Optical Strong Line Ratios Cannot Distinguish Between Stellar Populations and Accreting Black Holes at High Ionization Parameters and Low Metallicities Astropy ( Astropy Collaboration et al. 2013 ) , NumPy C. R. Harris et al. 2020 , Matplotlib ( J. D. Hunter 2007 )
Nikko J. Cleri, Grace M. Olivier, Bren E. Backhaus, Joel Leja, Casey Papovich, Jonathan R. Trump, Pablo Arrabal Haro, Véronique Buat, Denis Burgarella, Emilie Burnham, Antonello Calabrò, Jonathan H. Cohn, Justin W. Cole, Kelcey Davis, Mark Dickinson, Steven L. Finkelstein, Ray Garner, III, Michaela · 2025
Read Optical Strong Line Ratios Cannot Distinguish Between Stellar Populations and Accreting Black Holes at High Ionization Parameters and Low Metallicities Astropy ( Astropy Collaboration et al. 2013 ) , NumPy C. R. Harris et al. 2020 , Matplotlib ( J. D. Hunter 2007 ) by Nikko J. Cleri, Grace M. Olivier, Bren E. Backhaus, Joel Leja, Casey Papovich, Jonathan R. Trump, Pablo Arrabal Haro, Véronique Buat, Denis Burgarella, Emilie Burnham, Antonello Calabrò, Jonathan H. Cohn, Justin W. Cole, Kelcey Davis, Mark Dickinson, Steven L. Finkelstein, Ray Garner, III, Michaela (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-21660.txt.
Introduction
Nikko Cleri and a large team asked whether light line ratios can tell young stars from feeding black holes in distant galaxies in a 2025 paper. Telescopes now see such galaxies at high redshift, where the classic ratio tests were not built to work. Sorting the two light sources matters for counting black holes and star birth.
The team ran a large grid of cloud models lit by stars or by black holes, varying age, metal content, density, and more. In the three classic diagrams, position turned out to hinge on ionization level and metal content more than on the light source. At high ionization and low metals, the two model families overlap heavily. One diagram let many star-lit models fall in the black hole zone. The authors urge care with early-universe spectra.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nikko J. Cleri, Grace M. Olivier, Bren E. Backhaus, Joel Leja, Casey Papovich, Jonathan R. Trump, Pablo Arrabal Haro, Véronique Buat, Denis Burgarella, Emilie Burnham, Antonello Calabrò, Jonathan H. Cohn, Justin W. Cole, Kelcey Davis, Mark Dickinson, Steven L. Finkelstein, Ray Garner, III, Michaela |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 59 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-21660
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Optical Strong Line Ratios Cannot Distinguish Between Stellar Populations and Accreting Black Holes at High Ionization Parameters and Low Metallicities Astropy ( Astropy Collaboration et al. 2013 ) , NumPy C. R. Harris et al. 2020 , Matplotlib ( J. D. Hunter 2007 ) Nikko J. Cleri, Grace M. Olivier, Bren E. Backhaus, Joel Leja, Casey Papovich, Jonathan R. Trump, Pablo Arrabal Haro, Véronique Buat, Denis Burgarella, Emilie Burnham, Antonello Calabrò, Jonathan H. Cohn, Justin W. Cole, Kelcey Davis, Mark Dickinson, Steven L. Finkelstein, Ray Garner, III, Michaela Hirschmann, Weida Hu, Taylor A. Hutchison, Dale D. Kocevski, Anton M. Koekemoer, Rebecca L. Larson, Zach J. Lewis, Michael V. Maseda, Lise-Marie Seillé, Raymond C. Simons Abstract High-redshift observations from JWST indicate that optical strong line ratios do not carry the same constraining power as they do at low redshifts. Critically, this prevents a separation between stellar- and black hole-driven ionizing radiation, thereby obscuring both active galactic nuclei demographics and star formation rates. To investigate this, we compute a large suite of photoionization models from Cloudy powered by stellar populations and accreting black holes over a large grid of ages, metallicities, initial mass functions, binarity, ionization parameters, densities, and black hole masses. We use these models to test three rest-frame optical strong line ratio diagnostics which have been designed to separate ionizing sources at low redshifts ( z ≲ 2 z\lesssim 2 ): the [N II] -BPT, VO87, and OHNO diagrams. We show that the position of a model in these diagrams is strongly driven by the ionization parameter (log U) and the gas-phase metallicity ( Z gas ), often more so than the ionizing spectrum itself; in particular, there is significant overlap between stellar population and accreting black hole models at high log U and low Z gas . We show that the OHNO diagram is especially susceptible to large contamination of the AGN region defined at z ∼ 1 z\sim 1 for stellar models with high log U and low Z gas , consistent with many observed JWST spectra at high redshift. We show that the optical line ratio