Estimating Average Causal Effects with Incomplete Exposure and Confounders
Lan Wen ∗ and Glen McGee Department of Statistics and Actuarial Science, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, Ontario, Canada [email protected] · 2025
Read Estimating Average Causal Effects with Incomplete Exposure and Confounders by Lan Wen ∗ and Glen McGee Department of Statistics and Actuarial Science, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, Ontario, Canada [email protected] (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-21786.txt.
Introduction
Lan Wen and Glen McGee tackle causal estimates when key data are missing. Their twenty twenty-five paper asks for the average effect of a treatment, but in real studies the exposure and the confounders are often partly unrecorded. Their case study asks whether prescription opioid use raises the risk of death.
Standard fixes work when data are missing at random, but can bias the answer when they are not. The pair sets out several stated assumptions for the harder case. Under each, they show the effect can still be pinned down from the seen data. They build doubly robust estimators that stay valid if one of two model parts is right, and test them in simulations and survey data.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Lan Wen ∗ and Glen McGee Department of Statistics and Actuarial Science, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, Ontario, Canada [email protected] |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 55 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-21786
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Estimating Average Causal Effects with Incomplete Exposure and Confounders Lan Wen ∗ and Glen McGee Department of Statistics and Actuarial Science, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, Ontario, Canada [email protected] Abstract . Standard methods for estimating average causal effects require complete observations of the exposure and confounders. In observational studies, however, missing data are ubiquitous. Motivated by a study on the effect of prescription opioids on mortality, we propose methods for estimating average causal effects when exposures and potential confounders may be missing. We consider missingness at random and additionally propose several specific missing not at random (MNAR) assumptions. Under our proposed MNAR assumptions, we show that the average causal effects are identified from the observed data and derive corresponding influence functions in a nonparametric model, which form the basis of our proposed estimators. Our simulations show that standard multiple imputation techniques paired with a complete data estimator is unbiased when data are missing at random (MAR) but can be biased otherwise. For each of the MNAR assumptions, we instead propose doubly robust targeted maximum likelihood estimators (TMLE), allowing misspecification of either (i) the outcome models or (ii) the exposure and missingness models. The proposed methods are suitable for any outcome types, and we apply them to a motivating study that examines the effect of prescription opioid usage on all-cause mortality using data from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES). First draft : October 29, 2023 Current draft : June 23, 2025 causal inference; double robustness; missing not at random; multiple imputation; outcome-independent missingness; targeted learning. 1. Introduction Observational studies are often used to investigate causal questions in epidemiology. When outcomes, exposures and confounders are all completely observed, estimating causal effects proceeds via standard estimation techniques like parametric g-formula ( Taubman and others 2009 ; Lajous and others 2013 ; Lodi and others 2015 ) , propensity score-based methods ( Hernán and others 2000 ; Cain and others 2010 ; Neugebauer and others 2014 ) , or doubly robust methods ( Bang and Robins 2005 ; Tran and others 2019 ; Wen and others 2023 ) . A limitation of observational studies, however, is that data are often missing. Consider, for example, a motivating analysis of the 1999—2004 cycle of the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES), which found that opioid prescriptions increased risk of all-cause mortality ( Inoue and others 2022 ) . Our interest lies in estimating the average causal effect of opioid prescription on 5-year all-cause mortality among the elderly, and the data include several potential confounders. The NHANES data is linked to the National Death Index mortality data, so while the outcome of interest is fully observed, missing data arise in the exposure and potential confounders. More