Scale-resolved turbulent Prandtl number for Rayleigh-Bénard convection at \Pran = 𝟏𝟎 − 𝟑 \Pran\bm{=10^{-3}}

Shashwat Bhattacharya 1, Dmitry Krasnov 2, Ambrish Pandey 3, Toshiyuki Gotoh 4,5, Jörg Schumacher 2 · 2025

Read Scale-resolved turbulent Prandtl number for Rayleigh-Bénard convection at \Pran = 𝟏𝟎 − 𝟑 \Pran\bm{=10^{-3}} by Shashwat Bhattacharya 1, Dmitry Krasnov 2, Ambrish Pandey 3, Toshiyuki Gotoh 4,5, Jörg Schumacher 2 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-22110.txt.

Introduction

Shashwat Bhattacharya and four co-authors study swirling hot fluid in a 2025 physics paper. Their setup is a layer heated from below, a classic model of convection. The fluid has a very low Prandtl number, meaning heat spreads far slower than motion. They ask how the mixing of heat and motion changes across scales.

The team ran direct simulations of the layer across a range of heating strengths. They built a scale by scale measure of the mixing ratio from a classic theory. The measured ratio came out near ten, vastly above the molecular value. In effect, the wild flow behaves like a much thicker fluid. The finding backs earlier models of convection inside the Sun.

Catalog record

CREATORShashwat Bhattacharya 1, Dmitry Krasnov 2, Ambrish Pandey 3, Toshiyuki Gotoh 4,5, Jörg Schumacher 2
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE50 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-22110

