Anharmonic phonons via quantum thermal bath simulations

T. Baird, R. Vuilleumier, S. Bonella · 2025

Read Anharmonic phonons via quantum thermal bath simulations by T. Baird, R. Vuilleumier, S. Bonella (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-21139.txt.

Introduction

Taylor Baird, Rodolphe Vuilleumier, and Sara Bonella published a computational physics paper in 2025 on lattice vibrations. Vibrations, or phonons, reveal a material's heat and light behavior. Light atoms and cold conditions add strong quantum effects. Including those effects in simulations is usually very expensive.

The authors combine two methods to cut that cost. A quantum thermal bath adds nuclear quantum effects cheaply. A newer correlator method then extracts vibration frequencies from the motion data. Together they give phonon patterns across a crystal. Tests began with simple one-dimensional systems. The team then applied the scheme to solid neon. They report strong efficiency and accuracy, with clear limits noted.

Catalog record

CREATORT. Baird, R. Vuilleumier, S. Bonella
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE52 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-21139

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Anharmonic phonons via quantum thermal bath simulations T. Baird, R. Vuilleumier, S. Bonella Abstract Lattice vibrations within crystalline solids, or phonons, provide information on a variety of important material characteristics, from thermal qualities to optical properties and phase transition behaviour. When the material contains light ions, or is subjected to sufficiently low temperatures and/or high pressures, anharmonic and nuclear quantum effects (NQEs) may significantly alter its phonon characteristics. Unfortunately, accurate inclusion of these two effects within numerical simulations typically incurs a substantial computational cost. In this work, we present a novel approach which promises to mitigate this problem. The scheme leverages the recently introduced quantum correlators approach for the extraction of anharmonic phonon frequencies from molecular dynamics data. To account for NQEs without excessive increase of the computational cost, we include nuclear quantum effects via the quantum thermal bath (QTB) method. This is the first full exploration of the use of QTB for the calculation of phonon dispersion relations. We demonstrate the noteworthy efficiency and accuracy of the scheme, and analyze its upsides and drawbacks by first considering 1-dimensional systems, and then the physically interesting case of solid neon. I Introduction Phonons, the quantized vibrations of a crystal lattice, are fundamental to understanding a wide range of material properties. Their behavior influences diverse physical characteristics, spanning from heat transport and mechanical stability to electronic interactions and optical responses ashcroft1976solid ; srivastava2022physics . Analyzing phonon dynamics provides key insights into thermal phenomena such as heat capacity, expansion, and conductivity ziman2001electrons , as well as structural attributes like elasticity, shear moduli, and phase stability baroni2001phonons ; born1955dynamical . Furthermore, phonons play a critical role in optical properties—governing infrared absorption and Raman scattering cardona1982light — while also affecting electronic properties, including bandgap modulation and electron-phonon interactions giustino2017electron . Phonons also contribute to more exotic phenomena such as thermoelectric performance and even superconductivity tinkham2004introduction ; togo2015first . In this article, we present a method for calculating the lattice vibrational properties of crystalline solids that enables one to account for nuclear quantum effects (NQEs) and anharmonicity beyond the level of perturbation theory. The approach consists of sequentially performing molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, extended to include (approximately) NQEs, followed by a post-processing procedure that utilizes the harvested MD trajectories to extract phonon spectra. As demonstrated by the illustrative application to solid neon, this scheme accurately captures non-trivial effects. Furthermore, its relatively low numerical cost permits one to increase the system size and temporal duration of the simulations. Several methods can currently be employed to carry out calculations of phonon spectra in solids. The most traditional of these approaches is density functional perturbation theory (DFPT) baroni2001phonons , which accesses phonon frequencies through interatomic force constant matrices. DFPT computes these matrices via a perturbative approach that approximates second derivatives of the total energy, hence falling under the class of harmonic approximations. A related, but arguably less sophisticated technique is the frozen phonon method (also referred to as the small displacement method or supercells approach) which approximates these energy Hessians via finite-differences weyrich1990frozen ; alfe2009phon ; van2002effect . Both of these methods are only strictly valid at zero kelvin and for classical systems, or