( Popovic et al. 2023 ; Brout et al. 2022 ) . The extinction model employed in the Pantheon+ supernova compilation ( Brout et al. 2022 ) and subsequently used by ( Riess et al. 2022 ) to measure the Hubble constant ascribes different total-to-selective extinction coefficients to host galaxies with stellar mass larger or smaller than 10^{10}M_{\odot} ( Brout & Scolnic 2021 ) . The B-band extinction coefficient measured from high stellar-mass host galaxies in the Hubble flow is R_{\rm B}\approx 3 . Despite the fact that these galaxies consists predominantly of early morphological types, the model extrapolates the same extinction coefficient to the corresponding high stellar-mass calibration galaxies, which happen to make up 70 per cent of the entire calibration sample. The