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Scale-resolved turbulent Prandtl number for Rayleigh-Bénard convection at \Pran = 𝟏𝟎 − 𝟑 \Pran\bm{=10^{-3}} Shashwat Bhattacharya 1, Dmitry Krasnov 2, Ambrish Pandey 3, Toshiyuki Gotoh 4,5, Jörg Schumacher 2 Abstract We present a framework to calculate the scale-resolved turbulent Prandtl number \Pran t \Pran_{t} for the well-mixed and highly inertial bulk of a turbulent Rayleigh-Bénard mesoscale convection layer at a molecular Prandtl number \Pran = 10 − 3 \Pran=10^{-3} . It builds on Kolmogorov’s refined similarity hypothesis of homogeneous isotropic fluid and passive scalar turbulence, based on log-normally distributed amplitudes of kinetic energy and scalar dissipation rates that are coarse-grained over variable scales r r in the inertial subrange. Our definition of turbulent (or eddy) viscosity and diffusivity does not rely on mean gradient-based Boussinesq closures of Reynolds stresses and convective heat fluxes. Such gradients are practically absent or indefinite in the bulk. The present study is based on direct numerical simulation of plane-layer convection at an aspect ratio of Γ = 25 \Gamma=25 for Rayleigh numbers 10 5 ≤ R ​ a ≤ 10 7 10^{5}\leq Ra\leq 10^{7} . We find that the turbulent Prandtl number is effectively up to 4 orders of magnitude larger than the molecular one, \Pran t ∼ 10 \Pran_{t}\sim 10 . This holds particularly for the upper end of the inertial subrange, where the eddy diffusivity exceeds the molecular value, κ e ​ ( r ) > κ \kappa_{e}(r)>\kappa . Highly inertial low-Prandtl-number convection behaves effectively as a high-Prandtl number flow, which also supports previous models for the prominent application case of solar convection. \captionsetup justification=justified, width=1 † † affiliation: 1 School of Mechanical and Materials Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology Mandi, Kamand 175005, India 2 Institute of Thermodynamics and Fluid Mechanics, Technische Universität Ilmenau, P.O.Box 100565, D-98684 Ilmenau, Germany 3 Department of Physics, Indian Institute of Technology Roorkee, Roorkee 247667, India 4 Department of Engineering, Nagoya Institute of Technology, Nagoya 466-8555, Japan 5 Research and Education Center for Natural Sciences, Keio University, Hiyoshi, Yokohama, 223-8521, Japan 1 Introduction The turbulent Prandtl number \Pran_{t} is an essential parameter in many turbulence applications, particularly for astrophysical or geophysical examples with extreme amplitudes of their dimensionless control parameters, such as in solar and stellar convection ( Schumacher & Sreenivasan 2020 ; Käpylä 2021 ; Garaud 2021 ; Alam et al. 2025 ) . It is required to construct accurate turbulence models for simulating highly turbulent heat transport in the Sun and other stars, or in the atmosphere ( Li 2019 ) , along with various engineering applications, such as cooling liquid metal blankets in nuclear reactors ( Otić & Grötzbach 2007 ) . The turbulent Prandtl number is given as the ratio of the turbulent viscosity \nu_{e} to the turbulent diffusivity \kappa_{e} : \Pran_{t}=\frac{\nu_{e}}{\kappa_{e}}\,. (1) The values of \nu_{e} and \kappa_{e} can differ by orders of magnitude from their molecular counterparts, the molecular viscosity \nu and the molecular diffusivity \kappa . Thus, they shift the range of \Pran_{t} significantly away from that of the molecular value \Pran=\nu/\kappa . For moderate Prandtl number fluids at \Pran\sim 1 , such as air and water, \Pran_{t} is predicted with reasonable accuracy using the Reynolds analogy, according to which the eddies that are responsible for the turbulent transport of momentum are also responsible for transporting heat ( Bricteux et al. 2012 ; Li 2019 ; Abe & Antonia 2019 ) . This argument implies that \Pran_{t}\approx 1 . Rüdiger 1989 derived turbulent Prandtl numbers of \Pran_{t}\sim{\cal O}(1) by analytical mean field calculations in Fourier spectral space for 0.01\lesssim\Pran\lesssim 1 . It must be noted that Reynolds’ analogy does not hold true for liquid metals ( \Pran\ll 1 ), for which \Pran_{t} has been observed to be larger than unity ( Reynolds 1975 ; Jischa & Rieke 1979 ; Bricteux et al. 2012 ) . Similar observations have been made for passive scalars by Donzis et al. 2014 for the turbulent Schmidt number in case of passive scalar mixing. Recent investigations on turbulent channel flow ( Abe & Antonia 2019 ) and thermal convection ( Tai et al. 2021 ; Pandey et al. 2021 ; Pandey et al. 2022a ) suggest that \Pran_{t} increases with decreasing \Pran . Turbulent Prandtl numbers that deviate strongly from unity can have a significant impact on the range of scales which have to be resolved in simulation models ( Bekki et al. 2017 ; Karak et al. 2018 ; Pandey et al. 2021 ; Pandey et al. 2022a , see, for example) . In both parameters, \nu_{e} and \kappa_{e} , the effect of the turbulent fluctuations at the smallest unresolvable scales is condensed. These fluctuations are typically highly intermittent; however, they are not incorporated in derivations of \Pran_{t} . Turbulent viscosity and diffusivity can be obtained by the so-called Boussinesq or flux-gradient ansatz for the turbulent stresses, which is given by \langle u_{i}^{\prime}u_{j}^{\prime}\rangle\approx-\nu_{e}\left(\frac{\partial\langle u_{i}\rangle}{\partial x_{j}}+\frac{\partial\langle u_{j}\rangle}{\partial x_{i}}\right)\quad\mbox{and}\quad\langle u_{i}^{\prime}T^{\prime}\rangle\approx-\kappa_{e}\frac{\partial\langle T\rangle}{\partial x_{i}}\,, (2) with i,j\in\{x,y,z\} . In equations ( 2 ), the Reynolds decompositions u_{i}=\langle u_{i}\rangle+u_{i}^{\prime} and T=\langle T\rangle+T^{\prime} are used, where \langle\cdot\rangle represents the mean and the prime represents the corresponding fluctuation about the mean. These relations rely on the existence of monotonic mean gradient profiles in the flow at hand. Käpylä & Singh 2022 used the flux-gradient ansatz to analyse turbulent Prandtl numbers for 0.01\leq\Pran\leq 10 , and obtained \Pran_{t}\sim 1 for bulk turbulence, which is sustained by forcing a sinusoidal shear mode that does not affect the local isotropy, but generates a finite mean gradient. Such gradients are absent in Rayleigh-Bénard convection (RBC) for the mean velocity components, as shown recently in Samuel et al. 2024 . Other examples are transiently growing convective boundary layers ( Heyder et al. 2024 ) , which have a zero mean temperature gradient and require additional mass-flux parametrizations for the buoyancy flux ( Siebesma et al. 2007 ) . The RBC setup, which is of interest for the present discussion, consists of a fluid enclosed between two parallel horizontal plates of vertical distance H , with the bottom plate kept at a higher temperature than the top plate. Recently, Pandey et al. 2021 ; Pandey et al. 2022a computed \Pran_{t} for a wide range of Prandtl numbers in RBC using the k_{u} - \epsilon framework, where k_{u} is the turbulent kinetic energy and \epsilon is the viscous dissipation rate. However, the study assumed that the ratio of the unknown prefactors of \nu_{e} and \kappa_{e} is constant. The validity of this assumption has not yet been verified. In this paper, we examine the turbulent Prandtl number of RBC at a very low molecular Prandtl number of \Pran=10^{-3} . We calculate \Pran_{t} on the basis of the refined similarity theory, which was developed by Kolmogorov 1962 and Obukhov 1962 for homogeneous isotropic turbulence and is known under the abbreviation K62. We consider the bulk of an extended turbulent mesoscale convection layer, where the active character of the temperature field as a driver of fluid motion becomes less important in comparison to that in the boundary layers close to the bottom and top walls. Therefore, we can apply an extension of the K62 framework, which was developed by Stolovitzky et al. 1995 for passively advected scalar fields in a turbulent flow.

Read the complete text