for atoms with large mass, where nuclear quantum effects such as zero-point motion can be neglected. To go beyond this, accounting for the anharmonic effects that come into play at finite temperatures and enabling a quantum mechanical treatment of the ions, a diversity of alternative approaches have been proposed. These include the self-consistent harmonic approximation hooton1955li (SCHA) and its stochastic extension SSCHA errea2014anharmonic ; bianco2017second , self-consistent ab-initio lattice dynamics (SCAILD) souvatzis2008entropy , and the self-consistent phonon method werthamer1970self ; tadano2015self (SCP). These methods are based on variational principles and optimize self-consistently a trial Hamiltonian with respect to phonon modes and internal degrees of freedom of the crystalline system. All of them either rely on perturbation theory in order to include anharmonic effects, or assume the possibility of fitting the true anharmonic potential energy surface to an effective harmonic potential. If either of these assumptions are invalid, then these strategies run into difficulties. Alternatively, there are a family of methods that utilize molecular dynamics to characterize the lattice vibrations of crystalline systems. Such MD simulations are typically ab initio (AIMD) in nature, though the use of machine-learned potentials is becoming more prevalent in the literature. The temperature-dependent effective potential (TDEP) method belongs to this category of approaches hellman2011lattice . In TDEP, AIMD trajectories are generated, and the resulting forces are used to determine the optimal harmonic force constants. These force constants are determined by minimizing the difference between the calculated DFT forces and those predicted by a model harmonic Hamiltonian, typically using a least-squares procedure, which provides the criterion for optimality. Molecular dynamics trajectories are also at the core of the recently introduced quantum correlators (QC) approach of Ref. ( 20 ) , which allows one to capture all orders of anharmonicity without any underlying assumptions limiting the systematic improvement of the treatment. The approach, originally developed for finite temperature calculations of generalised normal modes for classical systems, has lately been generalised to path integral molecular dynamics (PIMD) rpmd , thus accessing essentially exact sampling of the underlying quantum Boltzmann distribution and including quantum effects in the phonon spectrum. The issue with using PIMD to incorporate nuclear quantum effects is, however, the increased numerical cost it incurs which, recent progress notwithstanding ceriotti2012efficient ; brieuc2016quantum ; ceriotti2009nuclear ; markland2008efficient ; ceriotti2011accelerating ; buxton2017accelerated ; marsalek2016ab ; fletcher2021fast ; musil2022quantum , may still remain problematic. To circumvent this computational expense, in this work we have adapted the QC scheme to take advantage of a recently proposed method for approximate sampling of the quantum distribution of the nuclei, namely the quantum thermal bath (QTB) qtb . This is, to the best of our knowledge, the first time QTB has been applied to the full study of phonon dispersions (although it has been employed to assess isotope effects in LiH and LiD crystals where the authors also explored phonon densities of state dammak2012isotope ). The non-trivial exploratory calculations presented here provide the groundwork for future use of QTB to investigate phonon properties in quantum crystals. II Methods II.1 Quantum anharmonic phonons via Kubo correlators In Ref. ( 20 ) a new approach to compute anharmonic phonon spectra including quantum nuclear effects within the path integral formalism was proposed. The method determines the matrix of principal modes, Y , and the characteristic frequencies, \omega_{FF}^{2} , of the system by solving the following generalized eigenvalue problem (GEV): \left[\langle\langle\bm{\mathsf{F}}\bm{\mathsf{F}}^{T}\rangle\rangle\right]_{i_{1}i_{2}}Y_{i_{2}i_{3}}=\omega_{FF,i_{3}}^{2}\left[\langle\langle\bm{\mathsf{p}}\bm{\mathsf{p}}^{T}\rangle\rangle\right]_{i_{1}i_{2}}Y_{i_{2}i_{3}} (1) where i_{1},i_{2},i_{3} are atomic indexes, \bm{\mathsf{F}} are forces and \bm{\mathsf{p}} momenta. The double bracket indicates that Kubo correlations are to be used. The Kubo correlation of A and B is defined as K_{AB}=\langle\langle AB\rangle\rangle=\frac{1}{\beta Q}\int_{0}^{\beta}d\lambda\mathrm{Tr}\left[e^{-(\beta-\lambda)H}Ae^{-\lambda H}B\right] (2) where H is the Hamiltonian, \beta=1/k_{B}T ( k_{B} is the Boltzmann constant and T the temperature), and Q=\mathrm{Tr}\left[e^{-\beta H}\right] is the partition function. Use of Kubo correlators ensures, in particular, that \beta\langle\langle\bm{\mathsf{F}}\bm{\mathsf{F}}^{T}\rangle\rangle is an estimator of the Hessian of the Hamiltonian, i.e. the dynamical matrix, and that \langle\langle\bm{\mathsf{p}}\bm{\mathsf{p}}^{T}\rangle\rangle is diagonal and an estimator of mk_{B}T . Furthermore, the diagonal nature of the Kubo correlation for momenta ensures that the principal mode matrices are unitary in

Read the complete text