diagnostics are most sensitive to the shape of the < < 54 eV ionizing continuum, and that the derived ionizing sources for a given set of optical strong line ratios can be highly degenerate. Finally, we demonstrate that very high ionization (>54 eV) emission lines that trace ionizing sources harder than normal stellar populations help to break the degeneracies present when using the strong line diagnostics alone, even in gas conditions consistent with those at high redshifts. I Introduction Reliably identifying the sources of ionizing photons is critical to properly interpreting observations of galaxies, especially at high redshifts now accessible with JWST . Misattributed emission from accreting black holes can be responsible for orders of magnitude discrepancies of derived quantities such as star formation rates and stellar masses ( J. Brinchmann et al. 2004 ; H. Netzer et al. 2007 ; D. J. Rosario et al. 2013 ; R. L. Davies et al. 2014b ; R. L. Davies et al. 2014a ; D. J. Rosario et al. 2015 ; T. T. Shimizu et al. 2015 ; M. Magliocchetti et al. 2016 ; S. L. Ellison et al. 2016 ; L. M. Cairós et al. 2022 ; B. Wang et al. 2024 ; B. Wang et al. 2025 ; M. Siudek et al. 2025 ; S. Berger et al. 2025 , e.g.,) . There exist many different methods for constraining the presence a luminous accreting black hole; objects for which the data support the presence of a luminous accreting black hole are referred to as “active” (or “active galactic nuclei”; AGN), and those for which the data do not have sufficient evidence are referred to as “inactive” or “star forming”. These methods are thought to be highly dependent on viewing angle ( C. M. Urry & P. Padovani 1995 , e.g.,) , and range across the electromagnetic spectrum from detections of high-energy photons in the X-ray regime ( Y. Q. Xue et al. 2011 ; Y. Q. Xue et al. 2016 ; B. Luo et al. 2017 , e.g.,) , to synchrotron emission in the radio ( T. M. Heckman & P. N. Best 2014 ; P. Padovani et al. 2017 , e.g.,) . In the infrared, photometric selections have long been used to distinguish between accreting supermassive black holes and star-forming galaxies by tracing emission from hot dust largely associated with AGN ( M. Lacy et al. 2004 ; J. L. Donley et al. 2012 ; D. Stern et al. 2005 ; A. Kirkpatrick et al. 2017 ; A. Kirkpatrick et al. 2023 , e.g.,) . Rest-frame optical diagnostics of ionizing sources are among the most widely used, largely due to the development of instruments designed to target rest-frame optical spectroscopy at various redshifts ( D. G. York et al. 2000 ; I. S. McLean et al. 2012 ; P. Jakobsen et al. 2022 , e.g.,) . Emission lines from permitted transitions, most commonly the Balmer lines, with broad profiles (FWHM \gtrsim 1000~\mathrm{km~s}^{-1} ) trace the dense, rapidly moving gas which is predominantly associated with the broad line region around a black hole, and are common diagnostic tools given the lack of other known physical conditions to produce such signatures ( D. E. Osterbrock & W. G. Mathews 1986 ; J. W. Sulentic et al. 2000 ; G. Kauffmann et al. 2003 ; J. R. Trump et al. 2011 , e.g.) . The diagnostics that we focus on for the remainder of this work are those based on intensity ratios of rest-frame optical emission lines. Emission line ratios have been used to classify ionizing sources for several decades; early studies used only a single emission line ratio (e.g., \hbox{[{O~III}]}~\lambda 5008 / H \beta ) to characterize a source as a star forming region or host of an accreting black hole ( L. Searle 1971 ; H. E. Smith 1975 ; D. Alloin et al. 1978 ; J. M. Shuder & D. E. Osterbrock 1981 , e.g.,) . However, it was quickly shown that this one-dimensional determination was insufficient for separating Seyfert 2s from intense starburst galaxies or shock heating ( T. M. Heckman 1980 ; J. A. Baldwin et al. 1981 ; V. A. Balzano 1983 ; W. C. Keel 1983 ; D. E. Osterbrock & R. W. Pogge 1985 , e.g.,) . The addition of a second dimension with another emission line ratio led to the ‘‘BPT’’ diagrams 1 1 1 Colloquially, the terms “BPT” or “BPT-style/BPT-like” have been used to refer to any emission line ratio diagnostics used to separate ionizing sources. For clarity, we will refer to each of the three diagrams studied in this work explicitly; the [O III] / H \beta versus [N II] / H \alpha diagram as the “ [N II] -BPT” diagram, the [O III] / H \beta versus [S II] / H \alpha diagram as the “VO87” diagram, and the [O III] / H \beta versus [Ne III] / [O II] diagram as the “OHNO” diagram. , which compared \hbox{[{O~III}]}~\lambda 5008 / H \beta to \hbox{[{N~II}]}~\lambda 6585 / H \alpha or \hbox{[{O~I}]}~\lambda 6302 / H \alpha ( J. A. Baldwin et al.