specifically, 24% of observations were missing either the exposure of interest or a confounder in the analytic sample, so standard methods that rely on data being complete may not apply. Extensions have been proposed to accommodate either missing exposures ( Williamson and others 2012 ; Zhang and others 2016 ; Kennedy 2020 ; Sperrin and Martin 2020 ) or missing confounders ( Qu and Lipkovich 2009 ; Crowe and others 2010 ; Mitra and Reiter 2011 ; Seaman and White 2014 ; Williamson and others 2012 ; Evans and others 2020 ; Levis 2022 ; Ross and others 2022 ; D’Agostino and Rubin 2000 ; Ding and Geng 2014 ; Yang and others 2019 ; Guan and Yang 2019 ; Sun and Liu 2021 ; Miao and Tchetgen Tchetgen 2018 ; Blake and others 2020b ; Blake and others 2020a ; Lu and Ashmead 2018 ; Mattei 2009 ) . When the exposure is missing at random (MAR; Rubin 1976 ; Seaman and others 2013 ; Mohan and Pearl 2021 ) and confounders are fully observed, several authors proposed augmented inverse probability weighted estimators ( Williamson and others 2012 ; Zhang and others 2016 ; Kennedy 2020 ) . When confounders are MAR and exposure is fully observed, existing methods include multiple imputation (MI) ( Qu and Lipkovich 2009 ; Crowe and others 2010 ; Mitra and Reiter 2011 ; Seaman and White 2014 ) , influence function-based estimators ( Scharfstein and others 1999 ; Evans and others 2020 ; Levis 2022 ) and inverse probability weighting (IPW; Ross and others 2022 ). When confounders are missing not at random (MNAR), further assumptions are needed. Under an outcome-independence assumption ( Ding and Geng 2014 ) , proposed approaches include two-stage least squares estimation ( Yang and others 2019 ) , imputation strategies ( Guan and Yang 2019 ) , and doubly robust estimation ( Sun and Liu 2021 ) —though all rely on a rank constraint (also referred to as a completeness condition) that precludes binary outcomes. Other authors assumed existence of a shadow variable ( Miao and Tchetgen Tchetgen 2018 ) or that covariates act as confounders only when they are observed ( Rosenbaum and Rubin 1984 ; D’Agostino and Rubin 2000 ; Blake and others 2020a ; Blake and others 2020b ) . Missingness is not restricted to only exposures or only confounders, yet there exists limited guidance on estimating average causal effects when both exposure and confounders may be missing. Several authors provided algorithms for identifiability and/or testability based on graphical models, but did not discuss plausibility of the graphs nor estimation in causal settings ( Mohan and others 2013 ; Mohan and Pearl 2014 ; Bhattacharya and others 2020 ; Nabi and Bhattacharya 2023 ) . Starting from Directed Acyclic Graphs (DAGs) depicting missingness mechanisms (m-DAGs), Moreno-Betancur and others 2018 discussed identifiability of causal quantities but limited discussion of estimation to available-case analysis and MI (see Dashti and others 2021 ). In particular, they noted that efficient estimation “require tailoring for each m-DAG and recoverable parameter and have not commonly been used”. The focus of this paper is on estimating average causal effects when both exposure and potential confounders may be partially observed. We begin with one of several assumptions about the missingness mechanism(s): besides a MAR assumption, we propose several variations of the outcome-independence assumption. Motivated by the NHANES analysis, the proposed MNAR assumptions permit missingness in the exposure—opioid prescription—to depend on missing potential confounders and the missing exposure itself, and allows shared unmeasured common causes between these aforementioned variables. Importantly, none of the assumptions restrict the types of outcomes allowed. Under each set of assumptions, we derive identifying formulae, and corresponding influence functions under a nonparametric model. We show that standard MI (e.g., Joint Multivariate Normal MI, Fully Conditional Specification MI) yields valid estimates when data are MAR but can be biased otherwise. For each of the MNAR assumptions, we propose targeted maximum likelihood estimators (TMLE) that are doubly robust, allowing misspecification of either (i) the outcome models or (ii) the exposure and missingness models. 2. Setup: Causal estimand and assumptions Suppose we collect n fully observed, independent and identically distributed observations. Under this setting, let Y denote an outcome of interest, A an exposure variable taking values in \mathbb{N} , and L a vector of potential confounders. For ease of exposition, we assume throughout that the outcome Y is binary and the covariates L are discrete, but methods described herein are