Morphisms on the modular curve X 0 ( p ) X_{0}(p) and degree 6 6 points
Maarten Derickx, Petar Orlić · 2025
Read Morphisms on the modular curve X 0 ( p ) X_{0}(p) and degree 6 6 points by Maarten Derickx, Petar Orlić (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-21166.txt.
Introduction
Maarten Derickx and Petar Orlic study maps between special curves tied to whole-number math in a 2025 paper. The curves, called modular curves, code deep facts about number patterns. They ask when a map from one such curve to a curve with rich shape must be the one standard map that all expect.
For all prime levels below 3,000, they prove that any such map of degree past one is that standard map. Strong signs hint the same holds for all primes, and they state that guess in full. The result lets them sort all low-degree points on these curves that come from such maps. One open prime case for degree six is named.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Maarten Derickx, Petar Orlić |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 48 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-21166
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Morphisms on the modular curve X 0 ( p ) X_{0}(p) and degree 6 6 points Maarten Derickx, Petar Orlić Abstract . Let p p be a prime. We study the morphisms f : X 0 ( p ) ℚ → Y f:X_{0}(p)_{\mathbb{Q}}\to Y , where Y / ℚ Y/\mathbb{Q} is a curve of genus ≥ 2 \geq 2 . We prove that for p < 3000 p<3000 such an f f must be isomorphic to the quotient map X 0 ( p ) → X 0 + ( p ) X_{0}(p)\to X_{0}^{+}(p) . This allows us to classify all points of degree ≤ 25 \leq 25 on X 0 ( p ) X_{0}(p) that come from a map to some curve of genus ≥ 2 \geq 2 . As an application, we were able to determine all curves X 0 ( p ) X_{0}(p) with infinitely many points of degree 6 6 over ℚ \mathbb{Q} , continuing the previous results on small degree points on X 0 ( N ) X_{0}(N) . 1991 Mathematics Subject Classification 11G18, 11G30, 14H30, 14H51 1. Introduction Morphisms X_{0}(N)\to Y defined over number fields are an important topic in arithmetic geometry and have been the subject of extensive research. Let us first discuss the case when g(Y)=0 and Y is isomorphic to \mathbb{P}^{1} . Let C be a smooth projective curve over a field k . The k -gonality of C , denoted by \textup{gon}_{k}C , is the least degree of a non-constant k -rational morphism f:C\to\mathbb{P}^{1} . Thus, determining the gonality of X_{0}(N) is very important if one wants to study morphisms X_{0}(N)\to\mathbb{P}^{1} . The gonality of modular curves has been extensively studied. Zograf [ 36 ] gave a lower bound for the \mathbb{C} -gonality for any modular curve X(\Gamma) , linear in terms of the index of the corresponding congruence subgroup \Gamma . Later, Abramovich [ 1 ] and Kim and Sarnak [ 26 , Appendix 2] improved the constant in that lower bound. Moreover, there are upper bounds on the gonality of any algebraic curve in terms of its genus g , see [ 31 , Proposition A.1] . Regarding the curve X_{0}(N) , Ogg [ 30 ] determined all hyperelliptic, Bars [ 3 ] determined all bielliptic, Hasegawa and Shimura [ 17 ] determined all trigonal curves X_{0}(N) over \mathbb{C} and \mathbb{Q} , and Jeon and Park [ 22 ] determined all tetragonal curves X_{0}(N) over \mathbb{C} . Najman and Orlić [ 28 ] determined all curves X_{0}(N) with \mathbb{Q} -gonality equal to 4,5, or 6 . They also determined the \mathbb{Q} -gonality of all curves X_{0}(N) for N\leq 144 and for many of those curves also determined their \mathbb{C} -gonality. Let us now consider the case when g(Y)=1 and Y=E is an elliptic curve. Determining all possible degrees of morphisms to E is useful when searching for small degree points because the only curves with infinitely many rational points are those of genus 0 isomorphic to \mathbb{P}^{1} and positive rank elliptic curves. If one wants to determine all possible degrees of rational morphisms