Avatars and Environments for Meetings in Social VR: What Styles and Choices Matter to People in Group Creativity Tasks? CCS: Human-centered computing Virtual reality CCS: Human-centered computing Collaborative interaction CCS: Human-centered computing Mixed / augmented reality CCS: Human-centered co

Anya Osborne, Sabrina Fielder, Lee Taber, Tara Lamb, Joshua McVeigh-Schultz, Katherine Isbister · 2025

Read Avatars and Environments for Meetings in Social VR: What Styles and Choices Matter to People in Group Creativity Tasks? CCS: Human-centered computing Virtual reality CCS: Human-centered computing Collaborative interaction CCS: Human-centered computing Mixed / augmented reality CCS: Human-centered co by Anya Osborne, Sabrina Fielder, Lee Taber, Tara Lamb, Joshua McVeigh-Schultz, Katherine Isbister (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-21780.txt.

Introduction

Anya Osborne and five co-authors study meetings in social virtual reality in a twenty twenty-five paper. After the pandemic, many teams meet by video call, and social VR offers a more shared feel. The team asks which avatar styles and which virtual rooms help groups do creative work.

Two studies build on each other, both on the Mozilla Hubs platform. The first asked eighty-seven people what avatar and room traits they prefer for varied meeting types. The second put forty people in pairs, as avatars in headsets, to do creative tasks in distinct settings. The results guide how avatar looks and room design shape teamwork.

Catalog record

CREATORAnya Osborne, Sabrina Fielder, Lee Taber, Tara Lamb, Joshua McVeigh-Schultz, Katherine Isbister
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE85 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-21780