X_{0}(N)\to E , there are two cases with respect to the conductor of E : \textup{cond}(E)=N and \textup{cond}(E)<N . The case \textup{Cond}(E)=N is easier and can be dealt with using the Modularity theorem. Theorem 1.1 (Modularity theorem) . Let E/\mathbb{Q} be an elliptic curve of conductor N . Then there exists a non-constant rational morphism f:X_{0}(N)\to E . Furthermore, if f has the least possible degree, then any other morphism g:X_{0}(N)\to E factors through f . Therefore, all rational morphisms X_{0}(N)\to E are of the form [d]\circ f for some d\in\mathbb{Z} . This holds even for CM curves because the extra endomorphisms are not defined over \mathbb{Q} . The case \textup{cond}(E)<N is more involved. Derickx and Orlić [ 13 , Proposition 1.10] gave a method to compute all possible degrees of rational morphisms X_{0}(N)\to E if E has positive rank. This paper focuses on the case when g(Y)\geq 2 . A useful result here is the De Franchis-Severi theorem. Theorem 1.2 (De Franchis-Severi) . Let X be a compact Riemann surface of genus g\geq 2 . Then the following two statements hold: (a) For a fixed compact Riemann surface Y of genus \geq 2 , the number of non-constant holomorphic maps X\to Y is finite. (b) There are only finitely many compact Riemann surfaces Y of genus \geq 2 which admit a non-constant holomorphic map from X . This is an opposite situation from the genus 0 or 1 case where there can be infinitely many morphisms to \mathbb{P}^{1} or an elliptic curve. Therefore, it makes sense to try to determine possible morphisms from a fixed curve X to a curve of genus \geq 2 , especially if X is a modular curve. Baker, González-Jiménez, González and Poonen [ 2 ] consider the maps from X_{0}(N) and X_{1}(N) to hyperelliptic curves and it is natural to try extending their results by considering the maps to non-hyperelliptic curves. In this paper we study the modular curve X_{0}(p) for p prime. The reason for considering only the prime levels is that the arguments become simpler and more computable. For example, all simple factors A\subseteq J_{0}(p) occur with multiplicity 1 and are associated with newforms. We prove the following two results. Theorem 1.3 . Let p<3000 be a prime and let Y be a nice (smooth, projective, and geometrically integral) curve over \mathbb{Q} of genus \geq 2 . Suppose that f:X_{0}(p)\to Y is a non-constant morphism of degree d>1 defined over \mathbb{Q} . Then f is isomorphic to the quotient map X_{0}(p)\to X_{0}^{+}(p) . Theorem 1.4 . Let p be a prime and let J_{0}(p) be the Jacobian of the curve X_{0}(p) . If J_{0}(p) is isogenous to A^{+}\oplus A^{-}\oplus A with A^{+}\subseteq J_{0}(p)^{+} , A^{-}\subseteq J_{0}(p)^{-} being simple abelian varieties and A\subseteq J_{0}(p) such that \dim A\leq 2 , then, up to isomorphism, the quotient map X_{0}(p)\to X_{0}(p)^{+} is the only non-constant rational morphism of degree d>1 from X_{0}(p) to a curve of genus \geq 2 . Numerically, it seems that Theorem 1.4 is applicable for a majority of prime levels p . Indeed, by analyzing the data computed in [ 5 ] (also available on LMFDB [ 27 ] ) and [ 8 , Section 9] it follows that it is applicable for 77636 out of the 78498 primes below 1,000,000 ( \approx 98.9\% ). Furthermore, we also computed this percentage for all primes below B for several B<1,000,000 and this seems to suggest that this percentage is slowly climbing to 100\% . Motivated by Theorem 1.3 and Theorem 1.4 , we state the following conjecture. Conjecture 1.5 . Let p be a prime. Then, up to isomorphism, the quotient map X_{0}(p)\to X_{0}(p)^{+} is the only non-constant rational morphism of degree d>1 from X_{0}(p) to a curve of genus \geq 2 . There are two reasons we think why 1.5 is true. First, the number of A\subseteq J_{0}(p) not ruled out by Corollary 3.4 becomes more sparse with larger values of p . Second, the computational results of [ 8 ] show that it is very rare for curves X_{0}(p)