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Avatars and Environments for Meetings in Social VR: What Styles and Choices Matter to People in Group Creativity Tasks? CCS: Human-centered computing Virtual reality CCS: Human-centered computing Collaborative interaction CCS: Human-centered computing Mixed / augmented reality CCS: Human-centered computing Scenario-based design CCS: Human-centered computing User studies Anya Osborne, Sabrina Fielder, Lee Taber, Tara Lamb, Joshua McVeigh-Schultz, Katherine Isbister Abstract . Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, many professional entities shifted toward remote collaboration and video conferencing (VC) tools. Social virtual reality (VR) platforms present an alternative to VC for meetings and collaborative activities. Well-crafted social VR environments could enhance feelings of co-presence and togetherness at meetings, helping reduce the need for carbon-intensive travel to face-to-face meetings. This research contributes to creating meeting tools in VR by exploring the effects of avatar styles and virtual environments on groups’ creative performance using the Mozilla Hubs platform. We present the results of two sequential studies. Study One surveys avatar and environment preferences in various VR meeting contexts (N=87). Study Two applies these findings to the design of a between-subjects and within-subjects research where participants (N=40) perform creativity tasks in pairs as embodied avatars in different virtual settings using VR headsets. We discuss the design implications of avatar appearances and meeting settings on teamwork. 1. Introduction As technology progresses, so does the way we work, communicate, and solve problems. As a consequence of the COVID-19 pandemic, the shift to video conferencing (VC) technologies significantly contributed to the viability of virtual work at a large scale ( Brucks and Levav 2022 ) . Social Virtual Reality (VR) has shown a tremendous increase in the commercial market as an emerging technology for rich embodied interactions, relationship building, leisure, and work activities ( Handley et al. 2022 ) . Unlike VC software, the commercial increase of social VR has been driven by the capacity of embodied awareness ( Smith and Neff 2018 ) , including a heightened experience of social presence ( Bailenson et al. 2004 ; Yoon et al. 2019 ; Steinicke et al. 2020 ) or the feeling of “being there” ( Heeter 1992 ; Lombard and Ditton 1997 ) with other people in a shared virtual environment. Social VR can even enable new forms of social augmentation ( Freeman and Maloney 2021 ; Maloney et al. 2020b ; Moustafa and Steed 2018 ; Roth et al. 2019 ) that exceed what is possible in face-to-face contexts ( Roth et al. 2018 ; Roth et al. 2019 ; McVeigh-Schultz and Isbister 2021a ; McVeigh-Schultz and Isbister 2021b ; McVeigh-Schultz et al. 2021 ; Isbister et al. 2022 ) . In our larger research agenda, we propose creating novel design interventions in social VR that can unleash new collective human capacities and establish new grounds for effective collaboration and social connection in VR meetings. This research focuses on the specific workplace task of creative ideation as a crucial workplace activity in social VR. We concentrate on creative ideation as it is fundamental to scientific and commercial innovation at workplace meetings ( Handley et al. 2022 ; Salter and Gann 2003 ) . Recent studies on virtual teams found that VC groups generate less creative ideas than in-person groups because of the ‘narrowed visual focus’ ( Brucks and Levav 2022 ) and that immersive virtual environments where people are presented as avatars contribute to enhancing creative collaboration among distributed teams ( Le et al. 2017 ; Guegan et al. 2016 ; Buisine et al. 2016 ; Bourgeois-Bougrine et al. 2020 ; Toumi et al. 2021 ; Kohler et al. 2009 ; Riordan and O’Reilly 2011 ; Guegan et al. 2017a ) . Prior research empirically and neurologically relates narrowed visual and cognitive focus induced by VC to a constrained associative process inherent to idea generation ( Friedman et al. 2003 ; Posner 2011 ; Rowe et al. 2007 ) , where thoughts diverge into many to be then assimilated and transformed into new creative ideas ( Mednick 1962 ; Nijstad and Stroebe 2006 ; Jung et al. 2013 ) . Experimental studies in 3D virtual worlds like Second Life demonstrated that the embodiment of avatars, perceived as creative, enhances brainstorming performance ( Guegan et al. 2017b ; Buisine et al. 2016 ; Buisine and Guegan 2020 ; Bhagwatwar et al. 2013 ; Peña and Blackburn 2013 ; Vosinakis and Koutsabasis 2013 ) , particularly in the fluency and novelty of generated ideas ( Guegan et al. 2016 ) . Furthermore, deliberate choices of visual and contextual cues to prime creative thinking in these worlds were shown to further augment team performance, outperforming simulations of traditional office settings ( Peña and Blackburn 2013 ; Bhagwatwar et al. 2013 ) . These findings were complemented by recent work on remote collaboration in social VR (Spatial.io), underscoring the role of spatial and embodied interaction in fostering creative thinking among coral scientists over a 1-2 month period during work meetings ( Olaosebikan et al. 2022 ) . Cumulatively, these studies advocate for avatar-mediated brainstorming in multi-user VR as a potent tool for creativity support ( Toumi et al. 2021 ) and improved behavioral, emotional, and social engagement, compared to traditional methods ( Yang et al. 2018 ; Guan et al. 2021 ; Lee et al. 2019 ) . If social VR ultimately closes the gap between VC and face-to-face interaction, the question arises whether this new medium could productively supplant in-person collaborative ideation. However, realistic avatars often invoke decreased affinity and increased unease ( Shin et al. 2019 ; Seymour et al. 2021 ) due to the uncanny valley effect ( Schwind 2018 ; Mori et al. 2012 ; Waltemate et al. 2018 ) , while cartoon-style avatars raise concerns about professional appropriateness ( Bailenson and Beall 2006 ; Inkpen and Sedlins 2011 ; Junuzovic et al. 2012 ) . In HCI research on VR, few have examined the symbiotic relationship between avatar styles and virtual environments in meeting scenarios, with some notable exceptions ( Williamson et al. 2021 ; Williamson et al. 2022 ; McVeigh-Schultz et al. 2019 ) . Our research aims to fill this gap by examining these aspects within the Mozilla Hubs platform. We situated our research in Mozilla Hubs due to its widespread adoption in academic and remote research contexts ( Bredikhina et al. 2020 ; El Ali et al. 2021 ; Eriksson 2021 ; Williamson et al. 2021 ; Yoshimura and Borst 2020 ; Gomes de Siqueira et al. 2021 ; Ratcliffe et al. 2021 ; Williamson et al. 2021 ; Williamson et al. 2022 ; Maloney et al. 2020a ; Li et al. 2022 ; Sanchez et al. 2024 ) . Moreover, its device compatibility and shared link invitation model ( Osborne et al. 2023 ; Osborne 2024 ) facilitate rapid, seamless entry into virtual spaces ( McVeigh-Schultz et al. 2019 ; Osborne et al. 2019 ) , serving requirements for our research objectives. This paper undertakes a two-fold research approach within the Mozilla Hubs platform to explore avatar and environment impacts on creative VR collaboration. Study One, a survey, identifies preferred avatars and settings in Mozilla Hubs for varied meeting contexts. Study Two applies these preferences in a between-and-within-subjects investigation where participants undertake creative

Read the complete text